US State Department Report on International Religious Freedom addresses issue of Armenian spiritual heritage in territories that came under control of Azerbaijan

ARMINFO
Armenia – June 3 2022
Marianna Mkrtchyan

ArmInfo. A September Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe resolution on the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict cited the “catastrophic impact” of the  long-running conflict “on the cultural heritage and property of the  region, for which both Armenia and Azerbaijan have a responsibility.”  This is stated in the US State Department annual Report on  International Religious Freedom: Armenia.

The report notes, “The constitution states that everyone has freedom  of thought, conscience, and religion.  It recognizes the Armenian  Apostolic Church (AAC) as the national church and preserver of  national identity but also establishes separation of religious  organizations and the state.  The law prohibits, but does not define,  proselytism, which may be interpreted as forced conversion.”

According to the report, “The trial continued of a prominent Baha’i  lawyer, Edward Manasyan, charged in 2017 with organizing illegal  immigration; Baha’i community members said they believed the charges  were brought because of his religion.  The country’s highest court of  appeal, the Court of Cassation, rejected a Baha’i appeal alleging the  government had illegally wiretapped the group and used the  information gathered to prosecute Manasyan.  Yezidi human rights  activist Sashik Sultanyan was indicted on charges of “inciting  hatred” based on off-the-record comments he made to a journalist  criticizing the treatment of Yezidis in the country that were  surreptitiously recorded and posted online by the journalist.   Sultanyan’s prosecution drew strong criticism from international  human rights groups. 

 In February, the government announced it planned to remove a course  on the history of the Armenian Church from the mandatory school  curriculum as part of a broader educational reform, generating  significant public debate.  A September Parliamentary Assembly of the  Council of Europe resolution on the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict cited  the “catastrophic impact” of the long-running conflict “on the  cultural heritage and property of the region, for which both Armenia  and Azerbaijan have a responsibility.” Representatives of some  religious minorities, such as the Seventh-day Adventists and several  evangelical groups, as well as the Jehovah’s Witnesses, reported that  public attitudes towards them had generally improved compared with  the previous year and reported little or no negative content in the  media during the year.  Anonymous social media users, however,  continued to target the evangelical Word of Life Church with online  hate speech and harassment,” the report reads.

” Some members of the Jewish community and civil society members  reported that antisemitism, including negative speech by members of  the public and vandalism, increased after Azerbaijan used  Israeli-supplied weapons during intensive fighting in the  Nagorno-Karabakh conflict in the fall of 2020.  During June  parliamentary elections, an opposition figure who had never held  elected office criticized the Word of Life Church and Jehovah’s  Witnesses, referring to them as “sects,” a term these religious  groups did not use to describe themselves and which was generally  perceived as pejorative.  Human rights groups stated that verbal  targeting of religious minorities, both on and offline, decreased  during the year, as the individuals who had previously targeted  religious groups largely pivoted to discussing the aftermath of fall  2020 fighting and COVID-19.  On February 12, the Holocaust and  Genocide Memorial was vandalized for the third time since the 2020  fighting.  Representatives of minority religious groups stated that  societal and family pressure remained a major deterrent for ethnic  Armenians to practice a religion other than the Armenian Apostolic  faith.  The U.S. Ambassador and other embassy officials continued to  promote religious tolerance, respect for religious minorities, and  interfaith dialogue during meetings with government officials.   Embassy representatives raised with government officials and members  of parliament the cases of criminal prosecution of Yezidi and Baha’i  leaders and monitored their trials.  The Ambassador and other embassy  officials regularly consulted with religious groups, including the  AAC, evangelical Christians and other Protestants, Jehovah’s  Witnesses, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (Church of  Jesus Christ), Yezidis, the Jewish community, Apostolic Assyrians,  Pentecostals, and Baha’is, and individual members of the Muslim  community, to discuss the state of religious freedom in the country.   Embassy officials engaged government officials and civil society  representatives to discuss the impact of the Nagorno-Karabakh  conflict on religious group

Yerevan Municipality lost in court to businessman Samvel Aleksanyan

ARMINFO
Armenia – June 3 2022
Naira Badalian

ArmInfo.Yerevan Municipality lost in court to Armenian businessman Samvel Aleksanyan regarding the construction of his building on the municipal territory, Mayor  Hrachya Sargsyan told reporters on June 3.

“The court ordered the Yerevan Municipality to legalize the  construction,” he said.

As Sargsyan explained, the city administration lost the case in all  court instances and was forced to legalize the building.

It should be recalled that in September 2020, former MP, businessman  Samvel Aleksanyan filed a lawsuit against the Yerevan Municipality  because of the decision taken by Mayor Hayk Marutyan. The businessman  applied to the Administrative Court with a demand to invalidate the  decision No. 2898-A adopted on September 16, 2020 by the Mayor of  Yerevan.

According to this decision, Samvel Aleksanyan carried out the  construction (in 2015) of illegal buildings- constructions on a land  plot owned by the state, at the address of Shrjanain St 102/4,  Malatia-Sebastia administrative district, in connection with which  administrative proceedings were initiated at the mayor’s office.  Thus, Yerevan Mayor Hayk Marutyan decided not to legalize the  unauthorized buildings and structures at the specified address. In  addition, he instructed the head of the Malatia-Sebastia  administrative region, with the support of the Department of Urban  Planning and Land Control and the public order service, to dismantle  these unauthorized buildings and free the state-owned land from  illegal possession. 

Situation in Karabakh conflict zone to be on agenda of talks of Russian FM in Turkey

ARMINFO
Armenia – June 3 2022
Marianna Mkrtchyan

ArmInfo. The situation in the zone of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict will be on the agenda of the talks of Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov in Turkey. Official  representative of the Russian Foreign Ministry, Maria Zakharova,  announced this on June 3 during a weekly briefing.

She noted that on June 8 Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov will  pay a working visit to Ankara for talks with Turkish Foreign Minister  Mevlut Cavusoglu.

“It is planned to discuss the state of and prospects for deepening  bilateral cooperation on a wide range of issues of trade and economic  cooperation in the context of the application of illegitimate  sanctions against Russia by the West.

There will also be an exchange of views on topical issues of the  regional and international agenda, primarily on the current situation  in Ukraine, as well as in the Syrian, Libyan and Nagorno-Karabakh  settlement, on the situation in the Balkans, Afghanistan, Central  Asia,” she said. 

Yuri Khachaturov: We do not want war, but we want to be respected

ARMINFO
Armenia – June 3 2022
Marianna Mkrtchyan

ArmInfo. We don’t want war, but we want to be respected. Former Secretary General of the CSTO, former Chief of the General Staff of Armenia, Colonel-General Yuri  Khachaturov stated from the rostrum on France Square in Yerevan.

At the beginning of his speech, the Armenian general spoke about the  background of the resignation of first President of Armenia Levon  Ter-Petrosyan on February 3, 1998, when Prime Minister Robert  Kocharyan, Minister of Defense Vazgen Sargsyan and Minister of  Internal Affairs and National Security Serzh Sargsyan did not support  Ter-Petrosyan’s proposed plan for settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh  conflict, which included the demilitarization of the conflict zone  and the return to Azerbaijan of a number of settlements taken during  the hostilities of 1992-1994.

“Then they said that people will come to power, whose coming will  cause bloodshed, that there would be a war. And what really happened?  We lived in peace for 20 years, lived like winners. We were proud of  our army and state. There was no war. They said we want war, but we  didn’t want war. Even now they say we want war, but we don’t want  war, we want to be respected,” he said.

At the same time, Khachaturov expressed bewilderment at the behavior  of officials and parliamentarians from the ruling power when they are  asked a question about the future of Artsakh. “I don’t understand  these ministers and the rest officials, they are asked a simple  question. Are you in favor of Artsakh being part of Azerbaijan? They  say we cannot answer. I understand that they can do nothing to  prevent Artsakh from becoming part of Azerbaijan, but at least say  that you do not want NKR to be part of Azerbaijan. Can’t you do that,  aren’t you Armenian? “Then who are you?” He asked.

Khachaturov also bowed before the parents of the soldiers who died  for the homeland, calling them saints, while urging them not to  condemn those who did not come to the square. According to him, each  of them experiences the pain of loss in their own way.

Referring to the work of law enforcement officers, the general  expressed bewilderment and indignation at the behavior of people in  uniform. He shamed all those law enforcement officers who use  disproportionate brute force against peaceful demonstrators,  especially women.

“When did we get to the point where the police drag women by the  hair, kick them in the stomach? Guys, behave more modestly, remember  that you are all in the field of view of our citizens,” he said,  adding that they would not succumb to the provocations of law  enforcement officers and will not beat law enforcement officers in  response. According to him, the authorities are just waiting for  this.  “Don’t wait, we won’t beat you. Viva Armenia, Viva Artsakh,  Viva the Armenian people,” Khachaturov summed up.

It should be noted that a rally of the opposition Resistance Movement  is taking place in France Square.  It should also be noted that the  Armenian parliament today at 16:00 convened an extraordinary meeting  at the request of the “Hayastan” and “I have the honor” opposition  factions. On the agenda is the discussion and adoption of a statement  on Armenian-Turkish and Armenian-Azerbaijani relations. The meeting  did not take place due to the lack of a quorum. Only 33 opposition  MPs attended the meeting, while 54 MPs  were needed for a quorum.   The ruling Civil Contract faction announced last week that it would  not take part in an extraordinary meeting of the Armenian parliament,  initiated by the “Hayastan” and “I have the honor” opposition blocs  and scheduled for June 3. The Civil Contract stated that they would  not succumb to political blackmail and would not take part in an  extraordinary meeting, but would continue to protect the rights of  Artsakh and its population at all levels and platforms.

Human rights activist: There is not a single shot of protesters using violence against policemen

NEWS.am
Armenia – June 3 2022

There is not a single frame of protesters using violence against police officers, Human rights activist, former Ombudsman of Artsakh Ruben Melikyan wrote on his Facebook page.

His statement comes as follows:

  • THERE IS NO SINGLE footage of protesters using violence against police officers.
  • There are LOTS of footage of cops using violence against protesters.
  • There is footage showing how policemen throw a flash and sound grenade at other policemen.

And under these conditions:

  1. a criminal case is initiated under article 225: riots
  2. 12 (or more) protesters are detained, some of whom were subjected to severe violence
  3. not one of the police officers who committed the atrocities was not only detained, but no one even said anything about it …

P.S.: These are “mathematical truths”, and all those who claim otherwise are “experts in all matters” serving Turkish interests,” the human rights activist wrote.

Filmmaker travels back to her roots in telling Armenian story through ‘Hidden Map’

June 1 2022
Ani Hovannisian in the hidden chapel of Hokeats Armenian Monastery, Monastery of the Spirits, outside the city of Van. (Courtesy of Steven Sim)

Ani Hovannisian is always on a journey to find the truth.

In each project, she searches for it.

With her latest, “The Hidden Map,” she journeyed to modern-day Turkey to unravel some of her family’s history.

Her family story starts with the Armenian genocide, which began in 1915. During a short time, 1.5 million Armenians were killed or expelled by Ottoman Turks.

Those that were affected include Hovannisian’s family.

Ani Hovannisian is always on a journey to find the truth.

In each project, she searches for it.

With her latest, “The Hidden Map,” she journeyed to modern-day Turkey to unravel some of her family’s history.

Her family story starts with the Armenian genocide, which began in 1915. During a short time, 1.5 million Armenians were killed or expelled by Ottoman Turks.

Those that were affected include Hovannisian’s family.

Baydzar and Sarkis, among the last full Armenians in Diyarbakir, Turkey. (Courtesy of Ani Hovannisian)

“The Hidden Map” will air at 7 p.m. Sunday, June 5 and 10:30 a.m. on June 12 on World channel 5.4. It will air on New Mexico PBS at 9 p.m. Tuesday, June 7, on channel 5.1.

Hovannisian wanted to tackle the story because it’s often one that is not remembered in history.

She’s also thrilled that PBS is taking a chance to give her the platform to share the story.

“It’s not a cinematic masterpiece, but it goes deep,” she says. “The Armenian story has been hidden and forgotten by Turkey intentionally. My grandparents were exiled from that land.”

Hovannisian had traveled with her father to the area.

advertisement


“I had to face the unfathomable loss and the story of my grandparents growing up,” she says. “I can’t tell you how filling that is. Before I worked on this project I was in nonfiction programming. I always knew that I would one day tell the Armenian story in a grand way. It’s not only a genocide history lesson. It’s much bigger than that.”

As she traveled back she met Sim, who lived in an old Armenian home.

This is where she was able to uncover more stories.

“That was the turning point,” she says of meeting Sim. “Here was this guy who spent 30 years of his life finding and discovering our Armenian past. He’s kind of a loner and he cares about the stories. To see these relics that he had was evidence of the genocide.”

Hovannisian wanted to bring attention to not only the Armenian genocide but to the many crimes against humanity that are allowed to happen without any accountability.

She wanted to tell the stories of the silenced and forgotten voices within this tragedy.

advertisement


“For me to know that there are going to be 1,000 airings of ‘The Hidden Map’ across the country makes my heart beat fast,” she says. “The story has been forgotten for 100 years. These stories have been buried beneath the soil and going to be unearthed. What’s important is that this story is a continuing story. It’s a human story. It’s the story of every people’s struggle and how critical it is for the truth to be known. Every person has a history that is complicated. This is a jumping off point for others to learn about a piece of history that is always trying to be erased.”

https://www.abqjournal.com/2504219/filmmaker-travels-back-to-her-roots-in-telling-armenian-story-through.html

Iran attaches importance to neighborliness with Armenia

Mehr News Agency, Iran
June 2 2022

TEHRAN, Jun. 02 (MNA) – Iranian President Ebrahim Raeisi told his Armenian counterpart that Iran considers Armenia a friendly and close country and attaches importance to its neighborliness with Armenia.

Speaking in a phone call with the President of Armenia Vahagn Khachaturyan on Thursday, Raeisi described Iran-Armenia’s continuous consultations as a sign of the importance and depth of friendly relations between the two countries.

“Protecting the geopolitics of the region, including international borders, respecting the national sovereignty of countries, and strengthening communication infrastructure between the regions is the principle of the Islamic Republic of Iran,” the Iranian president added.

He also called for expanding Iran-Armenia’s bilateral and multilateral cooperation in the fields of energy and transportation, saying that these ties will strengthen peace, stability and economic and trade prosperity in the region.

“Iran supports the progress in the peace talks between Armenia and the Republic of Azerbaijan,” he also pointed out, expressing hope that that the remaining issues in this regard will be resolved peacefully and in accordance with the principles of international law and respecting the sovereignty and territorial integrity of the two countries.

President of Armenia, for his part, presented a report on the implemented agreements and appreciated the principled positions of the Islamic Republic of Iran in the developments in the region, describing Iran’s role in the region as important and effective.

Expressing his country’s interest in expanding economic, trade, political, and cultural cooperation with Iran, Khachaturyan said that the continuous holding of a joint commission on economic cooperation between the two countries will definitely facilitate and accelerate the expanding process of relations between Iran and Armenia.

He also welcomed the holding of the 3+3 summit in Tehran as soon as possible.

MP

Armenia supports Saudi bid to host World Expo 2030

Saudi Gazette – Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
June 2 2022
Ararat Mirzoyan and Adel Al-Jubeir

RIYADH — Minister of State for Foreign Affairs, Cabinet Member and Climate Affairs Envoy Adel Al-Jubeir made a phone call late on Wednesday evening to the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Armenia Ararat Mirzoyan.

During the call, they discussed relations between the two countries.

The Armenian Minister of Foreign Affairs expressed his country’s support for Saudi Arabia’s hosting of the World Expo 2030.

For his part, Minister Al-Jubeir expressed the Kingdom’s thanks to Armenia for supporting the Saudi bid. — SPA

British Embassy Yerevan celebrates Platinum Jubilee of Her Majesty The Queen

    June 2 2022

The British Embassy holds event to mark the 96th birthday and the Platinum Jubilee of Her Majesty The Queen.

Military spending of Armenia and Azerbaijan – in numbers


June 2 2022


  • JAMnews

Military spending of Armenia and Azerbaijan

Armenia is actively discussing the country’s military spending and compares it with Azerbaijan’s military budget. The FIP.am “Fact investigation platform” reports that in 2020, Armenia was the second most militarized country in the world and the first in the South Caucasus. In 2021, Armenia became the fifth, and Azerbaijan – the third. However, the platform notes that it is necessary to take into account a significant disproportion between the “absolute values of the numbers”, that is, the real costs.

For example, 17% of the budget allocated by Armenia on defence needs in 2020 is a much more modest amount than the 13% spent by Azerbaijan due to the difference between the budgets of the countries.

FIP.am pays special attention to facts and figures since “Armenia’s military spending is often a subject of numerous manipulations and speculations”.

“Fact Investigation Platform” positions itself as an independent media outlet. The goal of FIP.am is “ the disclosure of inaccurate information published by officials, official bodies and the media and preventing the spread of disinformation”.


  • Military experts on Karabakh – turning points, preparedness and drones
  • Opinion from Baku: Will Turkey open a military base in Azerbaijan?
  • My father burned alive after tank fire” – Mariupol resident recalls life under Russian occupation

Both Armenia and Azerbaijan allocate relatively significant portions of the state budget for military and defense expenditures, being among the most militarized countries in the world. According to the Global Militarization Index, in 2020 Armenia was the second most militarized state in the world and the first in the South Caucasus. According to the indicators of 2021, Armenia ranked fifth in the world, while Azerbaijan ranked third, following Israel and Oman.

The main source of information on countries’ military expenditures is the relevant allocations from the state budget. The main source of information on countries’ military expenditures is the relevant allocations from the state budget. In the case of Armenia, these means are allocated to the Ministry of Defense. Azerbaijan allocates funds for military expenditures to the Ministry of Defense, the State Border Guard Service, the State Security Service and the Foreign Intelligence Service.

The main sources of information about arms sales and their prices are specialized organizations, in particular the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI). However, the data are not complete․

Many military transactions and their values can be kept secret for a variety of reasons.

“If we define the borders, then what status of NK can we talk about?” – Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev stated that the conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh has been resolved

After the second Nagorno Karabakh war, Azerbaijan increased the country’s military budget by about 20%, from $ 2․2 billion to $ 2.6 billion annually for 2021 and 2022.

Armenia significantly increased its military spending after the 2018 revolution, reaching about 5% of GDP, surpassing Azerbaijan in terms of the ratio.

In 2021, Armenia allocated about $ 600 million from the state budget to the Ministry of Defense, and in 2022, it increased military spending by more than 10%, reaching $ 750 million.

In 2021, Armenia’s military spending amounted to 4․4% of GDP, and that of Azerbaijan amounted to 5․3%.

After the first Nagorno Karabakh war, since 1995, Armenia has allocated about $ 9 billion for military and defense expenditures. Azerbaijan’s military expenditures for the same period are about 5 times higher.

Despite the significant disproportion in the absolute values of the numbers, in 2020 Armenia allocated 17% of the budget for military expenditures, while Azerbaijan’s military spending was 13%.

Although the two countries are leaders in the world in terms of relative military spending, Azerbaijan’s rapid economic growth has greatly influenced its military procurement policy. Thus, Azerbaijan significantly increased its military spending in 2006, after the launch of the famous Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline, as well as in the years before the April 2016 war. It is also noteworthy that in 2020, just before the war, Azerbaijan again increased military spending by about 17%, while Armenia reduced it by 2.6%.

The Kremlin is trying to destabilize Armenia and Azerbaijan and believes that without it, the definition of borders between the two Caucasian countries is impossible, but Azerbaijani experts think otherwise

As we have already mentioned, the only official source on Armenia’s military expenditures is the state budget, broken down into allocations in the main directions. The growth of military spending in Armenia was mainly comparable to the economic growth, although sometimes it also exceeded the GDP growth rates.

Thus, during the last 10 years (2012-2021), the military budget of Armenia has doubled, increasing from AMD 155 billion to about AMD 312 billion. During the same period, the GDP increased from AMD 4.266 trillion to AMD 6.983 trillion, increasing by 1.6 times. Approximately AMD 345 billion were allocated to the Ministry of Defense from the 2022 budget.

Allocations to the Ministry of Defense in the 2018 budget increased significantly (from AMD 209 billion to 247 billion), of which AMD 238 billion were envisaged for meeting military needs.

It can be seen from the infographic that the growth of Armenia’s military spending mainly coincides with the general growth, and, as a rule, the allocations fluctuated in the range of 3-4% of GDP. It is noteworthy that Armenia has reduced allocations to the Ministry of Defense after the four-day war in 2016 and the 44-day war in 2020.

The data on the state budget and military expenditures are incomplete for the period of the tenure of the first president Levon Ter-Petrosyan, when Armenia was at war with Azerbaijan and was in the crisis of the post-Soviet period. Nevertheless, during these years Armenia had acquired a large number of weapons from Russia, which had a decisive impact on the course of the war.

According to the state budget information, during the rule of the second president of the republic Robert Kocharyan (1998-2008), a total of AMD 639 billion was allocated to the Ministry of Defense.

During the decade of Serzh Sargsyan’s rule (including 2018), Armenia allocated AMD 1 trillion 828 billion to the Ministry of Defense, and in the four years following the Velvet Revolution, during Nikol Pashinyan’s rule (2019, 2020, 2021 and 2022), AMD 1 trillion 272 billion were allocated.

However, it should be noted again that the country’s GDP has increased significantly compared to the 2000s, which is reflected in the military spending indicators.

The main, if not the only, major partner in arms trade with Armenia is Russia. Armenia receives more than 95% of its weapons from Russia.

Years ago the situation was the same in the case of Azerbaijan, but in the last decade the country has diversified its arms supply, procuring a huge amount of weapons and ammunition from Israel, Turkey, Ukraine and other countries.

According to SIPRI, Russia accounted for only 31% of Azerbaijan’s military procurements in 2015-2019, compared to 80% in 2009-2013. During the recent CSTO conference on May 16, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan addressed the issue of selling arms to Azerbaijan by Russia and other CSTO member states.

In response to such criticism in the past, Russian President Vladimir Putin described Russia-Azerbaijan military cooperation as “just business.”

During the 2020 war, the Fact Investigation Platform referred to the main suppliers of weapons to Azerbaijan and the main types of weapons acquired.

Among the countries supplying arms or other military equipment to Azerbaijan are the well-known suppliers, as well as other countries of the European Union and Europe, which have sold both arms and technology to Azerbaijan in different years.

Since then, Azerbaijan has not not made new statements about the acquisition of new weapons.

However, Armenia did announce earlier this year about the procurement of new transport helicopters from Russia, the transaction value of which is still unknown. The last big deal was made by Armenia in 2019, when it acquired four SU-30 fighter jets worth about $ 120 million.

https://jam-news.net/military-spending-of-armenia-and-azerbaijan-in-numbers/