Asbarez: UCLA Hosts First-Ever Conference on ‘Armenian Genocide Restitution in the Post-Recognition Era’

Panelists at UCLA’s first-ever conference on “Armenian Genocide Restitution in the Post-Recognition Era”


LOS ANGELES—The Armenian Genocide Research Program at The Promise Armenian Institute at UCLA, the Center for the Study of Law and Genocide at LMU Loyola Law School, and the National Association for Armenian Studies and Research co-hosted a conference on March 25 pertaining to Armenian genocide restitution. The conference was co-sponsored by the Armenian Bar Association, the Promise Institute for Human Rights at UCLA School of Law, and the Ararat-Eskijian Museum. 

Titled “What’s Next?: Armenian Genocide Restitution in the Post-Recognition Era,” this historic conference explored whether congressional recognition of the Armenian genocide in 2019 and President Biden’s recognition on April 24, 2021 offer new possibilities to pursue legal paths toward restitution, as well as how other restitution initiatives can serve as a model for future Armenian efforts.

Panelists included international human rights lawyer Kathryn Lee Boyd, who litigated the first successful art restitution case related to the Armenian genocide, UC Davis art history professor Heghnar Watenpaugh, known for investigating the complex history of medieval Armenian manuscript, the Zeytun Gospels, and lawyer and academic Mayo Moran, who facilitated restitution-related progress for Canada’s Indigenous population. 

“If American recognition is not to remain a merely symbolic gesture, must there not be certain legal ramifications to such recognition?” stated Taner Akçam, director of the AGRP at The Promise Armenian Institute at UCLA, in his introductory remarks. “The main purpose for recognizing historical injustices is to bring in their wake the at-least-partial recompense for past injustices. Indeed, if such acknowledgment is not followed by some steps in the direction of obtaining justice for past wrongs, then the gesture is truly without meaning.”

“I think that what President Biden did on April 24, 2021 was truly historic and something no other president was willing to do, and that provides a legal framework to begin working on restitution of cultural property, religious property, artifacts, that were part of the Armenian genocide,” said Keynote speaker Ambassador Stuart E. Eizenstat in a pre-recorded interview. Eizenstat also underlined similarities between the Holocaust and Armenian genocide restitution movements, suggesting the latter take a path similar to the former. “[This conference] has the prospect of being the equivalent to the 1994-95 Bard Graduate Conference that really elevated the issue of Nazi looted art,” he concluded.

The first panel outlined the legal precedent for Armenian genocide restitution cases within the United States, instances of foreign affairs preemption in such cases, and the importance of just attribution.

During the second session, panelists discussed the global landscape concerning looted art, including the story of Nigeria’s stolen Benin Bronzes and the restitution of Armenian cultural heritage.

The third panel focused on “what’s next” for the Armenian genocide restitution movement and how examples of political progress in other restitution cases can inspire a new path forward. 

Conference participants all agreed that this event marked the beginning of a new era pertaining to the Armenian genocide restitution movement. Organizers plan to take concrete steps to address the conference’s agenda, including establishing an inventory of Armenian looted assets in different countries. “It is now that we begin to build on what is undoubtedly a very promising future,” stated Dr. Akçam at the conference’s closing reception.

Watch the conference’s full proceedings on The Promise Armenian Institute’s YouTube Channel. A short documentary about the conference will be released this year by the Armenian Film Foundation. 

The Armenian Genocide Research Program was established within The Promise Armenian Institute at UCLA in early 2022. Led by Taner Akçam, the AGRP engages in research and scholarly activities pertaining to the study of the Armenian genocide in the Ottoman Empire during the early 20th century.

Armenia choses self-destruction by declining friendship with Russia

PRAVDA
Russia –
Lyuba Lulko

 29.03.2023 19:43

Armenia is close to losing its statehood in the fight against Azerbaijan. Meanwhile, it is possible to preserve the Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh as part of the Union State of the Russian Federation and Belarus.

On March 24, the Constitutional Court of Armenia recognised the country’s obligations under the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC) as consistent with the country’s Constitution.

The Russian Foreign Ministry warned Yerevan that Moscow found its plans to accede to the Rome Statute of the ICC against the backdrop of the recent illegal and legally void ICC “warrants” in relation to the Russian leadership to be absolutely unacceptable.


Moscow warned the Armenian side that Yerevan’s steps in this direction could lead to “extremely negative” consequences for Armenia’s relations with Russia.

Indeed, Moscow’s reaction deems justifiable as Yerevan has not ratified the statute for 19 years and suddenly decided to do it now.

Armenian officials said that the ICC would help to uncover “crimes committed by Azerbaijan.” However, most of them had taken place outside Armenia — in Hadrut and Shushi, which (in the perception of Yerevan) are already the territory of Azerbaijan. This excludes the application of the Rome Statute there.

As a matter of fact, there are different reasons that explain Armenia’s behaviour.

Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan believes that the November 2020 trilateral agreement (with the mediation of Russia) do not work. In particular, he claims that the Russian Federation does not prevent the blockade of Nagorno-Karabakh through the Lachin corridor, although this is part of Russia’s responsibility.

Armenia suggests leaving this format to conduct direct negotiations with Azerbaijan either through Georgia or a European platform.

However, those platforms set one condition — Armenia will have to break ties with the Russian Federation. This explains inadequate statements from Armenia’s National Assembly deputy Gagik Melkonyan, who said that Putin would be arrested in Armenia due to the recognition of the Rome Statute.


The West is using its leverage. The EU said it was not considering sanctions against Azerbaijan and suggested focusing on dialogue between the parties instead.

In fact, there are no sanctions coming, and the European Union has no intention to aggravate relations with Baku, because it gets Azerbaijani oil and gas as a replacement for the Russian fuel. Therefore, no one is going to bite the feeding hand of Azerbaijan.

In Azerbaijan, they believe that there is no such thing as the blockade of Nagorno-Karabakh. Instead, Azerbaijan tries to prevent arms supplies to Karabakh. President Ilham Aliyev warned that one should not negotiate with Azerbaijan from the position of force.

If Aliyev had been bolder, Yerevan would have lost any prospect of returning to Nagorno-Karabakh. The Armenian lobby is strong in the West, but it will not fight for the Armenians directly. Moreover, Armenia does not want to recognize the independence of the region. There is only meanness instead of courage, and it will pay off handsomely.

Armenia has already decided how it is going to continue to fight with Azerbaijan — it has taken Iran as an ally. Iran will not allow the formation of the Zangezur corridor along the border with Armenia to Nakhichevan. It will enter the war on the side of Armenia too.


It looks doubtful that Tehran will do that as it has a much bigger conflict brewing with Israel.

Instead of negotiating with Azerbaijan and Russia on Karabakh and preparing to win back morally and militarily, Armenia assumed that the West would come for help here and now.

As experience shows, such hopes do not lead to anything positive. The West may only care less about the people of Karabakh, and Armenia’s ambitions do not matter here either. The goal of the West is to defeat Russia. The Armenians are doomed to slaughter at this point — it goes about common residents of Karabakh and Armenia rather than the diaspora, including in Russia.

It appears that Yerevan intends to drain the cup of the death of its nation to the dregs. Armenia will pull out from the Collective Security Treaty Organisation (CSTO), which is already happening de facto. Afterwards, Armenia will exit the Eurasian Economic Union and then leave the friendship agreement with the Russian Federation (Russian peacemakers will be withdrawn from Karabakh and the Gyumri base).

The economy of Armenia will suffer in the first place, as it is largely dependent on cheap Russian fuel and Russian tourists. Prices for gas, oil, gasoline, diesel, etc will soar, and the inflation rate will surge to 20-30 percent.

Western “peacekeepers” will be deployed as well. As long as Europe needs Azerbaijan, the bargaining will continue and Yerevan will be eventually forced to accept the position of Baku to decide the fate of the people of Karabakh.

If Armenia were part of the Union State of Russia and Belarus, no Azerbaijani “environmentalists” would dare to block the Lachin corridor. The people of Karabakh would be granted autonomy as part of the Union State.


https://english.pravda.ru/world/156202-armenia_azerbaijan/

Russia, China sign statement on deepening strategic partnership

Save

Share

 20:45, 21 March 2023

YEREVAN, MARCH 21, ARMENPRESS. Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping signed a joint statement on the development of key areas of economic cooperation between the two countries until 2030.

ARMENPRESS reports, citing the gazeta website, the signing ceremony was broadcast on the Kremlin’s Telegram channel.

The leaders of Russia and China also signed a joint statement on deepening relations of comprehensive cooperation and strategic partnership.

According to Putin, in the documents signed by the parties, the task of multiplying the trade volumes was set. He noted that trade and economic cooperation is a priority for the relations between Russia and China.

PACE Committee on Legal Affairs and Human Rights adopts statement on unlawful blockade of Lachin Corridor by Azerbaijan

Save

Share

 16:04, 22 March 2023

YEREVAN, MARCH 22, ARMENPRESS. The Committee on Legal Affairs and Human Rights of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) has adopted a statement regarding the unlawful blockade of Lachin Corridor by Azerbaijan, Armenian delegate to PACE Vladimir Vardanyan said on March 22.

Vardanyan said he will present details soon.

Timeframe of new foreign ministerial meeting between Armenia, Azerbaijan and Russia under discussion – Lavrov

Save

Share

 16:41,

YEREVAN, MARCH 20, ARMENPRESS. Russia expects that the trilateral (Armenia, Russia, Azerbaijan) task force on regional unblocking will soon reach concrete agreements, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov has said.

“Russia also favors the intensification of the work of the border delimitation commission with Moscow’s consultative support. Moscow is also ready to support the signing of a peace treaty between Yerevan and Baku,” Lavrov added during a joint press conference with Armenian FM Ararat Mirzoyan in Moscow.

He said that the Armenian side reiterated PM Nikol Pashinyan’s statement on readiness to meet and now the new timeframe for a meeting between the Russian, Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign ministers is under discussion.

“We will soon choose the timeframe convenient to the three ministers,” Lavrov said.

PM Nikol Pashinyan holds meeting with former Secretary-General of NATO Anders Fogh Rasmussen

Save

Share

 17:17, 13 March 2023

YEREVAN, MARCH 13, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan held a meeting with former Secretary-General of NATO, founder of the Rasmussen Global international political consultancy firm Anders Fogh Rasmussen and his delegation.

Pashinyan and Rasmussen warmly recalled their meeting during the Munich Security Conference on February 18 this year, the Prime Minister’s Office said in a read-out. PM Pashinyan and Rasmussen exchanged views around regional developments and security challenges.

Issues related to security and stability in South Caucasus were discussed, and both sides attached importance to continual efforts in this direction.

Azerbaijan again falsely accuses Armenia and Artsakh of opening fire in renewed disinformation campaign

Save

Share

 13:10,

YEREVAN, MARCH 15, ARMENPRESS. The defense ministries of Armenia and Artsakh (Nagorno Karabakh) warned on Wednesday that the Azerbaijani defense ministry is again spreading disinformation.

The Azeri defense ministry accused the Armed Forces of Armenia and the Defense Army of Artsakh of opening fire. Yerevan and Stepanakert denied the accusations, labeling it as disinformation.

In a statement, the Ministry of Defense of Armenia said that “the statement released by the Defense Ministry of Azerbaijan claiming that from 00:15 to 02:30 March 15 the units of the Armed Forces of Armenia opened fire at Azerbaijani positions deployed in the eastern part of the Armenian-Azerbaijani borderline is untrue.”

In turn, the Defense Ministry of Artsakh said that “the statement released by the Defense Ministry of Azerbaijan claiming that Defense Army units periodically opened fire on March 15 at Azerbaijani positions deployed in the occupied territories of Martuni and Askeran regions in the Republic of Artsakh is yet another disinformation.”

Relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan should be settled as soon as possible. Scholz

Save

Share

 20:13,

YERERVAN, MARCH 14, ARMENPRESS. Germany is ready to provide its support in the direction of finding a long-term and feasible solution to the situation around Nagorno-Karabakh for the benefit of the local residents, ARMENPRESS reports, TASS informed, referring to the statement made by German Chancellor Olaf Scholz during a joint press conference with Azerbaijani president Ilham Aliyev.

“Our joint goal should be finding a long-term and feasible solution to this conflict for the benefit of the people of Nagorno-Karabakh,” he said, adding that the peaceful settlement of the conflict should be based on preserving the territorial integrity of Armenia and Azerbaijan.

Speaking about the placement of the European Union Civilian Mission (EUMA) in Armenia, the head of the German government noted that Berlin supports it and ensures the leadership of the mission. The German Chancellor noted that the settlement of relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan should take place as soon as possible.

CivilNet: Azerbaijan invites Nagorno-Karabakh officials to Baku to discuss ‘reintegration’

CIVILNET.AM

13 Mar, 2023 10:03

  • Former NATO chief Anders Fogh Rasmussen held talks with Armenian Defense Minister Suren Papikyan in Yerevan.
  • Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Russian President Vladimir Putin discussed the crisis in Nagorno-Karabakh during a telephone conversation.
  • Azerbaijan invited representatives from Nagorno-Karabakh to Baku for talks on what the Azerbaijani side described as “reintegration” and the “implementation of infrastructure projects in Karabakh.”

Music: Local composer’s ‘An Armenian Trilogy’ documentary to premiere on DPTV

March 9 2023
Local composer’s ‘An Armenian Trilogy’ documentary to premiere on DPTV
PUBLISHED: March 8, 2023 at 12:07 p.m. | UPDATED: March 8, 2023 at 12:08 p.m.

Dan Yessian released “The Freedom, The Fear and The Faith: An Armenian Trilogy” nearly eight years ago, and it’s remained a high point in a career that’s full of awards and achievements.

In 2014 the Farmington Hills-based composer was asked by his church priest to write a piece commemorating the centennial of the genocide in which 1.5 million Armenian families were murdered by the Turkish Ottomans. Yessian created an evocative three-movement, 22-minute duet between piano and violin, composed on one of the late Burt Bacharach’s old pianos. It was performed in 2017 by the Armenian Philharmonic and became the subject of a documentary by Yessian that will have its broadcast premiere at 7:30 p.m. Sunday, March 12, on Detroit Public Television (Channel 56).

“My objective was to musically interpret the feelings of my grandparents, whose stories reflected their escape from Turkey,” explains Yessian, 78, founder of Yessian Music, which also has offices and studios, run by his sons, in New York, Los Angeles and Hamburg, Germany. And while most of his composing work is shorter form for commercial clients, “An Armenian Trilogy” allowed him to stretch himself beyond that.

“This is the culmination of all my musical experience,” Yessian notes. “It was quite a feat for me in trying to make something interesting enough that would portray what (the genocide) was — which I never thought I’d be capable of doing. So this is something I could leave for my family, and for posterity, per se. It’s a passion.”

Yessian will appear during Sunday’s broadcast of the documentary, interviewed by DPTV’s Fred Nahat. The “Trilogy” itself is available via Amazon, iTunes and Spotify.