WE’RE ALL ARMENIANS
By Gwynne Dyer
Egypt Today
March 7 2007
The assassination of the editor of the only Turkish-Armenian newspaper
underscores Turkey’s battle between its past and future
When they buried Hrant Dink in Istanbul at the end of January, more
than 100,000 Turks came to his funeral, filling the streets and
chanting, "We are all Armenians!" There is a war going on for the
soul of Turkey, but at least a lot of Turks are on the right side.
Dink, who called himself "an Armenian from Turkey and a good Turkish
citizen," was murdered because he insisted on talking about the great
crime that happened in the country 92 years ago: the mass murder
of most of Turkey’s Armenian population in eastern Anatolia. The
newspaper he founded and edited, a bilingual Turkish-Armenian weekly
called Agos, had only a small circulation, but his outspoken editorials
had made him one of Turkey’s most famous journalists – and a target
for assassination.
His killer, 17-year-old Ogun Samast, was a semi-educated thug from
Trabzon in the far northeast of Anatolia. He was allegedly given the
gun by a group of older ultra-nationalists including Yusuf Hayal, who
was convicted of bombing a McDonald’s restaurant in Trabzon in 2004.
But these marginal characters are just pawns in the larger war between
those who want a more democratic, more tolerant Turkey and those
who are desperately defending the power and privileges of the old
"republican" elite.
Samast shot Dink from behind in the street in front of his
newspaper office. "I feel no remorse," the killer reportedly told
investigators. "He said that Turkish blood was dirty blood." Of course,
Dink never said any such thing. What he actually said, in a newspaper
article addressed to his fellow Armenians, was that their obsession
with the massacres of 1915-17 was having "a poisonous effect on
your blood."
But it’s easy to see how a useful idiot like Samast could have believed
that Hrant Dink was an enemy of the Turks, because just over a year ago
a Turkish court took that same phrase out of context, found Dink guilty
of "insulting Turkishness" and gave him a six-month suspended sentence
under Article 301 of the criminal code. A number of other Turkish
citizens -including Nobel Prize-winning author Orhan Pamuk -have been
prosecuted under the same law for daring to discuss what happened to
the Armenians, and most of them have received death threats, too.
It really is a kind of war, and the villains of the piece are precisely
the army officers, judges and senior civil servants who were once
seen as the guardians of the republican tradition, the people who
were going to modernize and democratize Turkey.
Unfortunately, "republican" doesn’t really mean the same as
"democratic."
When Mustafa Kemal Ataturk put the Ottoman Empire out of its misery
and declared a Turkish republic in 1923, his model was the democracies
of Western Europe, but his own countrymen were still largely sunk in
feudal obscurantism. Literacy was about 20 percent, and most rural
people still saw themselves as Muslim subjects of the Caliphate (which
Ataturk abolished in the following year), not as Turkish citizens.
The forms of the Turkish republic were democratic from the start,
but for a very long time the reality was a mass of illiterate
peasants under the harsh tutelage of a narrow educated elite who were
determined to Westernize the country. The republican elite rewrote
history (including the denial of the Armenian massacres) to mold a
new Turkish national consciousness and saw religion as a retrograde
force that must be banned from politics.
The decades passed, and much of the elite’s dream came to pass.
Turkey today has a per-capita income higher than Romania or Bulgaria,
the most recent countries to join the European Union. Democracy is
a reality, and the current prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan,
leads a party whose members openly refer to themselves as "Muslim
Democrats." Under Erdogan, there has been a wave of legal and
administrative reforms designed to qualify Turkey for EU membership.
But all this threatens both the rigidly secular ideology and the
autocratic privileges of the old republican elite.
>>From their powerful positions in the army, the judiciary and the
bureaucracy, the old republican elite work to undermine the reforms and
to wreck Turkey’s chances of joining the EU. In de facto alliance with
ultra-nationalist right-wing parties that also oppose EU membership,
they incite hatred of minorities, bring false prosecutions against
the advocates of a more open and democratic Turkish society and pursue
the long-term goal of destabilizing the democratic order.
It was they who smuggled the notorious Article 301 into the Criminal
Code when it was being reformed to align Turkish law with EU standards;
they who brought false prosecutions for "insulting Turkishness" against
Hrant Dink, Orhan Pamuk, and other well-known writers, journalists and
scholars; they who spread the lies about what Dink had actually said.
It is they, not some ignorant, angry teenager, who are really
responsible for his death.
But the war is not over yet, and the good guys have not lost. Foreign
Minister Abdullah Gul vowed last November to change or abolish Article
301, and recently 100,000 Turks thronged the streets of Istanbul to
mourn the country’s best-known Armenian and condemn his murderers. et
Gwynne Dyer, an award-winning journalist and documentary maker based
in London, is a regular Egypt Today columnist.>