NSS Armenia files motion to court for prolonging Gagik Khachatryan’s pre-trial detention

Save

Share

 20:38,

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 21, ARMENPRESS. The National Security Service of Armenia has filed a motion to the court for prolonging the pre-trial detention of former Minister of Finance, former chairman of the State Revenue Committee Gagik Khachatryan by 2 months, the press service of the NSS Armenia told ARMENPRESS.

Khachatryan is accused of organizing misappropriation of particularly large amount of sum and has been in detention for nearly 6 months. He denies any wrongdoing.

Edited and translated by Tigran Sirekanyan

Armenian deputy PM participates in EEC Council session in Moscow

Save

Share

 17:01,

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 21, ARMENPRESS. Deputy Prime Minister of Armenia Mher Grigoryan is taking part in the session of the Council of the Eurasian Economic Commission (EEC) in Moscow, the deputy PM’s Office told Armenpress.

The session launched with the discussion of the process of the EAEU 2020-2025 strategy development and issues over it which were not agreed upon. Thereafter, the session participants discussed the remaining issues on the agenda.

The session will also touch upon the issues relating to setting customs duties for separate goods.

Edited and translated by Aneta Harutyunyan




PM Pashinyan sends condolence message to Angela Merkel

Save

Share

 20:39,

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 21, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan sent a condolence message to German Chancellor Angela Merkel on the occasion of the tragic incident in Hanau town.

As ARMENPRESS was informed from the Office of the Prime Minister of Armenia, the message runs as follows,

“Honorable Mrs. Merkel,

It was with deep grief that I learned about the tragedy in Hanau town.

On behalf of the Armenian people and personally me I offer condolences and solidarity with you and the friendly people of Germany. I wish patience and spiritual strength to the relatives and friends of the victims, and speedy recovery to the injured”.

Nine people are dead following two shootings at shisha bars in the western German town of Hanau. Federal prosecutors are treating it as an act of terrorism. Turkish authorities say a number of those killed were of Turkish origin. Chancellor Angela Merkel said there are signs the shooter had racist motives.

Police launched an hours-long manhunt for the attacker – at first suspecting there was more than one shooter.

With the help of security cameras and witnesses, officers eventually identified the suspect and stormed his home near the Arena Cafe & Bar. They found him dead inside, near the body of his 72-year-old mother.

Edited and translated by Tigran Sirekanyan

Asbarez: L.A., Burbank, Glendale City Officials Endorse Elen Asatryan for Democratic County Central Committee


Elen Asatryan

LOS ANGELES—Having witnessed first-hand the tenacity and passion Elen Asatryan possesses for civic engagement and the Democratic Party, Los Angeles Councilmembers Paul Krekorian and David Ryu, Burbank Councilmembers Bob Frutos and Jess Talamantes, Burbank City Clerk Zizette Mullins, and former Glendale City Mayor and current City Treasurer Rafi Manoukian, announced their respective endorsements for Elen’s momentous grassroots campaign to secure a seat on the Democratic County Central Committee.

The city officials have worked closely alongside Elen during her two-decade-long political activism and advocacy career.

“I have known Elen for over 20 years, since she was just 16-years-old. Not only is Elen a champion for the Democratic Party, but she has also led one of the largest advocacy organizations in our community. Elen is an honest and resilient activist who fights for Democratic values, proper representation, and civil and human rights. She has also led many successful campaigns and community initiatives, and she will be a valued addition to the County Central Committee,” stated Los Angeles City Councilmember Paul Krekorian.

“I’m grateful for the overwhelming support received by organizations and community leaders with whom I have a shared vision for governing that includes an emphasis on encouraging public participation in the civic process, government transparency, and ensuring that underrepresented communities have a seat at the table,” said Asatryan. “Volunteering, and then eventually working, on both Councilmember Krekorian and former Glendale Mayor Manoukian’s campaigns sparked my passion for politics and public service early on. These endorsements are both humbling and a reminder of the values I hope to bring to LACDP,” she added.

As a first-generation immigrant, Elen, with her family, moved from Armenia to Glendale at the age of 10, where she then attended Columbus Elementary School, Toll Middle School, and Hoover High School. Elen was a 15-year-old when she volunteered on her first political campaign, and she never stopped championing for causes or candidates from that point forward. Elen went on to graduate from the University of California Los Angeles, where she studied Political Science with concentrations in American Politics and International Relations then serving as Executive Director of advocacy organizations overseeing 19 western U.S. states. In 2017, she founded The Stark Group—a consulting firm specializing in public affairs, nonprofits, and political campaigns.

Dedicated to empowering youth, Elen founded and led internship and mentorship programs for high school and college students, the first Armenian-American Sacramento based Walter and Laurel Karabian public policy fellowship program for recent college graduates. She also spearheaded the Path to College Program to help non-English speaking parents navigate the school system and provide a pipeline of support for students to graduate high school and complete the college admissions process successfully.

“I am excited for Elen Asatryan’s candidacy for the County Central Committee, and I am proud to endorse her. Throughout her career, Elen has invested her time and energy into empowering the community, with great results. When she is elected to the Central Committee, I am confident that Elen will continue to be a champion for social justice,” commented David Ryu, Los Angeles Councilmember District 4.

“While working for the City of Glendale and in my current role as the elected Burbank City Clerk, I have had the pleasure of working with Elen on many community projects. I found her to be very committed, dedicated, highly energetic, and always willing to go the extra mile to get the job done. I am honored to support and endorse Elen for the Democratic County Central Committee,” commented Burbank City Clerk Zizette Mullins.

In her mission to ensure that all voters, regardless of gender, race, ethnicity, and economic background have equal access to the democratic process, Elen developed and implemented voter registration and ‘Get Out the Vote’ initiatives resulting in over 50,000 newly registered voters in two years’ time in L.A. county alone and record-breaking voter turnout in some of the most heated local, state, and federal elections. Elen continues her service to voter inclusivity by serving on both the Los Angeles Voter Outreach Committee and Los Angeles City Votes Voter Outreach and Education Committee.

“Elen was fifteen 15-years-old when her dad used to drop her off at our campaign office. She worked for hours and hours almost every day and when her dad came, he would have to sit and wait outside for her to be ready to leave. She would not leave voluntarily, she had to be forced to leave so her dad could go home,” remarked former Glendale City Mayor and current City Treasurer Rafi Manoukian at a recent campaign event.

“Elen has been involved in political campaigns and the fight for minority rights, human rights, and recognition from the first day that I remember her and I believe that she will continue that. When you look at candidates and talk about elections, don’t vote for a person who makes a promise, vote for the individual based on their character. Elen is the most hardworking and dedicated individual to the Democratic ideals, and she has my confidence and support,” continued former Glendale City Mayor and current City Treasurer Rafi Manoukian.

These endorsements follow endorsements from Senator Anthony Portantino, former CA Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson, the East Area Progressive Democrats, the Armenian National Committee of America – Western Region and its local chapters Glendale, Burbank, Crescenta Valley, and Hollywood, the Southern California Armenian Democrats, the Armenian Rights Council of America, Los Angeles City College Board of Trustees President Andra Hoffman, Vice President Steve Veres, and Trustee Mike Fong, Glendale Unified School District Board of Education President Jennifer Freemon and members Shant Sahakian and Nayiri Nahabedian, Los Angeles Unified School District Board of Education Member Scott Schmerelson, Glendale Community College Board Trustee Ann Ransford and Former GCC Board of Trustees President Anita Gabrielian, Burbank Board of Education President Armond Aghakhanian and member Steve Ferguson, Burbank Teachers Association President Diana Abasta, and others. The full list of endorsements is available online. www.electelen.com/endorsements

The election for the Democratic County Central Committee will take place between February 22 and March 3 at 1,000 vote centers across L.A. County. Registered Democrats residing in State Assembly District 43, and those who have declined to state a political party but have requested a Democratic ballot, will see Asatryan’s name on their ballot.

For voters who have selected the option to vote by mail, ballots started arriving in mailboxes as of February 4. Elen Asatryan’s name may be found on page 3, 4 or 5 of the ballot.

For those not yet registered to vote, same-day voter registration is available in person at any vote center between February 22 and March 3. To register to vote, update voter information and political party preference, request a vote by mail ballot or find your nearest vote center. lavote.net

The DCCC is the official governing body of the Democratic Party in Los Angeles County. It is also the largest local Democratic Party entity in the United States, representing nearly 2.7 million Democrats in the 88 cities and the unincorporated areas of Los Angeles County – a population larger than 42 individual states.

The 43rd State Assembly District encompasses the cities of Burbank, Glendale, La Cañada Flintridge, La Crescenta-Montrose, and parts of Los Angeles including Hollywood Hills, East Hollywood, Little Armenia, Franklin Hills, Los Feliz, Silver Lake, and Atwater Village (90027, 90029, 90068 and most of 90039).

To learn more about, get involved in, and contribute to Asatryan’s campaign, visit www.electelen.com. For up to the minute updates, follow the campaign’s social media accounts on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter @ElectElen.

Asbarez: Crashing the Constitution to Crush a Court


Garen Yegparian

BY GAREN YEGPARIAN

For many months, there has been chatter in the Republic of Armenia (RoA) regarding amending its constitution. And, come to think of it, that chatter extended all the way back to when it was last reworked four-five years ago. There have been concerns all along about having a prime minister with too much power, a product of the shenanigans of the previous regime.

Things began to crystallize after Prime Minister Pashinyan’s announcement on December 30. A committee of experts was to be established. But soon, another policy target of the current regime converged – the struggle to take control of the Constitutional Court. By early February, seven of the nine member court had clearly been named as the targets of an April 5th referendum featuring only one amendment to the country’s constitution. It would force the seven out of office.

Immediately the demonization of the court, already underway, started to get louder. It was accused of putting “limits on the people’s power” and being a “terrible and direct threat to democracy”… plus, anyone opposing this process was accused of being “anti-state”! This crusade against the court has been adeptly packaged as part of the ongoing (oft-abused term) “revolution” that began in Spring, 2018 and anyone opposed to the changes became, by extension, anti-revolutionary. All of this demagoguery somehow evokes George Orwell’s “Animal Farm” for me.

This run at the Constitutional Court is also reminiscent of U.S. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s (FDR) attempt to increase the size of the U.S. Supreme Court from 9 to 16 judges and pack it with supportive appointees. He was well intentioned in that the court was obstructing efforts to lift the country out of the Great Depression. But, that would have set a bad precedent, politicizing the judicial system. He was thwarted and that helped restore the country to a course of increasingly solid rule of law.

Pashinyan and his My Step bloc had been deriding the seven, and especially the court’s current president, as corrupt. In fact, a pro-government news outlet recently reported that an investigation of that judge and his godson had been completed and made it seem like charges against them were in the making. Pursuing this kind of investigative and legal path to removing one or more corrupt judges from the Constitutional Court would have been completely reasonable, appropriate, and an enhancement of the rule of law in the RoA.

Instead, Pashinyan has opted for a route that actually undermines the rule of law. At the most obvious level, the process is unconstitutional based simply on the fact that the constitution calls for a review by the Constitutional Court of constitutional amendments prior to their being placed before the voters in a referendum. Pashinyan and the parliament, with its My Step majority, have decided to bypass this requirement. This requirement, found in Article 169 Section 2 of the RoA Constitution struck me as strange, but it is the law of the land. By circumventing it in order to consolidate power, Pashinyan and My Step are behaving much like their corrupt predecessors and others in history, worldwide, who have come to power riding a wave of popular support based on promises of a better life who are then faced with the very real and large challenge of delivering on their promises.

In this light, you can see the irony of their assertions about the seven targeted judges being holdovers from the previous regime of the Republican Party who still do the latter’s bidding! Even if this is true, and I would not be at all surprised if it is, the way to correct the problem is NOT the one chosen by Pashinyan. After all, he is just as much a holdover of a previous regime as any of the judges. Remember, he is Levon Ter Petrosian’s protégé and has some dark chapters in his civic/political/public life, too. But, he seems to have come around to a better path. Why take a step backward into the corrupt, fast-and-loose-with-the-law approach of his predecessors.

Is it not possible that even the seven judges appointed by previous regimes will now behave properly (if they weren’t before) since they are free of the pressure that those formerly in power could apply?

Is there not supposed to be a system of checks and balances among the executive, legislative, and judicial branches of government? Doesn’t this look like a power grab by the executive and legislative branches at the expense of the judicial?

Isn’t the judicial branch supposed to be the defender of the rule of law, the staid and plodding guardian of a country’s constitution and laws, even at times when citizens may be worked up over various, legitimate, issues and problems leading them to want to circumvent law and procedure to more rapidly achieve their desired goals, thus undermining the very rule of law?

Do not My Step and Pashinyan realize that using tactics which vilify one sector of society ultimately serves to divide it and runs counter to their message of national unity?

Should Pashinyan and My Step, as proponents of democracy, not WANT an opposing pole of power in government to serve as a check on them should they fall into the trap of abusing power? That can happen and has happened to even the most well intentioned of public servants.

Besides, who’s to say the judges who will replace the seven will be any better? An opposition news source reported last week that one of the two Constitutional Court judges appointed since Pashinyan/My Step came to power has not completed his duties because of travel in pursuit of personal business. As a result, the court has not delivered verdicts in a number of cases.

It is a time of peril for the RoA. If this route is taken and followed to its conclusion, the country could easily fall into the same downward spiral that followed the collapse of the Soviet Union and the country’s re-independence when the corrupt system was established under its first president’s watch. There is no doubt in my mind that given the popularity still enjoyed Pashinyan and My Step, they will succeed on April 5, setting them on a path of unchecked rule.

Let’s raise our voices in defense of the very process of positive change initiated two years ago by Pashinyan and our compatriots who took to the streets to reclaim their rights and dignity as citizens. Let’s remind the current regime of its responsibility and help it step back from the brink. Let’s make Pashinyan the Armenian FDR!

Asbarez: ACF to Honor Hovsep and Elizabeth Boyadjian at Annual Gala


Elizabeth and Hovsep Boyadjian

The Board of Directors of the Armenian Cultural Foundation announced this week that long-time community activists and benefactors Hovsep and Elizabeth Boyadjian will be honored at the organization’s annual gala. This year, the gala will be held on Sunday, March 1 at the Montage Beverly Hills, located at 225 N Canon Dr, Beverly Hills, CA 90210.

The Boyadjian’s storied activism and philanthropy spans decades in the Western Region community and extends to Armenia and Artsakh, as well as Antelias, Lebanon, the seat of the Holy See of Cilicia.

In October, His Holiness Aram I, Catholicos of the Great House of Cilicia announced the completion of months-long renovation efforts at Antelias’ St. Gregory the Illuminator Cathedral and the Catholicosate’s headquarters, made possible through the generosity of Hovsep and Elizabeth Boyadjian.

“Throughout the years, Hovsep and Elizabeth Boyadjian’s contributions to the advancement of ACF’s mission have been tremendous,” said ACF Chairman Avedik Izmirlian. “Together, the Boyadjians have had indelible impact on the ACF and we are proud to honor them.”

Hovsep Boyadjian has been active in several community organizations and institutions and has volunteered his time and services for many years. Notably, he was a member of the construction committees of the Western Prelacy and the St. Sarkis Church in Pasadena, of which he was the chair.

An active member of the Pasadena community, Hovsep Boyadjian has served on the Board of Trustees of the St. Sarkis Church and was elected to represent the church as a delegate to National Representative Assembly of the Western Prelacy.

Elizabeth Boyadjian currently serves as the secretary of the Western Prelacy Executive Council. In 2017, she represented the Prelacy at the World National Representative Assembly in Antelias.

She has been a member of the Board of Directors of the Armenian Cultural Foundation and the Armenian National Committee of America – Western Region, and has chaired the latter’s annual gala.

For the past decade, Elizabeth Boyadjian has been a driving force behind the success of the ACF’s annual galas, which have become a centerpiece event for the California Armenian-American community, raising tens of thousands of dollars to advance the ACF’s mission of contributing and strengthening educational and cultural institutions here, as well as in Armenia, Artsakh and Javakhk.

Throughout the years, the couple has contributed to the Western Prelacy, the ACF, the ANCA-WR, as well as school construction projects in Artakh. Hovsep and Elizabeth Boyadjian served as the Honorary President of Homenetmen’s 2006 Navasartian Games.

Baku Pogrom Survivor Details Horrors of Massacres in Congress


Editor’s Note: Congressional Armenian Caucus leaders joined with human rights advocates and Armenian American community leaders in a solemn remembrance of the 30th anniversary of the anti-Armenian pogroms in Baku, featuring bipartisan calls for continued U.S. humanitarian aid to Artsakh

The event featured moving keynote remarks by Anna Astvatsaturian Turcotte, who, along with her family, fled the anti-Armenian attacks in Azerbaijan’s capital, Baku, in the fall of 1989, finding safe haven in the US in 1992. An accomplished lawyer, author, and human rights advocate, Astvatsaturian Turcotte, explained, “The same anti-Armenianism that made my grandfather an orphan and that made me a refugee is alive and well today. Just as with anti-Semitism, rooting out the hatred toward Armenians cannot be done by brushing aside this history. The avoidance of calling things as they are contributes to the anti-Armenianism at the highest level of Azerbaijan’s government. These crimes continue with shooting across the Artsakh and Armenian borders at civilians.” Below is the complete text of Astvatsaturian Turcotte’s remarks

Good evening,
My name is Anna Astvatsaturian Turcotte. I am here today as an Armenian-American, an elected official, as a daughter, a wife and as a mother. But most importantly I am here today as an Armenian refugee from Baku. I am incredibly honored to be here today. This is the 3rd time I’m speaking in the heart of our democracy about my personal experience, and it never gets easier.

But I am incredibly thankful for the opportunity to speak for my community that still tries to heal, still has nightmares, and still finds itself to be the forgotten refugees from the Soviet Union during what seemed like, from west’s perspective, a positive thing – a collapse of the Eastern Block.

What makes talking about this even more difficult is that 75% of my life ago, two years of my childhood defined who I am today and now, 30 years later we are commemorating these events here today knowing full well that the conflict is ongoing, and Armenian children are still in danger of annihilation in Artsakh and in Armenia.

Three of my four grandparents were born in Armenia. After World War II they moved to Baku, Azerbaijan for work. My parents were born in Baku and so was I, along with my little brother Michael. In the last 100 years of my family’s history we survived mass atrocity in the form of genocide and crimes against humanity three times.

In January 1990 my childhood died.

30 years ago I was 11.5 years old. I remember the day we escaped to Yerevan a few weeks before the final massacre of Armenians in Azerbaijan in January, 1990.

But the events that destroyed my childhood started much earlier, in the city of Sumgait, a 30-minute drive from the capital, where innocent Armenian civilians were maimed, slaughtered, raped and set on fire. This happened in February of 1988 as a government-orchestrated attack to target ethnic Armenians that repeated few months later in mass form in the city of Kirovabad.

That event in Sumgait changed the lives of all Armenians in Azerbaijan. The unclassified recently CIA documents reveal and confirm the background and truth of these government orchestrated events.

The separate massacres might have appeared to be isolated to an outside observer, but they were waves, coming and going, building in hatred and strength, and during that entire time, we were on edge, and our communities were attacked in single-family events or in events on mass scale. We spent months hiding in our apartment, hoping that the violence against Armenians would end. But it never ended.

My father was ready to leave, despite difficulties of leaving everything behind and trying to find a place to live and permission to work in other parts of the Soviet Union. My mother didn’t believe that something horrific could happen to us in intellectual, multicultural Baku. But something happened to her one day, she came home and told us that we were leaving. We left everything behind and fled. We barely escaped.

My father travelled separately from us because he looked very Armenian and didn’t want to put us in danger. We survived. Many of my neighbors and family friends were not so lucky.

In January of 1990 my home and everything and everyone I knew were taken away from us by the last pogrom of the Armenians of Azerbaijan. The next two years we lived in horrid conditions as refugees

Many of you heard my story and many of my speeches across the country so I will try to bring it down from the historical background of my family’s 100 years of ethnic cleansing and genocide – that happened in 1915, 1918 and in 1989 to a more personal level of the people that I met across the world since my book came out and since my first public statement, here in this very building in 2012.

I have traveled extensively, representing my personal story and 350 thousands of Armenian refugees from Azerbaijan. 60,000 of them are your neighbors, your constituents, proud Americans. You will not find them being too pollical or speaking about their past. They are building their lives, putting their kids through college and trying to live a typical American life.

But everywhere I go, the story repeats itself. The trauma is compounded by denial. The trauma is compounded by continued aggression against Artsakh. The trauma of my people continues when Azerbaijan comes to our new country, US, and spreads lies about Armenians—antii-Armenianism.

It has been 30 years, yet I remember these violent days as if they happened yesterday. I can close my eyes any time and any day and anywhere in the world and be transported to my house in Baku, a few blocks away from Lenin square, and remember the smell of the sea walking the Caspian seaside boulevard.

I can count the number of olive trees in front of my house on the way to School #27.

I can also remember the utter horror of being injured by a grown Azerbaijani neighbor whose arms I scratched and hit to get away from his sweaty grip.

I was told not to tell my father then until we came to United States. My grandmother explained to me that my father would try to avenge my attempted rape or go to the policy – and we will all die, because we were Armenian.

I imagine the sweet faces of my neighbors and relatives as if I saw them yesterday.

I remember walking down the street with my face down to hide my distinct Armenian features. My father said if I was asked, to tell them I was Greek.

I remember my uncle Alexander who was badly injured trying to retrieve valuables from his apartment. He didn’t realize that it was already being looted by the Azerbaijani government thugs, ready to empty or move into tens of thousands of Armenian homes.

I remember beautiful Zhanna, who was my best friend’s mother. She died in January of 1990 at 35 years old at the hands of violent Azerbaijani thugs.

Her mother Lilya died of injuries and of a broken heart a few months later.

Her son, my best friend since age 5, Vilien, grew up with debilitating memories as an orphan in Russia. I will never see them or anyone from Baku again.

A stranger lives in my family’s house now. My neighbors were killed. My grandparents’ graves were bulldozed over, as were all Armenian graves, wiping out entire cemeteries.

Our friends and relatives are now spread across the world from the U.S. to Russia, Germany, France, Latvia, Ukraine and Armenia.

Many of these relatives are strangers now because we grew up so far away from each other and almost never get a chance to see each other.

We and our children speak different languages.

So many spirits were broken. So many lives were destroyed; the lives of 350,000 of people like me.

But here we stand as survivors, as victors. Successful in all walks of life, all professions, all locations.

Many of us have horrible memories of years living in cold and blockaded Armenia escaping with nothing, losing everything. I am constantly asked why I left Armenia. If you would see where I lived for three years during the war with no hope in sight, you would understand why my father thought his children deserved more, a better future. And he gave us that future.

Some of our refugees still struggle to find a comfortable life in Armenian and in Artsakh. Many die waiting. Artsakh, while fighting for its independence from a violent neighbor, also supports thousands of Azerbaijan’s refugees, all of whom are forgotten by the international humanitarian organizations, including the UN, because it’s a “frozen or ongoing conflict.”

It’s far from frozen, and these people still need assistance 30 years later while being shot at every day.

With all that said there is only one perpetrator responsible for this. My community agrees that Azerbaijan is to blame for its disproportionate and violent response toward its own citizens in retaliation to a legal process of Artsakh’s call toward self-determination in February of 1988.

We know that Azerbaijan got away with crimes against humanity and mass slaughter, exodus, and theft of our property, and the world, US and Europe included, generally turned a blind eye to these crimes.

As the Armenian pogroms in Azerbaijan were happening, when the Soviet Union was still intact, the some western countries, including the US adopted resolution and statements condemning these pogroms based on ethnicity.

However, the world, including US and EU, continues to turn a blind eye on these events when talking about any further development in the region.
The same anti-Armenianism that made my grandfather an orphan and that made me a refugee is alive and well today. Just as with anti-Semitism, rooting out the hatred toward Armenians cannot be done by brushing aside this history.

The avoidance of calling things as they are, contributes to the anti-Armenianism at the highest level of Azerbaijan’s government.
These crimes continue with shooting across the Artsakh and Armenian borders at civilians.

This is the same autocratic Azerbaijan that pardoned and made a hero of a convicted ax-murderers of a sleeping Armenian soldier during a NATO Partnership for Peace Program in Hungary. Azerbaijan is treated with kid gloves, yet the US State Department warns American-Armenians, even the ones that were born in US, from traveling to Azerbaijan in fear of ethnic violence against them.

This is the same Azerbaijan that commits war crimes on civilians living in Armenia during the April, 2016 war when not only Artsakh civilians were killed, but also Armenian civilians were mutilated on the border with Azerbaijan.

And the story continues. And that’s because back then in the 1980s there was no justice for the ones that died, no justice for the property we lost. No one but Armenian side remembers us during negotiation process over Artsakh. No politician dares to mention us when visiting the so-called “Democratic” Azerbaijan that recently proclaimed that ALL Armenians of the world are its enemy.

History falsification, disinformation and false propaganda realized by Azerbaijan, are points of fact within the premises of this very body. By condemning the ethnic hatred and racism and demanding Azerbaijan to assume the responsibility alone, the US will assist in curbing Azerbaijan’s genocidal rhetoric and will prevent a repetition of such events within the region.

By not funding the Azerbaijan’s military and contributing to peace building, demining for example, in Artsakh, the US will contribute to the future peaceful life of children in the region. Artakh has no humanitarian assistance to its 150,000 people, children and elderly. The frozen conflict status prevents UN from entering the region. Human Right Watch and Amnesty International do not consider it to be a priority, yet thousands of Azerbaijan born Armenians refugees live in Artakh without any aid for 30 years. They are not considered to be refugees in status, because they are technically in Azerbaijan, but would they survive if they went back to their homes in Baku?

Would I?

Back then the world turned a blind eye on us because we were nobodies, and we took care of ourselves. We scattered, trying to feed our children, learn the new language of our adoptive countries, build our own futures.

The world instead rejoiced at the collapse of the Soviet Union and not the destruction left in its dissolution.

We had nothing. But now we are here. Now we visit our state and federal capitals and remind the world who we are, and what happened to us. We are not going away. We will not allow this history, our history, and the history of Azerbaijan, to be painted over in the name of convenience.

And with that ongoing aggression and xenophobia, how does the world expect any concessions on the Armenian side over the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict? If any part of Artsakh is to be government by this xenophobic and autocratic regime you will be sending Armenians of Karabakh to the slaughter house similar to Sumgait and Kirovabad and Baku.

In closing I want to tell you how incredibly amazing my life has been despite so much loss and pain. I am in awe standing here in-front of you honoring my community. Thirty years ago I was a little dirty refugee girl and the world did not care for me. The world did not mention my loss on the news. The world did not care for the region where I was born.

Now, I am an American lawyer and elected official who travels across the world writing and speaking about what happened to my people. The strength in me comes from the sun, the water and soil of Syunik region and Nakhichevan region of Armenia where my grandparents are from, from the memory of my great grandparents who perished during the Armenian genocide, from the history of my resilient ancestors my father told us through family stories and his art.

Until the day I die I will do everything in my power to ensure my people are safe from mass slaughter, that the country of Armenia, including Artsakh, thrives, that Armenians of the world are connected by a common love and purpose to survive. I will ensure that the US and European legislators know over and over again, decade after decade if needed, that the same threat that made me a refugee and hurt my loved ones still threatens the Armenian people in Armenia and Artsakh.

After losing so much, the Armenian people from Azerbaijan stand strong. Azerbaijan wants us conveniently forgotten. You must never forget us.

We know enough from painful experience of the last 30 years that we stand alone. Finally, prove us wrong.

Thank you.

A Crisis is Brewing in Armenia


A person voting during Dec. 9 2018 election

BY VICKEN SOSIKIAN

As we speak a potentially catastrophic crisis is brewing in Armenia. In 2018, the world revered the democratic leap Armenians made through the people’s movement that ousted the old regime. The world applauded the free and fair elections that replaced the old legislative (National Assembly) and executive (government) branches with the current. Those elections resulted in a government controlled by Nikol Pashinyan and a National Assembly fully controlled by his party.

While pleased with a free and fair electoral process, many political analysts raised concerns about the two branches being controlled by one party. In that the spirit of the people’s movement was not to replace the old regime with a new one, but to eliminate the existence of omni-powerful regimes all together.

The Crisis
The government and National Assembly have called for a referendum to amend a single article (213) in the Armenian Constitution, essentially enabling them to replace the majority of sitting Constitutional Court justices with those they will appoint.

There are 2 critical problems here.
1. The referendum has been called without following due processes outlined in the Constitution (articles 168, 169). The Constitutional Law Regarding Referendums (Article 8, Part 2) as well as the Rules of Procedure of the National Assembly (Article 86) have also been violated. The process and the referendum is totally illegal.
2. In a country where one man’s party already controls the legislative and executive branches, the outright attempt to take control of the judicial branch counters the most basic democratic ideals including the need for balance of power. In fact, it violates Article 4 of the Armenian Constitution, which requires a balance of power between the three branches.

This is a crisis and its manifestation will be on the ballot April 5th.

An estimated 648,000 “yes” votes are needed for the constitutional amendment to take place.

With virtually every political group in the country urging citizens to boycott the illegal referendum, the Pashinyan camp is left alone with support from disgraced former president Levon Ter Petrosian.

Pashinyan will be the face of the “yes” campaign. Given the uphill battle he faces, he is expected to double down on his divisive rhetoric to secure the needed votes.

He has already announced that those who are against the referendum are against the state. He has already framed the referendum far from its real purpose by calling it the people’s vote in support of the 2018 revolution.

The Potential Catastrophe
Should Pashinyan secure the needed “yes” votes, he will control the appointment of the constitutional court judges. These judges are responsible for ensuring that laws passed by the National Assembly don’t violate the constitution. These judges must also review and approve the constitutionality of all treaties.

What could lie ahead? A Déjà vu of the Armenia-Turkey protocols? Artsakh concessions? Shifts in foreign policy?

What Now?
The dangers in total consolidation of power and the precedent set by circumventing the constitution is clear and present.

The people’s movement of 2018 changed a lot in Armenia, but it certainly did not do away with the most basic of democratic ideals, nor the rule of law.

Every Armenian must understand the severity of what lies ahead and do their part in ensuring democracy prevails.

RFE/RL Armenian Report – 02/21/2020

                                        Friday, 
Pashinian Demands ‘Answers’ From Council Of Europe Body
Armenia -- Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian meets with Gianni Buquicchio, 
president of the Venice Commission, Yerevan, 31Oct2018
The Venice Commission of the Council of Europe must answer “some questions” 
raised by the Armenian authorities before it can scrutinize controversial 
constitutional amendments drafted by them, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian said 
late on Thursday.
Pashinian appeared to criticize the Strasbourg-based legal watchdog as he again 
defended his drive to replace most members of Armenia’s Constitutional Court in 
an interview with Armenian Public Television. He also reiterated his claims that 
those judges remain linked to the “former corrupt authorities.”
He was asked why his administration did not send the draft amendments to the 
Venice Commission before putting them on a referendum scheduled for April 5.
“During my latest visit to Germany I had discussions regarding this situation 
with many partners and I can say that they are surprised that during that 
transformation period in Armenia such processes took place,” Pashinian replied 
in an apparent reference to equally controversial constitutional changes 
implemented by Armenia’s former leadership from 2015-2018.
“I brought our European partners’ attention to the fact that that whole process, 
which essentially was a clear case of abuse of the law relating to that 
transformation, took place under the watchful eye of the Venice Commission,” he 
went on. “And I think that before we address that issue the Venice Commission 
must answer some questions, including from our European partners.”
“We are now in discussions with European institutions to understand how to 
approach this issue,” he added without elaborating.
Venice Commission President Gianni Buquicchio has repeatedly expressed serious 
concern at the Armenian government’s “open conflict” with the Constitutional 
Court. The nine-member court’s chairman, Hrayr Tovmasian, and six other judges, 
who were installed by the former governments, have faced strong pressure from 
the current authorities to resign.
In a February 3 statement, Buquicchio reaffirmed the commission’s view that the 
high court judges must be free to decide whether to accept early retirement 
offered by the government. “I call again on all sides to exercise restraint and 
to de-escalate this worrying situation in order to ensure the normal operation 
of the constitution of Armenia,” read the statement issued following Pashinian’s 
renewed verbal attacks on Tovmasian.
The standoff has also prompted concern from the two Armenia co-rapporteurs of 
the Council of Europe’s Parliamentary Assembly (PACE). They said “political 
players” in the South Caucasus state should “refrain from actions and statements 
that could be perceived as exerting pressure on the judiciary.”
The co-rapporteurs, Andrej Sircelj and Kimmo Kiljunen, also reacted to the 
Pashinian administration’s ensuing decision to try to oust the judges through 
the referendum. In a February 6 statement, they urged the authorities in Yerevan 
to send the draft amendments to the Venice Commission for examination “as soon 
as possible.”
Representatives of the two opposition parties represented in the Armenian 
parliament similarly said that requesting a Venice Commission opinion on the 
proposed changes is essential for the legitimacy of the process. Pashinian’s 
political allies countered, however, that the authorities are not obliged to 
consult with the Council of Europe’s legal experts.
Visiting Germany last week, Pashinian met with German Chancellor Angela Merkel 
and Council of Europe Secretary General Marija Pejcinovic Buric. Merkel cited 
the Venice Commission’s role in ongoing “renewal process” in Armenia, while 
Pejcinovic Buric spoke of “concerns” about political developments in the 
country. Few other details of their talks with Pashinian were made public.
The Venice Commission has not commented on the upcoming Armenian referendum so 
far.
Constitutional Reform Panel Holds First Meeting
        • Naira Nalbandian
Armenia -- The first session of a state commission on constitutional reform, 
Yerevan, .
A newly formed government commission tasked with drafting wide-ranging 
amendments to the Armenian constitution met for the first time on Friday amid 
uncertainty about the outcome of its work.
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian announced plans to set up the commission in 
December. It was decided then that the ad hoc body will comprise 15 members, 
including Armenia’s justice minister, human rights ombudsman, a representative 
of the country’s judges, members of the three political forces represented in 
the parliament and legal scholars chosen by the Justice Ministry.
The commission’s members were appointed late last month just days before 
Pashinian’s political team unexpectedly drafted its own constitutional 
amendments and put them on a referendum slated for April 5.They call for 
replacing seven of the nine members of Armenia’s Constitutional Court locked in 
a dispute with the government.
The decision to hold the referendum raised new questions about the commission’s 
mission and time frames for the possible enactment of constitutional changes to 
be proposed by it. As recently as on January 21, Justice Minister Rustam 
Badasian said the authorities will be able to schedule a referendum on those 
changes by the end of this year.
However, Pashinian said on Thursday that the second constitutional referendum 
could be held simultaneously with Armenia’s next general elections due in 2023. 
He did not say which articles or chapters of the constitution the commission 
should concentrate on.
The commission chairman, Yeghishe Kirakosian, said after Friday’s meeting that 
the panel will come up with a package of amendments and initiate “public 
discussions” on it by September. “We don’t yet have a timetable for [what will 
happen] after that,” he told reporters.
Opposition Parties To Help ‘No’ Campaign For Armenian Referendum
        • Astghik Bedevian
Armenia -- The Armenian Revolutionary Federation holds a rally in Yerevan's 
Liberty Square, May 23, 2019.
Two major opposition parties have pledged to cooperate with a group of lawyers 
campaigning for a “no” vote in the upcoming referendum on a government proposal 
to oust most members of Armenia’s Constitutional Court.
The 61 lawyers critical of the Armenian government were officially registered on 
Tuesday as the sole “No” side in the unfolding referendum campaign.
The official status allows them to have free airtime on state television and 
appoint two of the seven members of each precinct-level election commission that 
will be formed for the April 5 vote. They will thus need to recruit over 4,000 
sympathizers ready to join those commissions, a difficult task for the mostly 
Yerevan-based lawyers.
Earlier this week, the No campaign appealed to Armenia’s four leading opposition 
parties to help fill its commission seats with their members and supporters.
All of those parties have questioned the legality of the referendum, saying that 
the court-related amendments drafted by Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian’s team 
contradict the Armenian constitution. But none of them has decided to officially 
campaign against a “Yes” vote sought by Pashinian.
According to Ruben Melikian, a “No” campaign coordinator, the opposition Bright 
Armenia (LHK) and Dashnaktsutyun parties have responded positively to the appeal.
“We need to be sure that we will have people capable of performing the duties of 
commission chair, secretary or member, and the public should be confident that 
those functions are performed by people who sincerely oppose the referendum 
process,” Melikian told RFE/RL’s Armenian service on Friday.
LHK and Dashnaktsutyun representatives confirmed that they will allow and 
encourage members of their parties to join the commissions and monitor the 
proper conduct of the referendum.
Dashnaktsutyun’s Ishkhan Saghatelian said this is not at odds with his party’s 
calls for a boycott of the vote. He argued that Dashnaktsutyun’s objective is to 
scuttle the passage of the constitutional changes.
The two other opposition forces, the former ruling Republican Party and Gagik 
Tsarukian’s Prosperous Armenia Party, have not yet responded to the lawyers’ 
appeal.
Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2020 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
 

Tobacco importers talk consequences of Armenia’s “anti-tobacco” bill

Banks.am, Armenia
Feb 21 2020
 
 
 
21.02.2020
 
 
Banks.am has contacted several tobacco importers for comments on passage of the “anti-tobacco” bill, which took place last week, and its possible ramifications.
 
Below you can read the responses we have received from JTI Armenia (Winston, Camel, Sobranie, LD, Monte Carlo trademarks) Director Ivan Bakharev, Imperial Tobacco (Davidoff, P&S, West trademarks) Market Manager Tigran Khachatryan, and British American Tobacco (Dunhill, Kent, Pall Mall, Rothmans, Lucky Strike trademarks) Director of Legal and External Affairs Caucasus & Moldova Zviad Skhvitaridze.
 
Tigran Khachatryan, Imperial Tobacco
 
In Armenia and other countries, tobacco industry wants to operate in a predictable and stable environment, but the recent changes in legislation will limit competitive capacities of tobacco companies. In particular, they will be no longer able to make any investment aimed at supporting small and medium-size points of sale.
 
We believe that the Government of Armenia has to assess the social and economic impact of the bill. Without a hint of a doubt, this bill will lead to decrease of tax revenue from tobacco industry, create obstacles and cause losses for retail sellers.
 
Global experience proves that ban on display consistently causes increase of illegal trade, which leads to drop in legal production in Armenia.
 
We urge the government to engage in a constructive, open dialogue with tobacco companies in order to have a transparent and regulated market. We expect a constructive solution which would comply with the EAEU treaty.
 
Ivan Bakharev, JTI Armenia
 
Unfortunately draft TCL voted by parliament of Armenia contradicts the EAEU treaty, bill itself is not clearly written and provides room for wide misinterpretation. We are afraid that the application of the law will lead to a sharp increase in the volume of illicit trade and will have serious negative economic impact on retail outlets in Armenia and will be damaging for the economy. And this is when tobacco companies are amongst top largest taxpayers in the country (two major domestic producers and two major importers are in top ten).
 
Another unfortunate development is lack of predictability and consistency of the process, for us as an international company operating in Armenia this is of utmost importance and when we see that very often decisions, statements and actions made by public officials are contradictory. This sends very negative message to the business society and investors.
  
One of the most controversial issues is the provision of uniform/plain packaging. The example of Australia, which was the first country to apply uniform packaging, shows that this measure is ineffective and harmful to all stakeholders except criminal groups. Uniform packaging will not reduce the volumes of smoking, but will cause great harm to the economy.
 
Uniform packaging puts pressure on prices and limits consumers’ ability to make informed decisions and make choices. In addition, the requirement for uniform packaging is contrary to the basic principles of paragraphs 51, 52 and 53 of the Eurasian Economic Union Treaty which are binding on the member states of the Union. We firmly believe that this is unnecessary measure that will significantly damage sector in Armenia and will have severe negative effects for the economy.
 
At the same time, the ban on the display of tobacco products will have a serious impact for retail universe in Armenia. According to the most modest estimates, the stores receive from the tobacco companies an average of 8-10 billion drams annually. With the new regulation retail will be deprived from this resource. Representatives of more than 3,500 shops have written to the National Assembly about this issue, but their opinion was not taken into account.
 
We call on the Government to engage in an open dialogue with the business operators and to regulate the market in light of the principles of better regulation by the OECD. In our opinion, the regulations should be proportionate rather than one-sided and should be managed based on inclusivity and transparency. We still do hope that decision will be revisited, and sound judgment will prevail, eventually leading to the situation were both state and business are benefiting from mutual cooperation.
 
Zviad Skhvitaridze, British American Tobacco
 
We are deeply concerned with the decision of the Parliament, all not weighted and ungrounded regulations were adopted without having Regulatory Impact Assessment on board. This was instigated by so called health care NGOs which will cause considerable problems for countries economy.
 
Georgia is a vivid example where due to unfeasible regulations state budget lost more than 200m USD only in one year. We do hope room for negotiations still exists to manage smooth implementation with proper transition periods.