With friends like Azerbaijan…

The Shift
 
 
With friends like Azerbaijan…
 
by The Shift Team
 
Reporters Without Borders UK Bureau Director Rebecca Vincent speaking to The Shift News at the Council of Europe building in Strasbourg during the vote on the Special Rapporteur’s report on Malta.
 
An op-ed by Rebecca Vincent, Reporters Without Borders UK Bureau Director.
 
Did you ever have one of those déjà vu moments? This week it was my turn, at the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE). I was there on behalf of Reporters Without Borders, along with colleagues from other freedom of _expression_ organisations, to advocate support for a crucial report and accompanying resolution on the assassination of journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia and rule of law in Malta.
 
Given the Maltese authorities’ failure to achieve justice for Caruana Galizia’s assassination close to two years after her assassination in a car bomb outside her home, and the government’s resistance to launching an independent public inquiry despite clear deficiencies of the criminal investigation highlighted in reports by European institutions, we expected the Maltese government – and ruling Labour Party members of the Maltese delegation – to attempt to counter the damning findings of the report and turn support away from the resolution.
 
Indeed, they did. But even more vocal than the Maltese ruling party itself was their somewhat unusual bedfellows from the Azerbaijani delegation.
 
Caviar Diplomacy and the Azerbaijani Laundromat
 
Azerbaijan is a country close to my heart, having lived there twice, gotten expelled in connection with my work with local human rights groups, and in the end, having worked predominately on human rights issues and cases from Azerbaijan for a decade.
 
During that time, many friends and colleagues – journalists, human rights defenders, political activists – were systematically targeted through a range of pressures, including political imprisonment, and from abroad I led international campaigns for their releases.
 
In the context of that work, I often attended PACE sessions to advocate support for resolutions and other measures aimed at holding the Azerbaijani government to account for its human rights obligations, and to secure the releases of political prisoners. This sometimes felt like a disproportionately difficult uphill battle, and eventually, we found out why.
 
In 2012, reports of so-called “caviar diplomacy” surfaced – a term coined by the European Stability Initiative in their initial reporting on corrupt lobbying tactics used by Azerbaijan within the Council of Europe and beyond.
 
In the midst of this, the Azerbaijani delegation celebrated an unlikely victory that was particularly demoralising to us who had worked so hard on the other side. A key report by then-Special Rapporteur Christoph Strässer on the situation of political prisoners in Azerbaijan was narrowly defeated.
 
Just before the vote took place, head of the Azerbaijani delegation Samad Seyidov made  a particularly emboldened statement: “I am completely against the approach it takes to Azerbaijan, but I will still be a member of the Assembly because this is not Mr Strässer’s Council of Europe; it is my Council of Europe, just as it is my Azerbaijan, as it will be forever”. Indeed, it certainly felt like Seyidov’s Council of Europe.
 
Five years later, in October 2017, details of an even bigger scandal emerged: the ‘Azerbaijani Laundromat’. The Organised Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP) uncovered a €2.5 billion fund used by Azerbaijan’s elite in a complex money-laundering and influencing-buying scheme that included payoffs between 2012 and 2014 to politicians to help launder Azerbaijan’s image, including at PACE.
 
To those of us working on human rights in Azerbaijan, the Laundromat revelations were no surprise: they crystallised and vindicated the things we had felt were happening during those disheartening years of attempting to hold the Azerbaijani government to account at the international level, including at PACE.
 
For its part, PACE convened an investigation and eventually found that 17 current and former MPs had broken PACE’s Code of Conduct, including Azerbaijan delegation head Seyidov, who was banned from holding any senior post within PACE for two years, as well as from representing PACE at third-party events, but remains able to speak within the assembly.
 
Two other MPs – Cezar Florin Preda from Romania and Jordi Xuclà from Spain – also received two-year bans with these conditions, and Preda continues to serve in the assembly.
 
Former PACE president, Spanish MP Pedro Agramunt, received a 10-year ban, but had already resigned his post as president in October 2017 for “personal reasons” before a motion for his dismissal (connected to his participation in a Russian-led trip to meet with Syrian president Bashar al-Assad) could be debated.
 
In June 2018, 13 other current and former MPs were banned from PACE and the broader Council of Europe for life.
 
The unholy alliance with Malta
 
Fast forward to this week at PACE. The day prior to the debate on the resolution on the assassination of Caruana Galizia, ruling party members of the Maltese delegation tabled a series of amendments aimed at weakening and undermining the resolution.
 
These amendments (ultimately unsuccessful) were supported by…you guessed it…delegates from Azerbaijan. The Azerbaijani delegation also hosted a side event competing with the side event we had organised in support of the Malta resolution, to present on ‘New Challenges and Ongoing Reform in Azerbaijan’ despite nothing of the sort being on the plenary agenda for the week.
 
The Azerbaijani delegation was out in full force during the plenary debate on the report and resolution, with a staggering four out of 20 total speaking slots taken by Azerbaijani MPs (compared to a modest two spaces for ruling party Maltese delegates themselves). Among them, Seyidov himself, attempting to dismiss the lack of justice for the murder of a journalist with the platitude “nobody’s perfect”, and along with three other Azerbaijani MPs, attacking Pieter Omtzigt’s character and credibility and calling for an investigation into corruption in Europe.
 
Although Malta’s ruling party MPs refrained from voting (after the deployment of Malta’s diplomatic muscle failed), all six of Azerbaijan’s MPs voted against the resolution.
 
One lesson can be drawn from the failed results of this unholy alliance, and that is despite the Azerbaijani government escaping largely unscathed for its previously documented corrupt lobbying practices, the era of caviar diplomacy is well and truly over.
 
As I stated in our side event before the plenary debate, it is an insult to both the intelligence and integrity of the Assembly in its entirety for delegations to continue to behave so crudely and assume they can convince anyone at all, or get their way. And that is the point that the Maltese government, and ruling party members of the Maltese delegation, so clearly missed.
 
We don’t know what, if any, arrangement might have taken place to secure Azerbaijan’s support in working to influence MPs against the resolution on the assassination of Caruana Galizia. We don’t know why the Azerbaijani delegation – more than the Maltese themselves – so vigorously promoted wrecking amendments or spoke so spectacularly unconvincingly on the floor of the Assembly.
 
Or perhaps there was no arrangement. Perhaps the Azerbaijani delegation simply viewed it as an injustice – in light of Azerbaijan’s own dismal human rights record, including impunity for past cases of murders of journalists – for PACE to dare to attempt to hold a Council of Europe member state accountable for its obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights.
 
Perhaps they were still angry with Omtzigt for leading calls for PACE to launch an inquiry into reports of corruption in the assembly and for PACE to write a new report on the issue of political prisoners in Azerbaijan.
 
Perhaps they were offended by the light the Malta resolution (which mentioned Azerbaijani involvement in examples of corruption in Malta) cast on Azerbaijan, referred to by one Azerbaijani MP who spoke both as “blackmail” and an attempt to damage Azerbaijan’s relations with Europe.
 
Or perhaps they simply wanted to impress their friends from Malta; their friends who continue to block efforts towards justice for the assassination of a journalist who had been investigating Azerbaijani money-laundering and investment into a secret shell company called 17 Black. Their friends who sell “golden passports”, granting full access to Europe. Their friends who, despite being an EU member state, are moving ever closer to matching the human rights record of their own authoritarian government.
 
And if that’s the case, really – who needs enemies?

Sports: Armenian boxer starts with victory at Minsk 2019

Panorama, Armenia
Sport 20:18 21/06/2019 Armenia

The 2nd European Games kicked off in Belarusian capital Minsk on Friday. The first competition day was opened by boxers. In the qualification round Armenian boxer Zhirayr Sargsyan competing in the 57 kg weight category defeated his Romanian opponent by 4:1 in the first bout.

Other representatives of Armenia – Gurgen Madoyan (69 kg), Arman Darchinyan (75 kg), Henrik Sargsyan (91 kg) and Gurgen Hovhannisyan (+91 kg) – are set to perform later today. 

EU Ambassador on law related to filmmaking industry in Armenia

News.am, Armenia
EU Ambassador on law related to filmmaking industry in Armenia EU Ambassador on law related to filmmaking industry in Armenia

16:45, 17.06.2019
                  

During parliamentary hearings devoted to the possible legislative solutions in the filmmaking industry at the National Assembly and organized by the Standing Committee on Science, Education, Culture, Diaspora, Youth and Sport, Head of the EU Delegation to Armenia Piotr Switalski said the European Union has decided to support the possible legislative decisions related to the filmmaking industry.

The Ambassador stated that, according to the EU, culture is a very powerful tool for Armenia that can not only help improve the country’s image, but also contribute to the country’s economic development.

The European official noted that Armenia is already participating in two events through sub-projects and that this will be an essential contribution to the country.

Switalski also voiced hope that this discussion will be a success and the National Assembly will adopt a law on the filmmaking industry.

Yerevan Brandy Company presents the second edition of the innovative collection ARARAT Single Cask 12 YO

Arminfo, Armenia

ArmInfo. ARARAT Single Cask 12 YO is the continuation of the ARARAT Single Cask innovative series launched by Yerevan Brandy Company back in 2017. The remarkable success of the predecessor of ARARAT Single Cask 12 YO – the first innovative drink of ARARAT, inspired the masters of Yerevan Brandy Company to continue the series, showing that innovation is not only about constant improvement, but also about finding new and unexpected facets.

ARARAT Single Cask 12 YO is the limited product of Yerevan Brandy Company with 12 years of aging, a unique age characteristic for ARARAT range. Non-blended and produced exclusively from endemic Armenian Lalvar grape variety, ARARAT Single Cask 12 YO is a kind of grisaille – a canvas made in one color, because the variety of organoleptic notes of Lalvar grapes in the hands of ARARAT masters created an incredibly bright shine of generosity.

Refined by North

Maturing for 12 years in a single cask, brandy spirit used for ARARAT Single Cask 12 YO has been aged in the cellars of YBC Tavush branch since the very first day of their foundation. Thus, brandy spirit obtained from rare Lalvar grape variety grown in northeastern part of Armenia over the years has been matured for a long time in the cellars of Tavush, where over the years the year-round constant temperature and the mild northern climate steadily gave the stained glass of organoleptic shades a noble refining. Thanks to this approach to the process of aging, ARARAT Single Cask 12 YO is distinguished by exceptional delicacy, subtlety, multi-subject fullness of taste and aroma.

Like its predecessor, ARARAT Single Cask 12 YO is a kind of invitation for a true connoisseur to the backstage of centuries-old traditions and the opportunity to appreciate the beauty of primeval origin. Skipped blending and cold filtration underlines the unique nature of the product.

Aesthetics of Contemplation

ARARAT Single Cask 12 YO has a light amber color and gloss mahogany. The long aging years are reflected in the ornamental image of drops flowing down in parallel after a slight rotation of the glass.

Aesthetics of pleasure

ARARAT Single Cask 12 YO is characterized by a harmonious caramel-vanilla aroma with soft floral notes and tones of smoked prunes. A strong, bounteous, rich taste with notes of candied fruit and roasted nuts turns into a long, pleasantly warming aftertaste.

Gold of contention: Armenia land dispute in spotlight as government steps in

Thomson Reuters Foundation
June 6 2019


by Umberto Bacchi
Protests against a gold mine have divided locals, some of whom say it will provide much-needed employment

By Umberto Bacchi

JERMUK, Armenia, June 6 (Thomson Reuters Foundation) – Tonnes of gold that lie under a snow-capped mountain in Armenia have locked locals and international investors in a bitter land dispute, with the country’s new government being watched closely in coming weeks as it tries to resolve the conflict.

For almost a year, protesters worried about potential damage to the environment have blocked access to works to complete a mine that its Anglo-American operator says would generate hundreds of jobs and millions in tax revenue for the state.

But their protests have angered some locals eager for jobs in the remote, mountainous region, with mining firm Lydian International saying it has had to axe more than 1,000 jobs and lost more than $60 million since the blockade began.

With a government-commissioned assessment into the mine’s environmental impact expected to be released within weeks, international investors were said to be watching closely to see how Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan handled the dispute.

“There are more valuable things than gold,” said Gagik Margaryan, one of a few dozen residents of the southern town of Jermuk and nearby villages that have taken turns since last June to watch over Amulsar, the mountain overlooking their homes.

The group has set up makeshift checkpoints on unpaved roads leading to extraction and treatment facilities built on the summit’s slopes, preventing access by workers.

The protests have divided locals, some of whom say the mine will provide much-needed employment to Jermuk, a town of about 3,000 people, and to rural communities in the area about 170 km (105 miles) southeast of the capital Yerevan.

Minerals and metals make up about half of Armenia’s exports and mining accounted for about 3% of the country’s economic output in 2017, government data showed.

FOREIGN JITTERS

An environmental impact assessment commissioned by Lydian to get approval to start work in 2016 stated there would be no significant impacts on the environment and local water supplies.

The company, which has invested almost $500 million in the project, said it fulfilled all legal requirements to start work.

Lydian Armenia’s managing director Hayk Aloyan warned the dispute was putting more at stake than just his own company’s business interests in the former Soviet republic.

“Imagine your biggest investment project is blockaded illegally,” he told the Thomson Reuters Foundation in his office in Yerevan.

“It is a huge reputational damage. We are too small a country to have the luxury of damaging our reputation”.

Drastic political changes in Armenia last year emboldened protesters to act against the planned mine.

In April 2018 mass protests against corruption and cronyism resulted in a peaceful revolution that propelled journalist-turned-politician Pashinyan to power with his authority as prime minister bolstered by an election win in December.

But the new government has found itself in a quandary, said Richard Giragosian, director at the Regional Studies Centre, a think tank based in Yerevan.

“(The government’s) heart is with the environmental protesters, but the economic importance of the mining companies is too big to ignore,” he said.

Last November the government commissioned a new independent assessment of the mine’s environmental impact, responding to what it said was public demand for full compliance of mining projects with environmental standards.

Results of that assessment are expected over the next month.

Deputy Prime Minister Tigran Avinyan said in emailed comments that mining activity in Amulsar could proceed if the investigation found “the environmental risks are manageable”.

Lydian said it would go to arbitration if forced to shut.

GOLDEN WATER

The Amulsar gold mine is surrounded by three rivers and two artificial lakes.

One of these, the Kechut reservoir, is connected by a Soviet-era underground tunnel to Lake Sevan, Armenia’s largest reservoir and the Caucasus region’s biggest body of water.

Mine opponents fear toxic discharge from gold extraction could contaminate water used for drinking and irrigation locally as well as in the Ararat valley, a key food-producing region.

“Amulsar is situated in a very sensitive area,” said Arpine Galfayan, an activist with the Armenian Environmental Front.

Lydian said it would implement measures to prevent cyanide, a chemical used to dissolve gold, and other potentially harmful substances from leaking into the environment.

Locals also fear the mine might deter tourists from visiting Jermuk, a spa town renowned for its hot water springs, and could push hotels out of business.

“People who want to recover their health will not come to a place where there are industries with heavy chemical elements involved,” said Tigran Margaryan, a Jermuk hotel owner. “This town will become a miners’ town.”

Lydian said it has invested more than $3 million in social projects, such as local businesses and infrastructure, to mitigate the mine’s impact, and it was ready to invest more to establish a natural park.

The company said it would source at least 30% of the mine’s 700-strong permanent workforce locally but added most of the roughly 1,400 people hired during construction work had now lost their jobs due to the protests.

“When I started to work for Lydian, I understood what it means to get a salary,” said Mkhitar Arshaikyan, a former biology teacher hired by Lydian as an environmental consultant.

Young people struggling to find jobs in farming communities around Jermuk will again be forced to seek employment far from home, he added during a closed-door meeting of mine supporters at an unmarked Lydian office in the city in May.

Yet others feel bargaining their mountain for a mine that would only operate for 16 years was not a good deal.

Samuel Poghosyan, 70, said he decided to protest last spring after dust from the mine covered the green slopes surrounding his house and his kitchen tap started spewing mud.

Construction work had damaged water pipes leading to his village, he said as he sat inside a rusty metal container serving as one of the blockade checkpoints.

Lydian said it had apologised for the incident and that such disruptions would end with construction works.

But the retired factory worker, with a penchant for flowers and books on U.S. capitalism, said he spends at least four days a week at the post to prevent the region’s natural beauty from being “annihilated” and would continue even if the government gave the mine the go-ahead.

“This is a paradise land that we received from our ancestors … and we are obliged to leave it to our future generations at least in the current conditions,” he said. (Reporting by Umberto Bacchi @UmbertoBacchi, editing by Astrid Zweynert, Zoe Tabary and Belinda Goldsmith Please credit the Thomson Reuters Foundation, the charitable arm of Thomson Reuters, that covers humanitarian news, women’s and LGBT+ rights, human trafficking, property rights, and climate change. Visit

Sports: Karabakh hosting most prestigious of unrecognised sporting events

JAM News
June 3 2019
 
  
 
 
Karabakh hosting most prestigious of unrecognised sporting events
 
 SAID VOUBA, STEPANAKERT JUNE 3, 2019
 
The European Football Championship under the auspices of ConIFA is the only chance for teams for whom the road is closed to big world tournaments to compete
 
The unrecognized European Football Championship under the auspices of ConIFA is being held in Karabakh on June 1-8.
 
Eight teams from unrecognized or partially recognized republics are taking part. For all of them, ConIFA tournaments are the only chance to compete, since they cannot enter large global tournaments.
 
What is ConIFA, who is participating, what are the prizes, how is Stepanakert hosting the tournament: all the details in short.
 
What is ConIFA?
 
ConIFA stands for the Confederation of Independent Football Associations. It was created in 2013 and involves the unification of teams and organizations that are not included in FIFA or in the continental confederations, because these republics are not recognized by the wider international community.
 
ConIFA declares absolute political neutrality and today has 40 teams.
 
The headquarters of the organization is located in Sweden in the city of Luleå.
 
• How the most prestigious of all unknown sports tournaments took place in Abkhazia
 
Preparations
 
It was decided to bring in the unrecognized football tournament to Stepanakert a year ago, and since then in Karabakh preparations for the tournament have been underway.
 
For all visitors, the fee has been cancelled for a single-entry tourist visa. Matches are divided between four cities, and in a year four stadiums were completely put in order.
 
11 hotels were proposed for athletes, judges and journalists.
 
The authorities also invited local residents to allow foreign guests into their homes as part of a wider homestay programme, to which more than 60 families responded.
 
Gurgen is one of those who joined the programme. His son, 15-year-old Samvel, who is fond of football, begged him to do so.
 
“We have fans here who represent Western Armenia [ed. Officially, the Eastern Anatolia region in Turkey – JAMnews]. It seems that we are all Armenians, but it turned out that we speak different Armenian languages and constantly switch to English. But now I have two teams for which I support, ‘Artsakh’ and ‘Western Armenia’”, Samvel says on the way to the stadium.
 
Guests and hosts
 
Together with the Karabakh team, eight teams are participating in the tournament. For various reasons, the Donetsk and Lugansk republics [ed. unrecognized republics that the whole international community considers part of Ukraine], as well as Transnistria [ed. Also an unrecognized republic, which the whole international community considers part of Moldova], refused to participate.
 
Among the participants there are the partially recognized republics of Abkhazia and South Ossetia.
 
Albanians also arrived under the flag of Chameria, the Italians under the auspices of Padania, Hungarians from the Székei region and representatives of Sapmi, better known as Lapland.
 
One of the most unusual participants is the Western Armenia team [ed. Eastern Anatolia region in Turkey]. This region has no territory, but there is a president and other government officials. The descendants of the victims of the Armenian genocide in the Ottoman Empire, scattered around the world, play for this team.
 
The level of commands is quite different. In the group stage games, it is clear that strong teams from Abkhazia, Padania and Sapmi have gathered quite professional football players, some of whom compete in reputable recognized championships. But other participants of the tournament are frankly amateur teams.
 
The opening ceremony was attended by two delegations – one led by the President of South Ossetia, the other was led by the Foreign Minister of Abkhazia.
 
Entrance to the ConIFA Championship opening ceremony took place without tickets, and volunteers are conducting city tours.
 
The stars of the opening ceremony were the famous musical group from France Gipsy Kings and the famous Armenian singer Sirusho, who is especially popular in Karabakh. Sirusho is the daughter-in-law of the second Armenian President Robert Kocharyan, who came from Karabakh.
 
In total, the opening ceremony was attended by more than ten thousand people, which is how many people the Stepanakert stadium accomodates, but the audience was all around: on the roofs of nearby houses and on the verandas of nearby cafes.
 
The final of the tournament will take place on June 9, the national teams of Abkhazia and Padania are considered favorites.
 
Toponyms, terminology, views and opinions expressed by the author are theirs alone and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of JAMnews or any employees thereof. JAMnews reserves the right to delete comments it considers to be offensive, inflammatory, threatening or otherwise unacceptable
 
 
 

Former Armenian weightlifter honored by Amsterdam Mayor for thwarting armed attempted robbery

Former Armenian weightlifter honored by Amsterdam Mayor for thwarting armed attempted robbery

Save

Share

16:28,

YEREVAN, MAY 31, ARMENPRESS. Armenian two-time European weightlifting champion Mel Daluzyan has made national headlines in Netherlands after stopping an armed robbery and getting stabbed in Amsterdam.

Daluzyan, a World Championship bronze medalist who formerly represented Armenia in her weightlifting career, is living in the Netherlands for already three years after being granted asylum.

Armed assailants attempted to rob the Albert Heijn supermarket in Amsterdam’s central part, when Daluzyan, who was shopping in the store, saw the attack and intervened to help the cashier, tackling the attackers to the ground. The former weightlifter was stabbed by the robbers and was airlifted to a hospital.

Amsterdam Mayor Femke Halsema personally visited Daluzyan to express appreciation.

“What you did was heroic. I am proud that Amsterdam has a resident like you,” the mayor told the Armenian.

“I am grateful that you effectively stopped the illegal actions of the armed masked assailants. I wish speedy recovery to you and I assure you that the City Hall stands ready to support you in all ways necessary,” the mayor said.

The assailants have been arrested on the scene.

Daluzyan will be discharged from hospital in a few days, according to media reports.

Edited and translated by Stepan Kocharyan




RFE/RL Armenian Report – 05/27/2019

                                        Monday, 
Armenia, China Sign Visa Waiver Deal
Armenia -- Foreign Ministers Zohrab Mnatsakanian (R) of Armenia and Wang Yi of 
China sign a visa waiver agreement in Yerevan, .
The foreign ministers of Armenia and China signed an agreement on visa-free 
travel between their countries after holding talks in Yerevan on Sunday.
The agreement will allow Armenian and Chinese citizens to visit and stay in 
each other’s country visa-free for up to 90 days.
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian stressed the importance of the deal when he met 
with Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi later in day. He said it will spur 
people-to-people and commercial contacts between the two nations.
Pashinian also noted his May 14-15 visit to Beijing during which met with 
China’s President Xi Jinping and Premier Li Keqiang. “I am glad that as a 
result of our discussions we reached concrete agreements on developing mutually 
beneficial cooperation,” he said, according to his press office.
“We are prepared for and intent on deepening mutually beneficial cooperation 
with Armenia,” Wang said for his part.
Official Armenian statements on the talks suggest that Wang’s meetings with 
Pashinian and Foreign Minister Zohrab Mnatsakanian focused on ways of boosting 
Chinese-Armenian economic ties. They specifically discussed Chinese involvement 
in infrastructure implemented in Armenia.
China is already Armenia’s second largest trading partner. According to 
official Armenian statistics, Chinese-Armenian trade soared by over 29 percent 
in 2018, to $771 million.
Regional security was also on the agenda of Wang’s talks in Yerevan, with 
Pashinian praising China’s “balanced” position on the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.
Scrutiny Of Armenian Judge ‘May Be Political’
        • Ruzanna Stepanian
Armenia - Smbat Gogian, chairman of the Supreme Qualification Committee, talks 
to journalists, Yerevan, .
The doctoral dissertation of an Armenian judge, who freed former President 
Robert Kocharian from custody last August, may have come under scrutiny for 
political reasons, a senior government official said on Monday.
The Court of Appeals judge, Aleksandr Azarian, overturned a lower court’s 
decision to allow investigators to arrest Kocharian on charges stemming from 
the 2008 post-election violence in Yerevan. He ruled at the time that the 
Armenian constitution gives the ex-president immunity from prosecution.
The higher Court of Cassation subsequently struck down Azarian’s ruling, paving 
the way for Kocharian’s renewed arrest in December. Kocharian was again freed 
on May 18 pending the outcome of his trial which began on May 13.
The decision made by a district court judge presiding over the trial angered 
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian and his political allies and supporters. 
Pashinian demanded on May 20 a mandatory “vetting” of all Armenian judges, 
saying that many of them remain linked to “the former corrupt system.”
A few days after Kocharian’s latest release, Smbat Gogian, the head of 
Armenia’s Supreme Qualification Committee, a state body overseeing the granting 
of postgraduate degrees, claimed that Azarian plagiarized some parts of his 
doctoral thesis.
The allegation, strongly denied by the senior judge, led an Armenian parliament 
committee on science and education to hold on Monday an extraordinary session 
on “possible legislative solutions for the fight against plagiarism.” Gogian 
also attended the meeting.
Gogian stood by the plagiarism claim when he spoke to RFE/RL’s Armenian 
service. He said his agency arrived at such a conclusion after being alerted by 
an individual whom he refused to name.
“By comparing files with each other, our [verification] system showed that 
[Azarian’s] dissertation has textual matches with two other dissertations,” 
added Gogian. One of those dissertations was written by Vazgen Rshtuni, the 
chairman of the Court of Appeals.
Asked whether political motives are behind the scandal, the official said: 
“Maybe they are … But I insist that the Supreme Qualification Committee did not 
initiate it.”
Azarian charged, meanwhile, that the plagiarism allegations as well as the 
parliamentary discussion organized by pro-government lawmakers are part of a 
coordinated smear campaign targeting him. “I think it’s clear to everyone that 
all bodies have been explicitly instructed to campaign against me,” the judge 
told News.am.
Azarian also said that he and Rshtuni were supervised by the same legal scholar 
when they worked on their dissertations. This why, he claimed, the two texts 
may have the same passages.
Ex-President’s Indicted Brother Again Allowed To Leave Armenia
        • Naira Bulghadarian
Armenia -- Aleksandr Sarkisian is taken in for questioning by the National 
Security Service, Yerevan, July 4, 2018.
Armenia’s National Security Service (NSS) has again allowed an indicted brother 
of Armenia’s former President Serzh Sarkisian to temporarily leave the country.
An NSS spokesman, Samson Galstian, told RFE/RL’s Armenian service on Monday 
that Aleksandr Sarkisian needs to undergo medical treatment abroad. He would 
not say in which country Sarkisian will receive it and for how long.
Sarkisian was already allowed by the NSS to travel to Europe in March. 
Investigators told him to return to Armenia in late April for further 
questioning.
The NSS charged Sarkisian with fraud in February several months after freezing 
his $30 million Armenian bank account as part of a separate inquiry. It 
announced shortly afterwards that he has donated $19.6 million from that 
account to the Armenian military. It said the state will also receive the rest 
of the sum in payment of Sarkisian’s back taxes.
The fraud charges stem from over a dozen drawings by the 20th century Armenian 
painter Martiros Saryan which were found in Aleksandr Sarkisian’s Yerevan villa 
in July. The NSS said his fugitive son Narek had fraudulently obtained them 
from Saryan’s descendants.
Narek Sarkisian, 37, fled Armenia in June 2018 before being charged with 
illegal arms possession and drug trafficking. The Czech police detained him in 
Prague in December on an Armenian arrest warrant. Armenian prosecutors have 
since been seeking his extradition.
Aleksandr Sarkisian’s second son, Levon, is currently standing trial on charges 
of attempted murder and illegal arms possession which he strongly denies. The 
33-year-old was arrested in July and freed on bail in September.
Sarkisian, 62, is thought to have made a big fortune in the past two decades. 
He held a seat in the Armenian parliament from 2003-2011.
Armenian, Azeri FMs To Meet Again
        • Susan Badalian
        • Aza Babayan
U.S. - Foreign Ministers Elmar Mammadyarov (R) of Azerbaijan and Zohrab 
Mnatsakanian (second from right) of Armenia pose for a photograph with the OSCE 
Minsk Group co-chairs in New York, 26 September 2018.
The foreign ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan will meet again soon for 
further talks on the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, the Armenian Foreign Ministry 
said on Monday.
The ministry spokeswoman, Anna Naghdalian, said Foreign Minister Zohrab 
Mnatsakanian and U.S., Russian and French mediators discussed in Yerevan 
preparations his “upcoming” talks with his Azerbaijani counterpart Elmar 
Mammadyarov.
The three mediators co-chairing the OSCE Minsk Group visited the Armenian 
capital at the start of a fresh tour of the Karabakh conflict zone. They met 
with Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian later in the day.
Naghdalian gave no date of Mnatsakanian’s planned talks with Mammadyarov.
The top Armenian and Azerbaijani diplomats most recently met in Moscow on April 
15 in the presence of Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov. A joint statement 
released by the three ministers said the warring sides reaffirmed their stated 
intention to strengthen the ceasefire regime around Karabakh and along the 
Armenian-Azerbaijani border and to take other take confidence-building measures.
Pashinian and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev briefly spoke with each other 
when they visited Brussels on May 13. It was Pashinian’s and Aliyev’s fifth 
face-to-face contact in about eight months. Their first meeting held in 
Tajikistan in September was followed by a significant decrease in ceasefire 
violations on the frontlines.
In an interview with the Russian daily “Kommersant” published on Monday, 
Mammadyarov sounded cautiously optimistic about further Armenian-Azerbaijani 
peace talks. He said Baku last year give Armenia’s new leadership time to 
“familiarize itself with details of the negotiation process.”
“That transitional phase ended, and negotiations resumed at the level of both 
the leaders of the two countries and the foreign ministers … The dialogue is 
going on in the existing format and under a particular agenda, which gives rise 
to certain optimism,” he said.
Mammadyarov also stressed that confidence-building measures by the two sides 
must go hand in hand with “real steps in the negotiation process” and 
“elimination of severe consequences” of the conflict. That first and foremost 
means a “withdrawal of occupation forces from Azerbaijan’s territories,” he 
said.
Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2019 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org

Where are the documents of the Young Turks trial? Paylan asked Erdogan’s aide

  • 26.04.2019
  •  

  • Armenia:
  •  

     

 48

Karo Paylan, the Armenian deputy of the Kurdish People’s Democratic Party of Turkey, addressed a written question to the president’s assistant, Fuat Oktay, regarding the location of the trial documents against the Young Turks for the crimes committed against the Armenian people in 1919-1922.


As reported by the Armenian “Agos” of Istanbul, Caro Paylan, reminding that in his scandalous statement of April 24, Erdogan spoke about the openness of Turkish archives, Karo Paylan emphasized that many scholars were not provided with the archive documents related to the trial of the Young Turks in 1919-1922 accused of committing a crime against the Armenian people.


The following was emphasized in Paylan’s questioning:


1. Are the documents related to the court case in the archive?


2. When did the documents of the mentioned court case enter the archive, when and in which department were they found?


3. If the claims that the trial documents are missing or inaccessible are not true, where are they now?


4. How can researchers “who want to know the truth” get the mentioned documents?


It should be noted that the Turkish court found the officials who organized the Armenian Genocide guilty and sentenced them to various punishments.

168: PM’s office has new deputy chief of staff

Category
World

Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has appointed Sargis Torosyan as Deputy Chief of Staff of his office.

Torosyan was serving as Head of the Social Affairs Department of Pashinyan’s office at the time of the appointment.

The previous Deputy Chief of Staff, Arthur Sargsyan, was sacked earlier last week.