`Armenian Cause became topical issue in Turkey’s domestic policy"

Aysor, Armenia
Oct 2 2010

`Armenian Cause became topical issue in Turkey’s domestic policy”

The namaz in Ani and `secret’ fixing the cross atop the Surb Khach
Church are interrelated, and we wonder why Turkey did it, Deputy
Director of the Caucasus Institute, political scientist Sergey
Minasyan told a press conference.

`I believe that if the cross were fixed according to an agreement,
Turkey would gain much more in information field, in Armenian-Turkish
process, Turkey-Europe and Turkey-US relations,’ expert said.

According to Minasyan, `the Armenian Cause has become a topical issue
in Turkey’s domestic policy, and fixing the cross was Turkish
authorities’ hasty response to the namaz offered in the Cathedral of
Ani.’

From: A. Papazian

Namaz in Ani Cathedral provocation: Euronews

Panorama, Armenia
Oct 2 2010

Namaz in Ani Cathedral provocation: Euronews

Euronews aired Friday the `Namaz in the Cathedral of the Arncient
Armenian Capital of Ani’. The action was initiated by the Turkish
opposition `National Movement’ Party, the third power in Turkey’s
parliament.

According to Euronews, Turkish sources have considered this action as
a provocation directed to the complication of Yerevan – Ankara
dialogue.

`Namaz in Ani Cathedral was the response of the Turkish nationalist
forces to the reconstruction works conducted in Sourb Khach (St. Cross
) Church of Akhtamar. The step has not been accepted by both sides
unilaterally. Though Turkish nationalists consider the reconstruction
of the church as a compromise, official Yerevan points out that the
church has merely a status of a historical monument,’ Euronews report
said.

From: A. Papazian

BAKU: Azerbaijan concerned over construction of nuclear station in A

news.az, Azerbaijan
Oct 2 2010

Azerbaijan concerned over construction of nuclear station in Armenia
Sat 02 October 2010 04:36 GMT | 7:36 Local Time

Khalaf Khalafov Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs of Azerbaijan
Khalaf Khalafov met Jan Kubiš, Executive Secretary of UN Economic
Commission for Europe in Geneva.

Press service of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs reports, the sides
emphasized the high level of cooperation within this organization,
successful activity in the fields of energy, transportation,
environment, customs, information-communication technologies, trade
and other spheres within the UN Economic Commission, as well as
importance of the elaboration of the new projects in the different
spheres of economy and development of cooperation in this direction.

The deputy minister expressed Azerbaijan’s concern over the
construction of a new nuclear power station in Armenia to the
Executive Secretary of the UN Economic Commission and said that the
new nuclear power station constructed on the basis of old one `
Metsamor nuclear power station would be a source of serious threats to
the environment and socio-economic situation in the region.

APA

From: A. Papazian

Mosaic IV: A Celebration of Sound at The Ford Amphitheatre

Mosaic IV: A Celebration of Sound at The Ford Amphitheatre

Friday, October 1st, 2010
by Asbarez

The Hamazkayin Armenian Educational and Cultural Association Western
Region will stage its successful concert series Mosaic on October 17
at the Forth Amphitheatre. In its fourth iteration, Mosaic has become
a staple of the Armenian community music scene. We caught up with
Mosaic IV organizers Tamar Abkarian and Lori Tatoulian, who discussed
the acts that will be featured at the concert, as well as some
surprises in store for the community.

Visit the Mosaic Facebook page for links to all the band pages, audio
samples and video clips
RSVP at the Mosaic IV event page on Facebook
Visit ItsMySeat.com to learn more about the bands and purchase tickets
Tickets are $20, $35 and $50. Proceeds from the event will benefit
Hamazkayin’s annual scholarship program. For sponsorship opportunities
and ticket discounts for organizations and groups of 15 or more,
please contact [email protected].
****

Asbarez: What is Mosaic and how has it evolved to its fourth carnation?

Tamar Abkarian: Mosaic is an opportunity to promote and instill
cultural appreciation through the integration of melodies, music, and
lyrics from the past with revolutionized means of expression. The
objective of Hamazkayin’s Mosaic Concerts is to celebrate the diverse
sounds of our culture and its progression today by introducing and
promoting the broad range of musical talents of young Armenians.

For the past three years, the Mosaic Concerts have been able to
introduce to the community the musical talents of our youth and their
interest in their roots, as well as their fusion of the old and the
new – something the community might otherwise not have known was
taking place.

Asbarez: What sets Mosaic apart from other concert series?

Lori Tatoulian: Mosaic presents emerging armenian musicians that take
armenian music and reinterpret it using current perspectives and
trends. This concert offers the community an eclectic array of genres
all in one night. The audience will enjoy alternative folk, jazz,
trip-hop, classical and rock all fused with armenian sounds. Mosaic
performers are known to be excellent musicians at the cutting edge of
musical creativity.

The past three Mosaic concerts not only introduced to the community
the musical talents of our youth but also provided these up-and-coming
artists the exposure that has already proven to benefit their future
success.

T.A.: What also sets the Mosaic Concert apart from other concert
series is the special thought given to hosts. We avoid the typical
hosts that are usually hosting most of the communities’ events by
having individuals who are vibrant and who bring an extra flavor to
the show. The evening will be hosted by actress/ playwright, Lory
Tatoulian, who with her comedic genius will have the audience laughing
throughout the night as well as keep the program flowing.

Asbarez: How do you choose the artists?

T.A.: With a lot of research and thought! The artists are chosen by
genre and style of music. The committee is a fairly young group of
individuals who want to put together a program with local talents as
well as talents from different parts of the United States and the
world that has cohesion and contrast at the same time with a
performance line up that will keep the interest of the young audience
as well as some older audience who appreciate the various young
talents, enjoy music and take pleasure in an event unique within the
community.

In the previous years, we’ve had performers from the East Coast such
as Zulal. Last year we had Lavach, a very talented band from France!
This year we are pleased to announce that for the first time we will
be showcasing five of LA’s finest bands at the Mosaic IV Concert:
Viza, Armenian Space Station, Echocell, A Splinter and Armenian Public
Radio.

The ability to have all local bands indicates that our young Los
Angeles based musical talents have progressed and successfully
translated its intrinsic cultural surroundings into musical
expressions.

Asbarez: Tell us a little about each of the performers?

L.T.: Go on a journey with global rockers, VIZA, who just recently
returned from an international tour with Serj Tankian previously from
System of a Down.

Experience Armenian Space Station’s epic compostions incorporating
Khatchadourian stylings performed by Greg Hosharian on keyboard with
the metal drum beats of Barrett Yeretsian

Feel the fusion of the organic with the electronic as Belinda Kazanci
from ECHOCELL provides the cure for our soul hangover.

Reminisce with A SPLINTER as Ashot Tadevosian sings the humorous
stories of our Armenian realities.

Enjoy ARMENIAN PUBLIC RADIO’s acoustic revival of Armenian folk
melodies performed by Saro Koujakian, Ryan Demirjian and Mher Ajamian.

Asbarez: How does each performer bring to life Armenian culture?

L.T.: Each performer’s origin and experiences shape the music that
they create. This concert presents the mosaic of influences that
inspire the current generation of armenian musicians and introduces
the evolution of our armenian music and culture.

*****’

Interview With Armenian Public Radio Members Mher Ajamian, Saro
Koujakian and Ryan Demirjian

Asbarez: How did the group come together?

Mher Ajamian: I was inspired while I was producing a concert for
Vicken Tarpinian last year. So I contacted Saro. Being cousins, we
had been a few bands together in the past ranging from rock to
acoustic. It had been a while since he had left Element, and was ready
to start up a new project. Ryan and I had played together in another
rock band, Sight of Sound, and I had always liked his style. He
worked well with us right from the get go.

Asbarez: What kind of music were each of you listening to growing up?
What was the first concert you attended?

Saro Koujakian: Guns and Roses, Pearl Jam.

Ryan Demirjian: Metallica, Megadeath, Beatles.

M.A.: R.E.M., James Taylor, Tracy Chapman, Armenian Influences: Vicken
Tarpinian (Hartar), Zulal, Haig Yazdjian, Datevik Hovanissyan.

Asbarez: Was there a certain `a ha!’ moment when you knew that music
was going to be a career for you?

M.A.: Still waiting on it! I think we’d all be financially better off
if we were able to cut music out of our life.

M.A.: Music is a passion for us and hopefully it will always remain
that way I don’t think it imperative for it to become a career.

Asbarez: Tell us about your creative process… What kind of environment
do you have to be in to make music?

M.A.: You need good input to have good output. So if we want good
Armenian music to come out, what better thing to put in than good
Armenian food? I think we all enjoy the family atmosphere. Being an
acoustic band we can practice pretty much anywhere, so it’s great to
be able to practice at each other’s house and have the family around.
The parents cook for us and it’s just a great casual atmosphere to
work in.

Asbarez: How would you describe the sound of APR?

M.A.: 70’s American Folk, (i.e. Simon and Garfunkel) meets, 90’s
Grunge Blues (i.e. Pearl Jam, Alice in Chains) meets Armenian Folk
(i.e. Zulal, Vicken Tarpinian)

Asbarez: What can fans expect from a live APR show?

M.A.: We’re pretty mellow. We sing songs that have time-tested
melodies, so everyone is going to love it. With us it’s about good
musicianship and expressing ourselves.

Asbarez: Tell us about your first live performance as a band.

M.A.: Wasn’t too long ago, we closed out at `Siroun Storytellers’ a
storytelling event where different individuals get up and read a story
from their own life experiences. The theme this time was their travels
to Armenia. We played about six songs at the end of the night, the
audience loved it.

Asbarez: Share with us your take on the current music scene.

M.A.: iTunes has really put the power of the business into the artists
hand. So I think we’re going to see a lot of good artists emerge that
will produce themselves. I think people can still appreciate quality,
and as a band if you can produce it on a consistent basis, it’s not
too hard to develop a following.

And now with Facebook and YouTube it’s so much easier to reach the
masses. And because you don’t have the record companies taking a huge
cut, you don’t have to sell nearly as much.I think a band like VIZA is
a perfect example of a successful band of the future.

Asbarez: Do you have a dream city that you’d like to play in?

M.A.: Montreal or Lebanon for the good Middle Eastern food.
Asbarez: Is there one artist or group out there that would be your
dream collaboration? Why?

M.A.: I think it would be great to have some feminine energy infused
into the band. So, Zulal, because we love their style and because of
their inspiration to us.

Asbarez: What’s one thing we’d be surprised to hear about APR?

M.A.: Saro, the singer lives and works in Vegas. (He also likes to
practice in his underwear when he can).
Asbarez: So, what is next for APR?

M.A.: Finish up recording our cd, hopefully by spring. And start
playing shows, here, there and everywhere.

*****

Interview with Armenian Space Station

Asbarez: How did the group come together?

Barrett Yeretsian: Greg and I were writing music for TV, film and
video games and we sort of stumbled upon the A.S.S. sound,
unexpectedly. My uncle introduced me to a guy from Armenia who heads
a nonprofit there and he heard a demo of `Commence Primary Ignition’
in my car and he flipped out, saying, `Armenia needs to hear this
music!’ Two weeks later, they booked our flights to Armenia and we
played our first show there last October in front of 1,500 people.
Clint and Phil joined the group as soon as we got back to the US.

Asbarez: What kind of music were each of you listening to growing up?
What was the first concert you attended?

Greg Hosharian: Classical Composers – Mozart, Bach, Beethoven,
Khachaturian, Rachmaninoff, Chopin as well as the Doors, Dream
Theater, Rush, Metallica to name a few and Armenian music – I love
just about every style of music!

B.Y.: Old school Metallica, Pantera, the Beatles,, Deftones, Ozomatli,
Dream Theater, classical music, down tempo, almost everything!

Asbarez: Was there a certain `a ha!’ moment when you knew that music
was going to be a career for you?

G.H.: I learned to play music as I learned to walk, since my father,
Composer/Conductor Edward Hosharian, instilled in me the love of music
at a very early age. I always wanted to do what he did and how he
made people feel with his music. Two other `a ha’ moments were when
my brother Peter took me to my first Rush concert and when my friend
David Mosikian introduced me to the Doors. All of this contributed to
my musical journey!

B.Y.: It was when I was at the Burning Man festival when I was 17. I
walked into the middle of the desert with a hand drum and started
jamming by myself. Within minutes, 20 other drummers and fire dancers
formed a circle around me and joined in …moments later, there were
hundreds of people dancing, singing, throwing fire and just going
crazy. At that point, I truly felt the power of music, how it brought
people and how inseparable it was from me.

Asbarez: Tell us about your creative process… What kind of environment
do you have to be in to make music?

B.Y.: Greg and I are unique in that we are always writing. When we
get together, it is pretty effortless. We each come up with ideas on
piano, guitar, bass or drums and just start jamming…a few hours later,
we have a nine-minute song.
Asbarez: How would you describe the sound of Armenian Space Station?

B.Y.: Put simply: Mozart meets old-school Metallica with an Armenian twist.
Asbarez: What can fans expect from a live Armenian Space Station show?

B.Y.: A lot of energy and a very unique experience…everyone who comes
to our shows says that they have never heard or seen anything like it.

Asbarez: Tell us about your first live performance as a band. How have
you changed since that first show to where you are now?

G.H.: Our first performance was a sold-out show in Armenia in front of
1,500 people as a part of the Sunchild Festival, which was meant to
raise awareness about environmental issues to young kids in Armenia.
It was surreal to debut in our homeland, something that we will
forever cherish and never forget. Our second show was in front of a
sold-out crowd at the Roxy in Hollywood…so not much has changed.

Asbarez: Share with us your take on the current music scene?

B.Y.: It’s a great time to be doing what we are doing. There is so
much change taking place in the music industry. We believe those
artists who are unique and true to themselves will be the artists of
the future.

Asbarez: Do you have a dream city that you’d like to play in?

B.Y.: Tokyo!

G.H.: Antarctica – on top of a glacier (or next to)
Asbarez: Is there one artist or group out there that would be your
dream collaboration?

G.H.: Beethoven and the Doors!

B.Y.: The Beatles!

Asbarez: What’s one thing we’d be surprised to hear about Armenian
Space Station?

B.Y.: The fact that we had no clue that the acronym spelled A.S.S.
when we named the group!

Asbarez: So, what is next for Armenian Space Station?

G.H.: After the Mosaic show, we will be getting back in the studio to
write and produce our next set of songs. You can expect us to push
ourselves further in every direction. The new songs will be crazier,
heavier, more beautiful and more progressive all at the same time.

From: A. Papazian

Planned dolphin tank in Yerevan raises concerns

Attraction or Exploitation?: Planned dolphin tank in Yerevan raises concerns

News | 30.09.10 | 14:57

NAZIK ARMENAKYAN
ArmeniaNow

Gohar Abrahamyan
ArmeniaNow intern

News that a tank for holding dolphins and other sea animals is being
built in Yerevan has raised concern of ecologists and animal-rights
activists who say Armenia is not suitable for such an attraction.

The construction of the circular tank started last month, initiated by
a Ukrainian organization – Nerum – on land leased by the Yerevan
Municipality. It is being constructed in Komitas Park, near the
`Pantheon’.

Silva Adamyan, Head of the Center for Bird Lovers NGO, says that
Armenian climate conditions are not favorable for having dolphins
here.

`It is an exploitation of an animal,’ she says. Further, no public
discussion has been held on the use of public space. `Is there an
expert’s opinion? Let them submit the documents allowing the import of
dolphins.’

Even those who welcome having the old park renovated, say that
renovation of the run-down site should not be at the expense of
endangering animals.

Environmentalist Knarik Hovhannisyan points out, too, that the Water
Resources Management Agency of the Ministry of Nature Protection of
Armenia has not been advised of the dolphin tank, which would require
1,500 cubic meters of water.

`This means that the water may be supplied by `Yerevan Jur’ (Yerevan
Water) Company, and this means that the dolphin tank will be
constructed at the expense of Yerevan residents’ drinking water,’
Hovhannisyan says.
While environmentalists try to find out whether legal requirements
have been met, construction of the tank continues.

Alexander Merlyan, Director of the Ukrainian Nerum Organization says
the tank will be ready for use `in about two months’.

If plans are fulfilled, the tank – five meters deep and 18 meters
radius — would house four dolphins, one sea lion and two seals. The
complex would be built to accommodate 900 visitors.

From: A. Papazian

Armenian Church Outraged By Turkish Nationalist Prayer

Armenian Church Outraged By Turkish Nationalist Prayer
Saturday, 02 October 2010 17:20
Azatutyun:

The Armenian Apostolic Church on Saturday expressed outrage at a
Muslim religious service held in an Armenian holy site in eastern
Turkey, calling it a serious blow to efforts to improve
Turkish-Armenian relations.

In a written statement, the church’s Mother See in the Armenian town
of Echmiadzin strongly condemned the Turkish government for allowing
the country’s leading ultranationalist party to hold a Friday prayer
at the 11th century Holly Virgin Cathedral in Ani, the ruined capital
of a medieval Armenian kingdom.

`This action is a political provocation that has nothing to do with
spiritual-virtuous feelings and religious freedom and rights,’ read
the statement. `At the same time it is an attempt to negate the
Armenian origin of the Ani cathedral, which was deprived of prayer as
a consequence of the [1915] Armenian Genocide.’

`It is also absolutely unacceptable to make a Christian shrine
available for `namaz’ (Muslim prayer) while consistently forbidding
legal heirs to the Christian heritage [in Turkey] to perform worship
in their own temples,’ it said. `Thus, the Turkish authorities are
continuing their steps aimed at destroying Armenian monuments and
misappropriating historical Armenian holy sites and cultural
treasures.’

`It is also evident that with this step Turkey is once again scuttling
efforts by Armenia and the international community to establish
Turkish-Armenian dialogue and normalize Turkish-Armenian relations,’
added the statement.

The Armenian Church and its supreme head, Catholicos Garegin II,
similarly condemned Ankara for failing to restore a cross atop another
medieval Armenian church located in the same region in time for a
landmark mass held there on September 19. Garegin abandoned his
earlier plans to send two high-ranking clerics to the ceremony, in
protest against the delay.

The cross was reportedly placed on the dome of the 10th century Holy
Cross church on Akhtamar island in Lake Van on Thursday.

The Ani and Akhtamar churches are among few surviving examples of the
ancient Armenian civilization in what is now eastern Turkey. Hundreds
of Armenian churches built there since the early Middle Ages were
destroyed, ransacked or turned into mosques during and after 1915
slaughter of more than one million Armenians in the Ottoman Empire.

The Armenian government has not yet officially reacted to the Ani prayer.

Original link:

From: A. Papazian

http://www.azatutyun.am/content/article/2174645.html

BAKU: Armenian serviceman killed in Azerbaijan’s occupied lands

Armenian serviceman killed in Azerbaijan’s occupied lands

02 October 2010 [14:35] – Today.Az

Another Armenian serviceman has been killed at a military unit No. 2
located in Azerbaijan’s occupied lands, Armenia-based `Hraparak’
newspaper reported.

“As a result of careless handling of the service arm’, soldier
Tigranyan mortally wounded his fellow soldier Hozbekyan. The incident
is under investigation,’ the newspaper says.

This is the second death in recent times in the same military unit.
This murder shows that the officers who were punished after a previous
murder are not the perpetrators of the incident. They were only “weak
links” and scapegoats. Otherwise, the second case in the same military
unit would not have occurred,” the newspaper says.

/Day.Az/

URL:

From: A. Papazian

http://www.today.az/news/regions/74431.html

AEF To Honor Mina and Hacob Shirvanian

AEF To Honor Mina and Hacob Shirvanian

Friday, October 1st, 2010
by Asbarez

GLENDALE – The Armenian Educational Foundation will honor Hacob and Mina
Shirvanian with the Lifetime Service Award at AEF’s 60th Anniversary
Gala on November 6, 2010. The Shirvanians hold the distinction of
being the longest serving members of the AEF. For 50 years, they have
actively participated and supported the organization, both of them
serving on AEF’s Board of Directors. The Shirvanians have been
instrumental in helping AEF successfully achieve its mission of
providing financial assistance to Armenian students and educational
institutions. It was under Hacob Shirvanian’s presidency that the
funding was raised and the vision became a reality in establishing the
AEF Chair in Modern Armenian History at UCLA.

The Shirvanians have not only volunteered countless hours in support
of AEF’s programs, but also are major contributors to AEF’s projects.
They have financed the renovation of five schools in Armenia, Artsakh,
and Javakhk, purchased computers and school supplies and sponsored
numerous scholarships. Since the independence of Armenia, the
Shirvanians have returned to the homeland on numerous occasions,
visited AEF renovated schools, continued to provide financial support
to those schools and participated in the disbursement of scholarships.

Since arriving in Los Angeles in 1956, the Shirvanians have been very
active in the Armenian community life. Mina Shirvanian helped
establish the Armenian Society of Los Angeles (Iranahye) and was one
of its first presidents. Hacob Shirvanian served several years as the
Vice President of the Ferrahian High School Board of Governors. They
have supported numerous organizations, including the Western Prelacy
Of the Armenian Apostolic Church of America, Ferrahian High School,
Armenian National Committee, Armenian Relief Society, Armenia Fund,
and many others.
For their service to the community, the Shirvanians have been
recognized by Catholicos Karekin II with the Knight of Cilicia Award
and Catholicos Aram I with the Prince of Cilicia Award. The
Shirvanians were presented Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh’s highest
civilian medal by Former Karabakh President, Arkady Ghukasian. They
were also honored by the ANCA Western Region with the Legacy Award and
the Adventist Hospital Foundation with the Philanthropy Award.

The Shirvanians have also been active in U.S. politics. Mr. Shirvanian
has the distinction of being the only Armenian who was appointed by
five consecutive governors – Ronald Reagan, Jerry Brown, George
Deukmejian, Pete Wilson and Gray Davis – to various state boards and
commissions.

The AEF 60th Anniversary Banquet will be held on Saturday, November
6th at the new Ritz Carlton/JW Marriot at LA Live in downtown Los
Angeles. For more information, sponsorship opportunities or tickets,
please contact Diane Cabraloff at (310) 729-1552 or Melody Petrossian
at (818) 434-1167.

From: A. Papazian

US Signals It Prefers Nabucco Over Other Pipelines

US Signals It Prefers Nabucco Over Other Pipelines

Friday, October 1st, 2010
by Asbarez

ISTANBUL (Hurriyet)-The United States on Friday signaled for the first
time that Nabucco is its preferred planned natural gas pipeline among
the project’s other rivals.

`We made it clear that we support the Southern Corridor. We also made
it clear that the Nabucco pipeline is preferable strategically and
politically. It will be hard to answer whether these projects will be
complementary or competitive since the initial gas is coming from the
Caspian,’ Richard Morningstar, special envoy of the United States
Secretary of State for Eurasian Energy, told a small of journalists in
Istanbul.

The U.S. has been a strong supporter of the Nabucco pipeline project,
planned to be built from Turkey to Austria and to transport 31 billion
cubic meters of natural gas.

But there are some other projects such as Interconnector Turkey Greece
Italy, or ITGI, and Trans-Adriatic Pipeline, or TAP. The ITGI is
planned with a capacity of 8 billion cubic meters and TAP with 10
billion cubic meters. The U.S. had until Friday declined to voice its
preference among the projects.

The resources in Central Asia and the Middle East are limited but with
the development of the second phase in the Shah Deniz field in
Azerbaijan, and with Iraq’s participation, the gas supplies could
increase dramatically, Morningstar added on the sidelines of the Black
Sea Energy and Economic Forum in Istanbul.

The decision, however, of giving the gas to a pipeline will be a
commercial one and will be made by the Shah Deniz consortium, he said.
Morningstar ruled out the possibility of Iranian gas supplies for
Nabucco or any other Western-backed pipeline projects.

`For me, the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan project was a dream. Now Nabucco is a
dream. Many countries are involved in this project. … We want to be a
helpful bystander,’ Morningstar said when asked about the difference
between the BTC and Nabucco pipelines.

He rejected the notion that there was a contradiction between the
Turkish government’s decisions to become involved in both the Nabucco
pipeline project and South Stream. The U.S. has no concerns regarding
the increased energy cooperation between Turkey and Russia, he also
added.

Within energy pipeline diplomacy, there is one country that has been
left out in the cold: Armenia. Due to an illegal blockade imposed by
its neighbors, Turkey and Azerbaijan, Armenia has been excluded from
the major energy projects in the region.

`I have fond feelings regarding Armenia. That is a shame that Armenia
is not part of these projects,’ Morningstar said. `If somehow an
agreement is reached, Armenia can become a full participant in the
region. And that is in everybody’s interest.’

It will take time, but eventually Armenia will participate in all
regional energy and economic projects, Morningstar said when asked
about whether there is a specific project that the U.S. wants Armenia
to become involved in.

From: A. Papazian

Liturgy in Holy Cross proved Armenians of Istanbul have not changed

Liturgy in Holy Cross Church proved Armenians of Istanbul have not
changed for 95 years
The danger of what happened on September19 is that Turkey might turn a
couple of more churches into a museum, allow divine services there and
then with a clear conscience pursue the policy of denying the Armenian
Genocide.

The liturgy in Holy Cross Church on the island of Akhtamaris now over,
generating many questions and, unfortunately, aconviction that the
ArmenianPatriarchate of Constantinoplenever had the courage or the
sound mind to refuse the service. We say unfortunately because
Archbishop Aram Ateshyan and the clergy of the Patriarchate become
partof the much-advertised Turkish show under the name of `tolerant
Turkey’. And, again, unfortunately, they were not the only ones there.

September 21, 2010
PanARMENIAN.Net –

With an enviable masochism and with almost a reverence, a number of
Armenian media sources successfully replaced the Turkish ones,
enthusiastically describing the meetings in Van and the liturgy
itself. Probably, they sincerely believed they were performing their
professional duties. In fact, no one argues, but there must be a limit
to everything, and in this case it would be sensible to follow the
example of the Turkish media, which limited itself to the mere
statement of the fact and wrote the same things as before the liturgy.
Certain representatives of St. Echmiadzin acted quite like the
Armenian press too.

`Declaring that holding a liturgy in the church Holy Cross on Akhtamar
Island is just another show of Turkey, Armenia has turned this issue
into a subject of speculation,’ at a press conference in Yerevan said
Archimandrite of Ararat Diocese of the Armenian Apostolic Church,
Komitas Hovnanian. Moreover, the archimandrite considers it wrong that
the Armenians should not have taken part in the liturgy.

In his revelations the Holy Father went even further, saying that it
was exactly Armenia that achieved conduct of a liturgy in the Curch of
Holy Cross. It would be difficult to think up a better absurdity.
Simply Turkey decided that it was necessary and she did it. And on the
whole, it is all the same for the Government of this country how many
Armenians were present – 100 or 10 thousand. The most important point
is that the liturgy was held, giving Ankara a bargaining chip in the
negotiations, in the EU, and finally in the USA. Only a very limited
person for whom the world ends at the threshold of his house would not
notice it. Again unfortunately, so it is for the majority of the
clergymen of the Armenian Apostolic Church. The only thing that
Echmiadzin proved to be capable of was the refusal to participate in
the liturgy. Even so, it can be assumed that this decision was made
after the boycott of Catholicos of the Great House of Cilicia, Aram I.
And surprisingly the cold attitude of Turkey to this action, which can
hardly be called a liturgy, did not put anyone to their guard. The
Armenians of Istanbul obviously expected some high-ranking official
from Ankara, but no one came, apart from the administration of the
Vilayet of Van. And why should there be? The church is restored,
UNESCO and the world are satisfied or pretend to be satisfied. What
else is necessary? But nobody learnt that the road to the church is
lined with broken khachkars (stone-crosses), graves of priests are
desecrated and the entire monastery complex, except for the church
remained in ruins and no one will ever think of recover it. Not to
mention thousands of destroyed and desecrated temples.

The last Archbishop of the Armenian Patriarchate of Constantinople
before the World War I, Maghakia Ormanian, still in 1913 warned his
congregation about the danger and untrustworthiness of the Ottomans.
The congregation, alas, would not listen to reason of late. We
witnessed the awful results – half a million killed, half a million
scattered. And how many were forcibly expelled! Their descendants now
suddenly `recovered their sight’ and began to talk about their
Armenian roots. And we, the residents of Armenia, almost with
tenderness begin to talk about some Turkish leader, claiming he is
actually an Armenian, and not a Turk. Who do we deceive and why is a
rhetorical question.

The danger of what happened on September19 is that Turkey might turn a
couple of more churches into a museum, allow divine services there and
then with a clear conscience pursue the policy of denying the Armenian
Genocide. And we have no doubt that things will go exactly that way…

Generally it must be said that the Armenians still live on myths about
Turkey as a state and the Armenian community of Istanbul. In
particular, the community is presented as a hostage in the hands of
the Turkish state, although this is true only partially. In fact, the
Armenians of Istanbul do not live so badly, the main thing for them to
remember is not to stand out from the Ottoman mass. And we must admit
that this community, formerly led by Archbishop Mesrop Mutafyan, and
now by Aram Ateshyan, has so far been doing it quite successfully. The
logic is simple – we’ll sit still and nothing will happen. The
Istanbul Armenians never learned the lesson of 1915, and the proof of
it is the murder of Hrant Dink, the threats against the patriarch and
common members of the community. It comes down to the fact that editor
of the Zhamanak daily Ara Kochunyan does not use the term `genocide’
in the pages of his publications… In this regard, very remarkable
are the words of Armenian poet, MP Grigor Zohrap in the night of 23 –
24 of April 1915. When he was told that he must escape since a
massacre was ahead, he replied: `Really? The Turks are our friends.
Yesterday I was playing backgammon with Talat, he would have told
me…’. 95 years has passed since then and nothing has changed: all
the Armenians are naive and believe in the power of applications,
letters, protests; the Turks continue their policy of eradication of
ermenimilliyet. It will always be so, until we have priests like
Archimandrite Hovnanian and pastors like the Patriarch of
Constantinople.

Karine Ter-Sahakyan

From: A. Papazian