Archag & Anahid: Cultivating Armenian Literature In France

ARCHAG & ANAHID: CULTIVATING ARMENIAN LITERATURE IN FRANCE
By Jennifer Manoukian

ianyan magazine

Feb 7 2012

With so much attention focused on the French-Armenian community in
recent weeks, it is an excellent time to remember the role that France
once played as the center of Armenian literary and cultural activity
in the diaspora.

In the 1920s and 1930s, the capital of Western Armenian intellectual
life shifted from Constantinople to Paris. During the Ottoman period
of social reform in the mid-nineteenth century, it was common for
affluent Armenian families to send their sons-and, in very few
cases, their daughters-to Paris to finish their schooling. These
young Armenians would generally return to the Ottoman Empire after
graduating with the hope of applying their knowledge and skills to
help improve the social and political situation of their community;
nevertheless, by the turn of the century, a small, yet influential
group of around 3,000 Armenians had settled in Paris. These Armenians
were often writers and activists who, threatened by Sultan Abdul
Hamid II’s increasingly authoritarian rule, chose to seek refuge
abroad where they could express themselves more freely without fear
of imprisonment or aggressive surveillance.

Of the small community of Armenians in fin-de-siècle Paris, one of the
most notable and well-respected members was Archag Tchobanian. Born
in Constantinople in 1872, Tchobanian attended the Guetronagan
School-known for producing some of the finest Armenian literary
minds-and began writing and translating from Armenian to French at an
early age. At twenty-three, he founded the literary journal “Dzaghig”
(“Flower” in Armenian) and, soon after, left Constantinople for
Paris where he established himself as key figure in French-Armenian
intellectual life for over a quarter of a century.

Celebrated as the ambassador of Armenian letters in France, this poet,
writer, translator and editor earned the respect not only of his fellow
Armenians, but also of some of the most prominent French writers and
politicians of the time. Through his relationship with people like
Anatole France and Georges Clemenceau, Tchobanian raised awareness
about the plight of the Armenian people in the Ottoman Empire and
garnered support among the French public for their cause.

Tchobanian was however very mindful of the danger of portraying
Armenians merely as a victimized people and challenged this image
by showcasing examples of their literary and cultural heritage to a
largely unfamiliar French public; he regularly published translations
of Armenian folktales in the French literary journals, organized
cultural events-memorably inviting Gomidas to perform in Paris in
1906-and hosting conferences and lectures on Armenian history and
literature.

The French-Armenian community of the time was also greatly indebted
to Tchobanian’s efforts to resist acculturation by fostering Armenian
literary production in the diaspora. His most enduring contribution to
this effort was the creation of the literary, artistic and scientific
journal, “Anahid,” in 1898.

With this journal, Tchobanian sought to instill in Armenians admiration
for their own cultural achievements and continue the literary and
intellectual legacy of the previous generations in the diaspora. He
understood “Anahid” as a means through which to conserve, perpetuate
and reconstruct Armenian identity in exile, especially with the
expansion of the community in the 1920s.

Each issue of the journal was composed of poetry, prose, translations,
literary criticism and an eclectic mix of articles on topics ranging
from architecture to music. Although poems by well-respected figures
like Siamanto or Taniel Varoujan were published in Anahid, Tchobanian
actively sought out and published works by emerging writers as well;
some of these young minds, like Zabel Yessayan and Zareh Vorpouni,
would later become leading figures in Armenian literature.

Despite an 18 year interruption from 1911 to 1929 and a brief hiatus
during the Nazi occupation of Paris in the 1940s, Anahid provided
an outlet for the artistic expression of a diasporan people for 33
years, in a way unrivaled by any other publication. The last issue
of Anahid was published in 1949 and was soon followed by the death
of its devoted editor in 1954.

Jennifer Manoukian is a recent graduate of Rutgers University where she
received her B.A. in Middle Eastern Studies and French. Her interests
lie in Western Armenian literature and issues of identity and cultural
production in the Armenian diaspora. She also enjoys translating and
has had her translations of writer Zabel Yessayan featured in Ararat
Magazine. She can be reached at [email protected]

http://www.ianyanmag.com/2012/02/07/archag-anahid-cultivating-armenian-literature-in-france/

Bollywood Blockbusters Popular Among Students

BOLLYWOOD BLOCKBUSTERS POPULAR AMONG STUDENTS
By NADIAH JOHARI

The Statesman

Feb 8 2012
Utah

The recently aired movie “A Cinderella Story: Once Upon A Song”
featured Bollywood elements that incorporated Indian dance, music,
costumes and colors. For Yeva Muradyan, the film was part of a
Bollywood trend spreading across campus.

“It has opened new ways for me to view the world and find out ~E
other cultures can be interesting,” said Muradyan, a junior majoring
in public relations.

Muradyan, a native of Armenia, said she started watching Bollywood
movies with her mother when she was a child. She said Armenians
are familiar with the Indian culture because Bollywood movies are
common there.

She said she is interested in Indian culture and Hinduism, and watching
Bollywood movies is a way for her to feel the culture.

“It’s very unique, it’s very old, it’s something that is different,
and I find it pretty amazing … the way they dance, the way they sing,
and the way they dress,” she said. “I can’t adapt to their culture
because it’s very different from mine, but I love to watch it. I’m
fascinated with it.”

Ashwin Kumar, a graduate student studying electrical engineering,
said Bollywood is a large industry in India, and almost all Bollywood
movies are love-oriented.

“Bollywood for Indians is more like an escape,” Kumar said. “It has
a lot of dance and colors. They put in a lot of hard work into stage
performances and the music that they play.”

Pooja Kavathekar, a graduate student studying computer science, said
even though there are political differences between Inida and Pakistan,
everyone – Indian or Pakistani – comes together for Bollywood.

Bollywood creates a cultural union, Kumar said.

Kavathekar said the average budget for a Bollywood movie is $8 million
because of the jewelry, costumes, sound effects and travel. Kumar
said he thinks it’s funny that the production crew loves to shoot
outside India.

“One thing about Bollywood, which Hollywood will probably never have,
is that there is no movie (that) can (have) a bad ending,” he said.

Kumar said other differences between Hollywood and Bollywood include
musical and dancing elements. He said family values are emphasized
in Bollywood movies, too.

“I think this is one thing that Bollywood cherishes. No matter what,
basic family values, such as not going against mother and father,
having special respect for (parents) and treating women as they should
be, are given a lot of concentration, and generally movies never go
against those values,” he said.

Kumar said in old Bollywood movies profanity and kissing scenes were
not allowed. However, he said today Bollywood accepts those elements
because of Western influence.

Kavathekar said movies containing elements of nudity are controversial
in India. She said movies are evaluated before they are released and
inappropriate scenes are often removed.

Carrie Miller, a USU graduate, said she sees Bollywood as a cinematic
tradition.

She said she was first introduced to Bollywood when she and her sister
were looking for a movie in high school. She came across the movie
“Bride and Prejudice,” which featured some Bollywood actors and
actresses. Although the movie was entirely in English, there were
some Bollywood elements she said she liked.

Initially, Miller said she did not know whether she liked the movies,
but she said the more she watched the Indian films, the more she came
to enjoy them.

Miller said she likes that there’s no swearing, sex or kissing scenes
in the Bollywood movies she has seen – they seem to promote values
that correspond with her own.

“I don’t think I’ve ever seen a Bollywood movie that I would have
rated PG-13,” she said.

Miller said she has greater appreciation for other cultures as a
result of being exposed to Bollywood.

“I grew up in a small Utah town – predominantly white, predominantly
Christian,” she said. “If it weren’t for Bollywood and my interest in
other cultures, I wouldn’t really have a lot of access to other ideas.”

To sum up Bollywood in one idea it would be “controlled chaos in
wonderland,” Kumar said.

http://www.usustatesman.com/bollywood-blockbusters-popular-among-students-1.2697067

TBILISI: Azerbaijani Most Militarized Country In South Caucasus

AZERBAIJANI MOST MILITARIZED COUNTRY IN SOUTH CAUCASUS

The Messenger
Feb 8 2012
Georgia

According to a global military index, Azerbaijan is the 15th most
militarized country in the world, out of 149 ranked countries. The
index is calculated by the Bonn International Centre for Conversion,
which compares military expenditure with GDP, and studies the amount
of heavy weaponry available to a nation’s forces. The most militarized
country in the world, according to 2010 data, is Israel, followed by
Singapore, Syria, and Russia. Georgia places 54th, with Armenia at
24th, Turkey at 26th, and Iran at 32nd.

From: Baghdasarian

ISTANBUL: ‘France Turns Freedom Of Expression Into Handicap Of Expre

‘FRANCE TURNS FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION INTO HANDICAP OF EXPRESSION’

Today’s Zaman
Feb 8 2012
Turkey

Turkey’s Minister of European Union Affairs Egemen BagıÅ~_ said on
Wednesday that France has turned freedom of expression into a handicap
of expression.BagıÅ~_ said at a press conference in Brussels that
Europe has a dilemma within itself. “On one side there is an EU that
cares about freedom of expression in Turkey, and on the other side
we face EU members that turn freedom of expression into a handicap
of expression,” he said.

BagıÅ~_ slammed France, which adopted a bill that criminalizes the
denial of Armenian genocide allegations. “What France does is to carry
Europe back to the Middle Ages. An EU that is afraid of talking and
discussing does not have much to give to humanity. The EU, the most
extensive peace project in the history of humanity, must be braver.”

Speaking at a press conference after his talks in Brussels, BagıÅ~_
said that if the EU regarded freedom of expression highly, it would
then have to open two related chapters to negotiations. BagıÅ~_
criticized chapter 23 of Turkey’s EU negotiations deals with the
judiciary and fundamental rights, and chapter 24 covers justice and
freedom and security. The chapters cannot be opened because of a veto
by an EU member — the Greek Cypriot administration.

Asked what Turkey’s attitude would happen if the foreign minister of
the EU term president Greek Cypriot administration wanted to visit
Turkey for a meeting of the Turkey-EU Joint Parliamentary Commission as
a representative of the European Council in the second half of 2012,
BagıÅ~_ said: “If a comprehensive solution is reached in Cyprus,
we would be in a close working relationship with the term presidency.

If a comprehensive solution is not reached, Turkey will not sit down
at the table with a half state.”

“The Greek Cypriot foreign minister can come to Turkey as a tourist.

Turkey’s doors are open to everyone. Our businesses and shops would
be pleased to serve the Greek Cypriot foreign minister,” he added.

Meanwhile, BagıÅ~_ has asked German authorities to open up archives
about Armenians so that historians can investigate Armenian genocide
claims.

BagıÅ~_ said in an interview that appeared on Welt Online, that the
Germans and Armenians were close allies in 1915 when Armenians claim
the genocide happened. “I wonder what lies in the German archives. The
Germans should open their archives, and historians must evaluate them,”
he said.

ANKARA: Turkish PM Says Turkey, Azerbaijan Should Keep Solidarity

TURKISH PM SAYS TURKEY, AZERBAIJAN SHOULD KEEP SOLIDARITY

Anadolu Agency
Feb 8 2012
Turkey

Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has said that Turkey and
Azerbaijan should continue their solidarity.

In an interview with Azerbaijan’s national television channel ANS,
Erdogan said regarding a law adopted at French Senate which penalizes
the denial of Armenian allegations regarding 1915 incidents during
Ottoman Empire period that Azerbaijani Turks’ assistance was of great
importance in this period.

“Our Azerbaijani brothers and sisters did their best and extended a
great support both in France and Azerbaijan,” he said.

Erdogan said that Turkey would conduct different works regarding the
matter in the coming period.

Solidarity and assistance between Turkey and Azerbaijan should
continue, he said.

French Senate adopted a law which penalizes the denial of Armenian
allegations regarding 1915 incidents during Ottoman Empire period.

Under the law, people, who deny the Armenian allegations, are sentenced
to one year in prison and 45,000 euro fine. On Tuesday, 77 senators
and 65 parliamentarians in France applied to French Constitutional
Council for the annulment of the law. The Council will announce its
decision within a month.

ANKARA: Turkish Minister Slams Switzerland Over Genocide Denial Prob

TURKISH MINISTER SLAMS SWITZERLAND OVER GENOCIDE DENIAL PROBE

Anadolu Agency
Feb 7 2012
Turkey

Istanbul, 7 February: Turkey’s European Union (EU) minister and
chief negotiator said on Tuesday that incidents of 1915 were “not
a genocide.”

Egemen Bagis said Swiss prosecutor should not lose time and investigate
himself when commenting on a preliminary investigation launched
against himself by the Swiss Prosecutor’s Office.

“I said that day the incidents of 1915 were not a genocide. And, I
am repeating it here today and I am basing my words on our documents
and archives,” Bagis told reporters before flying to Brussels, Belgium.

Bagis said Turkey’s history was always cleaner than that of countries
which dared to question Turkey. “Nobody should try to give us lessons
about human rights, freedom of expression or agonies experienced in
the past,” he said.

Egemen Bagis said Turkey had no hesitations or nothing to worry about,
and Turkey considered such initiatives non-existent.

Bagis called on Germany, United States, France, Armenia, Russia and
Britain to open their archives, and asked all historians to make
academic studies on the issue.

“Then, we, the politicians, can get the reports about history and
take some steps for the future,” Bagis also said.

Bagis later left for Brussels, Belgium.

Egemen Bagis will meet European Parliament President Martin Schulz,
Socialist Group’s leader Hannes Swoboda, Turkey Rapporteur Ria
Oomen-Ruijten and members of Committee on Foreign Affairs in Brussels.

Bagis is also expected to have a meeting with European Commissioner
for enlargement Stefan Fule and European Commissioner for Competition
Joaquin Almunia.

ANKARA: Turkish Foreign Minister Comments On Swiss Genocide Probe

TURKISH FOREIGN MINISTER COMMENTS ON SWISS GENOCIDE PROBE

Anadolu Agency
Feb 7 2012
Turkey

Ankara, 7 February: Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu on
Tuesday said that Switzerland and France were two different cases.

Davutoglu’s comments came after Switzerland launched an investigation
Monday on recent remarks made by Turkish EU Minister and Chief
Negotiator Egemen Bagis on the incidents of 1915 in Switzerland.

Switzerland and France are two cases that do not resemble each other.

On one hand, there is a law supported by the political will in France
and a completed process with penalties. On the other hand, there is
an incomplete legal process in Switzerland, Davutoglu noted.

Swiss Confederation President Michelin Calmy-Rey had criticized the
handling of historic matters by politicians in a recent trip to Turkey,
Davutoglu said.

We have summoned the Swiss ambassador in Ankara to the Turkish Ministry
of Foreign Affairs (MFA) on Monday after Switzerland launched an
investigation against Egemen Bagis, Davutoglu underlined.

In a recent trip to Switzerland, Minister Bagis had said that the
incidents of 1915 were not a “genocide”.

A law in Switzerland makes it a crime to deny Armenian allegations
in regard to the incidents of 1915.

ANKARA: Turkey’S EU Minister Meets EP Head

TURKEY’S EU MINISTER MEETS EP HEAD

Anadolu Agency
Feb 7 2012
Turkey

Turkey’s top EU official meets EP chief in Brussels.

BRUSSELS Turkey’s European Union Minister and Chief Negotiator for
accession talks Egemen Bagis on Tuesday met with European Parliament
President Martin Schulz in Brussels.

Commenting on foreign parliaments’ attitude toward Armenian allegations
on the Ottoman era incidents of 1915, Bagis said politicians and
parliaments should focus on the future instead of dealing with the
past and making historical research.

“Politicians should not steel any role from historians. Our job is to
make a history which is much more peaceful, prosperous and hopeful,”
Bagis told a joint press conference with Schulz after their meeting.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

ANKARA: Turkey’s EU Minister Calls On Germany To Open Archives Regar

TURKEY’S EU MINISTER CALLS ON GERMANY TO OPEN ARCHIVES REGARDING ARMENIANS

Cumhuriyet

Feb 8 2012
Turkey

Turkey’s European Union (EU) minister and chief negotiator, Egemen
Bagis, has called on Germany to open archives regarding Armenians to
help illuminate the issue.

BERLIN- German Welt Online posted Egemen Bagis’ remarks on its web-site
and quoted the minister as saying that Germany should open its archives
regarding Armenians and help illumination of the issue.

“Germany was a strong ally of Armenians in 1915, therefore Germans
should open their archives and give documents to historians to be
examined,” Bagis said.

Bagis said all documents he had seen regarding the issue did not
define the incidents of 1915 as “genocide”, and freedom of thought
was among European values.

“There are people who see incidents of 1915 as genocide and there are
as many people as those people who do not see them as genocide. There
is not any inconvenience in expressing this view,” Bagis said.

Bagis said both nations had losses during the World War I, and almost
2.5 million Muslims and 650,000 Armenians died.

Politicians had a responsibility about the future, not the past,
he said. Bagis said politicians were elected to make laws for the
future, not to pass laws regarding 500 years before, adding that it
was nonsense for parliaments to decide how history would be written.

French Senate adopted a law which penalizes the denial of Armenian
allegations regarding 1915 incidents during Ottoman Empire period.

Under the law, people, who deny the Armenian allegations, are sentenced
to one year in prison and 45,000 euro fine. On Tuesday, 77 senators
and 65 parliamentarians in France applied to French Constitutional
Council for the annulment of the law. The Council will announce its
decision within a month.

http://en.cumhuriyet.com/?hn=313974

BAKU: EU Discusses New Ideas On Garabagh Conflict Settlement

EU DISCUSSES NEW IDEAS ON GARABAGH CONFLICT SETTLEMENT

SIA INFORMATION AGENCY
Feb 8 2012
Azerbaijan

European Union’s Special Representative for South Caucasus Philippe
Lefort has concluded his visit to Azerbaijan.

EU representative in Azerbaijan Roland Kobia informs that yesterday
Lefort held in Baku talks with the President, the Minister of Foreign
Affairs, and the Justice Minister and also had a separate block of
consultations on the issue of Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict over
Nagorno Garabagh conflict.

“Negotiations on the conflict settlement are linked with the initiative
of European Commissioner Catherine Ashton on strengthening of the EU’s
involvement in the settlement process. Lefort exchanged views with
the leadership of new ideas to strengthen the EU’s role in conflict
resolution. Our ideas are being discussed with the governments of
Azerbaijan and Armenia and are signed in a general way in strengthening
the contacts between citizens of both countries.

Currently we are not ready to disclose fully all the proposed package
of initiatives,” Kobia said.

Today, the EU is represented in the Minsk Group on conflict settlement
by France.

Aynur Mehtiyeva