X
    Categories: News

Israeli strategic analyst Shay Gal calls on the State of Israel to recognize t

Nov 21, 2026

URISHLEM (JERUSALEM) — Israeli strategic analyst Shay Gal has called on Israel to formally recognize the genocides committed against the Syriac (Aramean-Assyrian-Chaldean), Armenian, and Pontic Greek peoples during the final decades of the Ottoman Empire. Gal argues that historical truth should not be compromised by diplomatic or strategic considerations.

In an interview with publisher Christos Konstantinidis, Shay Gal addressed the question of historical recognition in combination with broader geopolitical developments in the Eastern Mediterranean, including relations between Israel, Greece and Cyprus, and Turkey’s regional ambitions.

The discussion took on particular significance when Konstantinidis, drawing on his Pontic Greek heritage, challenged Israel’s reluctance to acknowledge the mass atrocities committed against Christian populations under Ottoman rule and during the subsequent rise of Turkish nationalism.

Shay Gal, the grandson of a Holocaust survivor, responded by drawing a connection between the responsibility to preserve the memory of the Holocaust and the obligation to acknowledge the suffering of other peoples. “As the grandson of a Holocaust survivor, I understand the duty of remembrance. A Jewish state does not bargain with the truth,” strategic analyst Gal said.

His remarks place renewed attention on the campaign for international recognition of the Sayfo Genocide against the Syriacs, and the Armenian and Pontic Greek genocides during the First World War. 

Recognition Beyond the Armenian Genocide

Gal’s position builds on an argument he had already advanced publicly in June 2026, when Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar announced plans to bring forward a proposal concerning recognition of the Armenian Genocide. At the time, Gal welcomed the initiative but warned against limiting recognition to one people. “The Armenian Genocide was not an isolated tragedy. The Assyrian Genocide was not an appendix. The Greek Genocide, including the Greeks of Pontus, was not a footnote,” he wrote.

He described the atrocities against Armenians, Syriacs, and Pontic Greeks as part of what he called the “Thirty-Year Genocide”, spanning the Hamidian massacres of the 1890s, the Young Turk period, and the early years of the Turkish Republic.

Gal argued that successive political authorities had presided over a broader historical process of persecution, extermination, dispossession, and denial. He maintained that recognizing only one part of that history would leave the experiences of other targeted communities inadequately acknowledged.

The question has also gained momentum through organized advocacy. In July, the European Syriac Union (ESU) formally appealed to Israel’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, urging the government to extend its proposed recognition to include the Syriacs and Pontic Greek peoples.

The organization said that the suffering of these communities was inseparable from the broader history of mass violence against Christian populations in the final years of the Ottoman Empire. It called on both the Israeli government and the Knesset to ensure that recognition reflected the experiences of all affected peoples. 

Turkey, Azerbaijan, and the Limits of Diplomatic Calculations

In the interview, Gal also addressed the geopolitical considerations that have influenced Israel’s approach to genocide recognition. He identified Israel’s strategic relationships with Turkey and Azerbaijan as important factors behind its historical reluctance to take a formal position.

Turkey has consistently rejected the characterization of the Ottoman-era massacres as genocide, while Azerbaijan has also not recognized the Sayfo.

Gal contends that diplomatic partnerships should not determine whether historical atrocities are acknowledged. He pointed to Israel’s ability to maintain strategic relations with Azerbaijan while developing closer cooperation with Armenia as evidence that diplomatic engagement and historical recognition need not be mutually exclusive.

The issue has become particularly relevant following Israel’s own deliberations over Armenian Genocide recognition.

In June 2026, the Israeli Cabinet unanimously approved Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar’s proposal concerning recognition of the Armenian Genocide. However, the measure still required approval by the Knesset, Israel’s parliament.

SyriacPress reported on 14 July that the planned parliamentary vote had been postponed ahead of the summer recess and Israel’s 27 October elections, leaving the Cabinet decision without the force of formal parliamentary recognition. The delay renewed questions about the influence of regional diplomatic considerations on the process. 

From Political Declarations to Institutional Recognition

Beyond an official declaration, Shay Gal proposed a broader framework intended to make recognition permanent. He called for parliamentary resolutions, the inclusion of the genocides in educational curricula, national commemorations, and the incorporation of historical recognition into Israel’s diplomatic policy. He also advocated cooperation between Israel, Greece, Armenia and representatives of the Syriac community to preserve historical documentation, collect testimonies and counter genocide denial.

Such measures would prevent recognition from becoming dependent on the political priorities of an individual government or the changing state of diplomatic relations.

Gal also distinguished between the responsibility of the Turkish state to acknowledge historical events and the personal responsibility of Turkish citizens today. He maintained that present generations should not inherit individual guilt for crimes committed by previous generations, while insisting that this should not absolve the state of its historical responsibilities. 

A Broader Campaign for Historical Justice 

For the Syriac (Aramean-Assyrian-Chaldean) people, Gal’s latest remarks represent another intervention in an increasingly visible international campaign to secure recognition of the Sayfo, alongside the Armenian and Greek genocides. For the Pontic Greeks, Armenians, and Syriacs, recognition is not simply for another political statement. It is for their history, suffering, and collective memory to be acknowledged as part of the historical record. 

https://syriacpress.com/blog/2026/11/21/israeli-strategic-analyst-shay-gal-calls-on-the-state-of-israel-to-recognize-the-genocides-of-syriacs-pontic-greeks-and-armenians/

—

Kalantarian Kevo:
Related Post