Israeli Lawmakers Weigh Recognizing Armenian Genocide

ISRAELI LAWMAKERS WEIGH RECOGNIZING ARMENIAN GENOCIDE
Jeffrey Heller

Chicago Tribune
,0,4894608.story
Dec 26 2011

JERUSALEM (Reuters) – Israeli lawmakers debated on Monday recognizing
the 1915 mass killing of Armenians by Ottoman Turks as genocide but
were warned by the Foreign Ministry about further damage to frayed
relations with Turkey.

The issue has stirred deep emotions in Israel, where some legislators
have said the Jewish people, who suffered six million dead in the
Nazi Holocaust, have a moral obligation to identify with the Armenian
tragedy, even at the risk of a Turkish backlash.

No decision was taken by parliament’s Education and Culture Committee,
which said it would hold another session at a future date.

“I can say that at this time, recognition of this type can have very
grave strategic implications,” said Irit Lillian, a Foreign Ministry
official who addressed the forum.

“Our relations with Turkey today are so fragile and so delicate that
there is no place to take them over the red line, where we have been,
I’m sorry to say, for many months,” she said.

Ties between the two former strategic allies were strained by Israel’s
killing of nine Turks in a commando raid on a Gaza-bound ship in 2010.

Turkey withdrew its ambassador to Israel after the incident and
suspended military cooperation.

Israel said its marines acted in self-defense after an initial boarding
party was attacked.

Zahava Gal-On, a lawmaker from the left-wing Meretz party, said Israeli
governments have refused to define the 1915 killings as genocide
“for cynical, strategic and economic, reasons, connected to ties
with Turkey.”

Israel, she said, has a “moral and historical obligation … to
recognize the genocide of the Armenian people” and ensure the subject
is taught comprehensively in its schools.

The committee session was the first public parliamentary hearing on
the issue.

Last week, Turkey cancelled all economic, political and military
meetings with its NATO partner France after the French National
Assembly voted overwhelmingly in favor of a draft law outlawing
genocide denial.

Armenia, backed by many historians and parliaments, says about 1.5
million Christian Armenians were killed in what is now eastern Turkey
during World War One in a deliberate policy of genocide ordered by
the Ottoman government.

Successive Turkish governments and the vast majority of Turks feel the
charge of genocide is an insult to their nation. Ankara argues that
there was heavy loss of life on both sides during fighting in the area.

(Editing by Myra MacDonald)

http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/sns-rt-us-israel-turkey-armeniatre7bp0es-20111226

AFP: Israel Lawmakers Debate Recognising Armenia Genocide

ISRAEL LAWMAKERS DEBATE RECOGNISING ARMENIA GENOCIDE

Agence France Presse
Dec 26 2011

JERUSALEM – An Israeli parliamentary committee held a landmark
discussion on recognising genocide in Armenia on Monday, a move likely
to further strain already tense relations with Turkey.

During the discussion on the “Jewish people’s recognition of the
Armenian genocide,” as defined by the committee, lawmakers, historians
and members of the local Armenian community stressed Israel’s moral
obligation to officially recognise the Armenian tragedy as a genocide.

The committee did not, however, make any decisions or issue any
declaration, and will meet again on the issue in the future.

In past years, the Knesset held hearings on the subject, but only
behind the closed doors of its foreign and defence committee.

This was the first time such a discussion was open to the public.

Proposals by lawmakers to hold hearings on the issue were rejected
by governments over the years, when ties between Israel and Turkey
were warm.

But relations plunged into deep crisis last year when Israeli forces
killed nine Turks in a raid on a Turkish ferry, part of an activist
flotilla seeking to breach Israel’s naval blockade of Gaza.

In October, Turkey expelled the Israeli ambassador and axed military
ties and defence trade. Last week, Israel cancelled completion of a
2008 contract to sell Turkey aerial surveillance equipment.

Committee chairman Alex Miller of the nationalist Yisrael Beiteinu —
the party headed by Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman — said the
discussion would focus on the “educational and academic” aspects
of the issue, such as the correct way to address it in schools and
universities, rather than its security and diplomatic angles.

Knesset speaker Reuven Rivlin also stressed that the issue was not
a political one.

“The subject has not arisen at the Knesset because things happened
between Israel and Turkey; not because we want to exploit a political
situation in order to settle accounts,” he told the committee at the
start of its debate.

But a foreign ministry representative at the discussion warned of
the repercussions an Israeli move toward recognising the Armenian
genocide could have on the already-strained relations with Turkey.

“Our relations with them are so fragile today, it is not right to
push them over the red line,” Irit Lillian said. “Such a recognition
at this stage could have severe ramifications.”

Ariyeh Eldad of the right-wing National Union party, who along with
Zehava Gal-On of the left-wing Meretz party initiated the hearing,
said: “In the past it was wrong to bring up the issue because our
ties with Turkey were good; now it is wrong because our ties with
them are bad. When will the time be right?”

Gal-On said Israel had a “moral and historic obligation” to recognise
the genocide of a million and a half Armenians, “especially when we
are still struggling against Holocaust denial. The Israeli educational
system cannot silence the Armenian genocide.”

Georgette Avakian of the Armenian National Committee in Jerusalem
was reservedly satisfied at the meeting’s conclusion.

“This was a breakthrough, since the education committee dealt with
it,” she told AFP. “But I’m disappointed that they haven’t reached
any conclusions and are putting it off” for further discussions.

Armenians say up to 1.5 million of their kinsmen died in orchestrated
killings during the final years of the Ottoman Empire.

The Turkish government strongly denies this, saying 300,000 Armenians
and as many Turks were killed in civil conflict when the Christian
Armenians, backed by Russia, rose up against the Ottoman Empire.

France’s lower house voted last week to criminalise the denial
of genocide in Armenia, prompting Turkey to suspend political and
military cooperation.

LDPR Leader: Turkey Is Obligated To Recognize Armenian Genocide

LDPR LEADER: TURKEY IS OBLIGATED TO RECOGNIZE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE

PanARMENIAN.Net
December 26, 2011 – 17:45 AMT

PanARMENIAN.Net – The leader of the Liberal Democratic Party of Russia
(LDPR) commented on French National Assembly’s adoption of a bill
penalizing Armenian Genocide denial.

“LDPR has repeatedly urged for Genocide recognition. We welcome
French MPs’ decision to pass the Genocide bill. Turning a blind eye
to 1,5 million people who’ve fallen victim to 1915 massacres would
be blasphemous, ” Vladimir Zhirinovsky stressed.

“1915’s tragedy is the darkest page in the history of humanity. No
European or Asian county has ever perpetrated such a cruel elimination
of people. With the whole world promoting the principles of democracy,
the international community must recognize the Armenian Genocide,”
LDPR leader said.

“Turkey is obligated to recognize the crime, returning Armenia’s
original lands,” LDPR website quoted Zhirinovsky as saying.

Reproduction Of Serzh Sargsyan’S Regime Will Weaken Armenia And Will

REPRODUCTION OF SERZH SARGSYAN’S REGIME WILL WEAKEN ARMENIA AND WILL ENCOURAGE AZERBAIJAN TO UNDERTAKE A NEW AGGRESSION

arminfo
Monday, December 26, 14:55

The reproduction of Serzh Sargsyan’s regime will weaken Armenia and
will encourage Azerbaijan to undertake a new aggression, the head
of the Politekonomia research center Andranik Tevanyan said during
a press-conference on Monday.

He said that the Armenian authorities have failed in all of their
understandings in the last years: the economy is collapsing, the SMEs
have been chocked – and the big business is the next.

“They are centralizing the government and are creating an economy of
one oligarch, an economy controlled by Serzh Sargsyan, his son-in-law
Mikael Minasyan and Prime Minister Tigran Sargsyan and guarded by
Chairman of the Constitutional Court Gagik Harutyunyan. This is
weakening Armenia and its immunity against external challenges. And
if this situation continues, Azerbaijan may resume its aggression,”
Tevanyan said.

The only way-out of this situation, in his opinion, is the
consolidation of the leading political forces into an effective
counterbalance to the regime. “For this purpose, we must change the
electoral code and transit to 100% proportional system,” Tevanyan said.

The German Pilgrim’s "Planet Armenia" Travels About Germany And Spre

THE GERMAN PILGRIM’S “PLANET ARMENIA” TRAVELS ABOUT GERMANY AND SPREADS ARMENIA’S AROMA
Ofelya Sargsyan

noyan tapan
2011-12-26

On November 26, 2011 at the Armenian Cultural Union in Hamburg took
place the eighth presentation of the book “Planet Armenia: Pilgrimage
to an Unknown Land” by Dr. Jochen Mangelsen. The book was released in
Frankfurt am Main in September 2011 by the “Armenian Media” publishing
house and has 187 pages. The book is rich in brilliant illustrations
which are made by the Bremen-based Armenian painter Marietta Armena.

Published in September the book had 8 presentations in 2 months
organized by different Armenian communities and German organizations.

Mangelsen’s book was also noted by the German media: immediately after
being published, one of the best read newspapers, the Weser Kurier
on September 4, 2011, as well as the Radio Station Suedwestrundfunk
SWR on September 19, 2011 and the Radio Bremen/WDR – Funkhaus Europa
on November 13, 2011, discussed it. Moreover, in January an one-hour
program devoted to the book is expected on the Nordwestradio by the
Radio Bremen.

The opening speech of the presentation in Hamburg was made by the
president of the German-Armenians’ Central Council and the Union of
the Armenian Academics Azat Ordukhanyan who said, “Within a month
Jochen moved from the north of Armenia to the south, reached Artsakh
and his book managed to be in 8 cities within 2 months travelling
from Bremen to Stuttgart, Frankfurt am Main, Halle, Leipzig, Berlin
and Hamburg. They say, in general there are no irreplaceable people
but Mangelsen is exceptional both as a friend and as a press advisor
to the German-Armenians’ Central Council”.

The book is a result of a several-week journey during which the
author moved from region to region, from monastery to monastery and
through spiritual adventures reached Artsakh. The South Caucasus
politically risky and uncertain conflict concerned him as much as the
country’s fantastic legends, history of millenniums, people, culture
and political events pushed him forward. He throws a bright look to
our country situated on the slope of Mt. Ararat and provides a new
perception about it, presenting it as a colorful and gorgeous planet.

He describes his book as a political feleton.

The book also includes text-miniatures – short novels which despite
being only a few lines reflect the unique magic of the country. The
book is truly exclusive and original and has already had a large sale.

Therefore, with some small additions the second edition is expected
after January and there will also be new presentations.

Dr. Jochen Mangelsen was born in 1942, is a journalist, lives and
works in Bremen, for many years worked as a spokesman for the Bremen
Radio. He began his journalistic career after studying oration,
drama studies, German language and philology. He was married with the
Armenian Seda Murdayan. His daughter, Sona, was baptized in Armenia
and in October, 2011 got married at the Armenian Church St. Hripsime
under the Armenian rite. Also, the same day Mangelsen’s grandchildren
were baptized at St. Hripsime. According to him the roots that Seda
instilled in her daughter’s soul have deep foundations.

The motivation that has brought Mangelsen to the topic “Armenia”
over 40 years, Mangelsen took from his own, German, history. The
holocaust committed by the generation of his parents makes him
sensitive towards the Armenian Genocide, the impunity of which,
many believe, encouraged the organizers of the Jews’ massacre in
Europe. The history of Germany and its approach to the history are
linked with the question of how modern Turkey treats to its past, to
the Genocide against its Christian neighbors organized by the Young
Turks, the position of Germany towards this tragedy as well as with
the responsiveness of the future generations. These are the facts
and circumstances that served as a basis for Mangelsen’s activity. He
created an Armenian-German circle in Bremen then in Hannover, worked
for the “Armenian-German Correspondence” magazine editorial, became its
co-editor and currently is a media consultant to the German-Armenians’
Central Council.

Intensive, personally based, politically motivated years of connection
with Armenia confirm his love for this country. Mangelsen himself says,
“What charms me in Armenia? Perhaps, it is just as follows: we fall
in love with a place, its nature and people and at one time we go to
discover them and that journey takes us to our souls. Armenia, as well
as Artsakh are miraculous countries full of legends, thousand-year-old
cultural monuments, deeply affected by Christianity, mythology and the
causalities of the modern history. Conclusion: I have been enchanted
with Armenia for about 40 years”. The proof of it is also his novel
“Ofelya’s long journey to Berlin published in 2001.

The book raises the Genocide issue of 1915 – 19 during which 1,
5 million Armenians were sent to innocent death. The novel also
describes the fate of many Armenian families who live abroad but are
unable to forget the horrific events of the past and feel abandoned
and forgotten by the world. In the first plan of the book is a family
story, in the background is the slaughter of millions of Armenians.

Alfred remembers his ancestors’ massacre and their migration from
Western Armenia. As for Ofelya, she had to accompany her relatives on
the hard ways of escapade from Persia. Mangelsen does describe the
turnovers and upheavals of their lives painstakingly and the book
reflects his compassion towards a multiply smitten country.

Afterward, Mangelsen shifts from fiction to travel literature genre and
in 2006 with Alexander Schmitt he published a book about his Jacob´s
pilgrimage to Spain. His readers expected that the Jacob´s pilgrim
would also pass through Armenia and Artsakh with his traveler’s
crook. At last, in 2010 the expectations of the writer’s fans were
satisfied: Mangelsen traveled to Armenia and Artsakh and summed up
his vivid impressions of the Nairian land in his third book which is
a pilgrim’s unique love confession to Armenia and Armenians.

Genocide Armenien : Aznavour Remercie Sarkozy

GENOCIDE ARMENIEN : AZNAVOUR REMERCIE SARKOZY

Le Parisien

26 dec 2011
France

Après l’adoption par l’Assemblee nationale du projet de loi sur la
penalisation de la negation des genocides, dont celui des Armeniens en
1915, le chanteur Charles Aznavour a fait part dans une lettre adressee
a Nicolas Sarkozy de ses “sentiments de fierte, de reconnaissance et
de justice rendue”.

Le texte doit encore etre approuve par le Senat, alors que la Turquie
a pris des mesures de retorsion.

Le site en ligne du magazine “Nouvelles d’Armenie” a publie en
integralite le courrier adresse au chef de l’Etat francais par
l’auteur-compositeur ne a Paris en 1924 de parents armeniens. “A
Erevan (la capitale de l’Armenie, ndlr), lors de votre visite d’Etat
exceptionnelle en octobre dernier, en vous rendant au Memorial
du Genocide armenien, vous avez appele la Turquie a revisiter son
histoire”, ecrit Charles Aznavour a Nicolas Sarkozy. “Vous avez redit
tout votre engagement en faveur de l’adoption d’une loi francaise
sur la condamnation du genocide armenien et de leurs descendants”.

“Des mots de sincère gratitude”

“Aujourd’hui”, les 500 000 Francais d’origine armenienne sont
fiers “que notre Assemblee nationale preconise la penalisation du
negationnisme”, ajoute l’artiste. La France est devenue “le premier
Etat au monde a donner force de loi a la reconnaissance du genocide
armenien”. “Aujourd’hui, ce sont des mots de sincère gratitude que
je voudrais vous adresser”, poursuit Charles Aznavour.

Le 12 mars 2011, lors d’un rassemblement de la communaute des Francais
d’origine armenienne devant le Senat, le chanteur avait reitere qu’un
vote sanction contre le candidat Sarkozy a la presidentielle de 2012
etait possible, lui demandant “d’honorer sa promesse “, rapportent
“les Nouvelles d’Armenie”.

L’artiste mène depuis longtemps un combat pour la reconnaissance
de ce genocide commis en 1915 sous l’empire ottoman. Depuis 2009,
il est l’ambassadeur de l’Armenie en Suisse. Il represente egalement
cette ancienne Republique sovietique auprès du bureau europeen des
Nations unies.

Le debat rouvert en Israël

Israël reflechit egalement a une reconnaissance officielle du genocide
armenien. Lundi, la commission de l’Education a tenu une discussion
publique sur ce thème. Deputes, historiens et membres du Comite
armenien de Jerusalem ont insiste sur l’obligation morale pour Israël
de reconnaître comme un genocide ce massacre. Une telle mesure avait
deja ete debattue ces dernières annees en commission parlementaire,
mais les discussions s’etaient deroulees a huis clos.

La commission n’a cependant pris aucune decision ce lundi sur cette
question qui fera l’objet d’autres reunions. Le Parlement israelien a
deja rejete plusieurs propositions similaires ces dernières annees,
quand Israël et la Turquie entretenaient des liens etroits. Mais
les relations se sont tendues depuis que la marine israelienne a tue
neuf Turcs en mai 2010 lors de l’arraisonnement d’une flottille qui
tentait de briser le blocus de Gaza.

http://www.leparisien.fr/politique/genocide-armenien-aznavour-remercie-sarkozy-26-12-2011-1784325.php

LANG : Paroles Blessantes Et Humiliantes A L’Egard De La Turquie

LANG : PAROLES BLESSANTES ET HUMILIANTES A L’EGARD DE LA TURQUIE
Jean Eckian

armenews.com
lundi 26 decembre 2011

Interroge ce matin sur RTL sur les menaces de mort qui pèsent sur la
personne de Valerie Boyer, et plus longuement sur la question de la
loi adoptee par l’Assemblee nationale, penalisant la negation de tous
les genocides, dont celui des Armeniens, Jack Lang, a d’une part, fait
etat de sa solidarite avec “cette collègue”, et maintient sa position
negative relative a la proposition de loi. Il rejoint ainsi les propos
de Robert Badinter qui evoque l’anticonstitutionnalite d’un tel texte.

Nous avons un double devoir d’amitie, avec l’Armenie et avec la
Turquie”, dit-il. Mais ajoute que nous avons des “paroles blessantes
et humiliantes a l’egard de la Turquie”. Evoquant les “massacres”
de la guerre 1914-18, le depute du Nord appelle la Turquie a regarder
son histoire en face.

Public Radio And Public TV Celebrate The 85th And 55th Anniversaries

PUBLIC RADIO AND PUBLIC TV CELEBRATE THE 85TH AND 55TH ANNIVERSARIES RESPECTIVELY

armradio.am
25.12.2011 12:30

At the A. Spendiarian National Academic Opera and Ballet Theater
President Serzh Sargsyan attended a festive event dedicated to the
85th anniversary of Armenia’s Public Radio and 55th anniversary of
Public TV.

On the 85th anniversary of Armenia’s Public Radio and 55th anniversary
of Public TV by the Presidential decrees a group of the area employees
has been awarded high state awards. President Serzh Sargsyan handed
the awards during the event, congratulated on the occasion of the
jubilee and thanked the awardees for their great job.

Nune Alexanian, a journalist of the Armenian Public TV First news
agency, Gagik Mkrtchian, Executive Director of the Armenia TV company,
Alisa Kalantarian, Editor-in-Chief of the Armenian Public Radio musical
programs and Hrach Keshishian, Executive Director of A-TV company were
awarded Movses Khorenatsi medals for their considerable contribution
to the development of the radio and television area in our country.

For the outstanding artistic achievements in the area of arts and
culture Manya Ghazarian, Director of Shoghakat spiritual and cultural
company was awarded the Movses Khorenatsi medal.

Movses Khorenatsi medals were awarded also to Ruben Mkrtchian, Senior
Program Director at Public TV, Slavik Sarkissian, Editor-in-Chief
of the Public TV Sport Studia, Mark Petrossian, creator of musical
programs on the Public TV, Marietta Vardanian, Public Radio editor
and translator of the Azerbaijani programs for broadcasting abroad
for their lasting work and artistic achievements in the area of radio
and television.

Arpen Movsissian, Public TV Hayits Hay program creator was awarded the
honorary title of the RA Distinguished Art Worker for the years-long
activity and considerable contribution to the area.

Boris Petrossian, Chief Cameraman of the Armenian Public TV was also
awarded the honorary title of the RA Distinguished Art Worker for
the years-long creative activities.

Arthur Grigorian, Senior Correspondent at the Armenian Public TV First
news agency was awarded the title of the RA Distinguished Journalist
for his contribution to the development of the journalistic area.

ANKARA: Protesters gather in front of the French Embassy in Ankara

Anadolu Agency, Turkey
Dec 23 2011

Protesters gather in front of the French Embassy in Ankara to protest
‘Armenian proposal’

ANKARA (A.A) -December 22, 2011 -A group of Turkish protestors
gathered in front of the French Embassy in Ankara on Thursday to
protest the “Armenian proposal” adopted in the French Parliament.

Describing themselves as the “Talatpasa Committee”, the protestors
carried banners that read “Stop France. We did not commit genocide but
we defended our homeland”.

Speaking on behalf of the group, Bulent Esinoglu said that “the French
decision implied the Turkish nation was a killer”.

We do not recognize the decision of the French Parliament, Esinoglu stressed.

Turkish Police took tight security measures in front of the French
Embassy in Ankara.

Meanwhile, the Chairman of Turkish Confederation of Tradesmen and
Craftsmen (TESK), Bendevi Palandoken, said Thursday that they strongly
condemned today’s vote at the French Parliament on the “Armenian
proposal”.

“We are removing all French products from our shelves,” Palandoken said.

We have prepared flyers condemning the French Parliament’s decision
today. The flyers would be posted on taxi cabs, minibuses, buses and
billboards, Palandoken also said.

ISTANBUL: US Armenians hail French `genocide’ law

Hurriyet Daily News, Turkey
Dec 24 2011

US Armenians hail French `genocide’ law
ANKARA

Ã`mit Enginsoy

The largest and most influential U.S. Armenian group late Dec. 22
welcomed a vote in French Parliament’s lower house to criminalize the
denial of what it calls the `Armenian genocide.’

Aram Hamparian, executive director of the Armenian National Committee
of America (ANCA), hailed the move, saying that `today’s overwhelming
vote by the French National Assembly reinforces the growing
international consensus and the mounting pressure on Turkey, for a
truthful and just resolution of the Armenian genocide.’

Hamparian urged the U.S. administration and Congress to move in a
similar way. `Closer to home, France’s stand underscores the need for
our own American president and Congress to finally reject Ankara’s gag
rule on the proper condemnation and commemoration of this still
unpunished crime against humanity,’ he said in an ANCA statement. `We
mark this occasion by urging President [Barack] Obama to honor his
pledge to recognize the Armenian genocide and the House [of
Representatives] leadership to bring the Armenian genocide
resolution… for a full [House] floor vote.’

Armenians say the killing of their kinsmen in the World War I-era
Ottoman Empire amounted to genocide. Turkey immediately announced that
it was withdrawing its ambassador to Paris, Tahsin BurcuoÄ?lu, after
the French assembly’s decision. Turkey has also warned that its
bilateral relations with the United States will deteriorate in a major
and lasting way in the event either the U.S. administrative or
legislative branch endorses an `Armenian genocide’ move.

The U.S. Congress has declined to formally approve `Armenian genocide’
resolutions in recent decades. In the latest such effort, the U.S.
House of Representatives declined to hold a vote on a genocide
resolution last year. The French Senate, Parliament’s upper chamber,
is expected to vote on the genocide denial bill early next year. The
Turkish government already has warned that it will retaliate seriously
if France formally endorses the latest bill.
December/24/2011