Goran Lennmarker report on Karabakh causes Baku discontent

GORAN LENNMARKER REPORT ON KARABAKH CAUSES BAKU DISCONTENT

Pan Armenian News
28.06.2005 07:36

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ The report on Nagorno Karabakh drawn up by Goran
Lennmarker will be heard at the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly summer
session to be held in Washington for the first time. Azeri delegation
to the OSCE PA headed by Chairman of the Standing Committee for
Economic Affairs of the Milli Mejlis Satar Safarov will also leave
for Washington to take part in the event. “We are not satisfied with
some provisions of the Lennmarker report. We will insist that the
report call Armenia an aggressor,” Satar Safarov said, reported the
Yerkir newspaper.

Freaks, frauds & Caspian adventures

The Evening Standard (London)
June 27, 2005

FREAKS, FRAUDS AND CASPIAN ADVENTURERS

THE ORIENTALIST: SOLVING THE MYSTERY OF A STRANGE AND DANGEROUS LIFE
SIMON SEBAG MONTEFIORE
BY TOM REISS
CHATTO, £16.99)

When, in 1991, I first started visiting and writing about Baku, the
turn-of-the-century oil-boom city on the Caspian Sea (now capital of
the ex-Soviet Republic of Azerbaijan), I took a novel called Ali and
Nino by a mysterious author called Kurban Said.

I went to witness the civil wars of the Soviet break-up and found a
new ‘Great Game’ for the oil riches of Baku. The beautiful novel by
Kurban Said was a poetical celebration of love and cosmopolitanism
betwixt East and West in revolutionary times: the Romeo and Juliet
of the Caspian. Azeris told me proudly that this Moslem author was
Azeri. I longed to know: who was Kurban Said? No one knew. Later,
researching my biography of Stalin, I read one of the earliest Stalin
biographies by Essad Bey. Who was Essad Bey? No one knew.

Now Tom Reiss’s work reveals Kurban Said and Essad Bey are the same
man. Since I was familiar with Baku and those books, I feared this
might be another ignorant journalistic travelogue. Far from it.
Sometimes hilarious, often heartbreaking, beautifully written,
glorying in its tolerance and curiosity, The Orientalist is an
exquisite and flamboyant biography of one of the most mysterious
literary butterflies of our time.

Featuring a bizarre cast of freaks and adventurers, it is not only
a detective-story, but also an anthropological study and a crazed
alternative history of the early 20th century.

Kurban Said and Essad Bey were really Lev Nussimbaum, spoilt son of a
Baku oil tycoon born in a palace at the centre of that city’s grand,
cultured Jewish-Russian milieu just as the 1905 Revolution shook the
Romanov Empire and unleashed vicious ethnic battles between Armenians
and Turkic Azeris.

The Russian Revolution and Civil War of 1917/18 shattered this
tolerant, rarefied world, destroying Nussimbaum’s fortune. Baku was
tossed savagely between Turks, British and Bolsheviks: the Nussimbaums
escaped via Persia and Georgia to Istanbul, thence to revolutionary
Germany. Fragile calm returned under Weimar. Here the Nussimbaums
spent their savings on Lev’s education and sank into emigre poverty
like other Russian refugees.

Then Lev converted from Judaism to Islam and his own romanticised
version of the Orient, re-making himself as Essad Bey, Muslim ‘prince’.

His vision resembled that of Disraeli in his novels: doesn’t every Jew
of Sephardic descent – Disraeli hailed from Morocco – harbour dreams of
Oriental grandeur? Essad Bey started to write a bestseller annually,
starting with Blood and Oil in the Orient. This new celebrity loved
to dress up in ‘Oriental’ costumes, play up for American journalists,
posing for photographs.

He knew everyone in Weimar Berlin and pre-Anschluss Vienna, then
married a beautiful jazz poetess, Erika Lowendahl, daughter of an
American/Czech shoe millionaire. The marriage ended in a notorious
society divorce that almost broke Essad Bey: she accused him of being
a fraud and keeping a harem! Heartbroken, he became Kurban Said and
wrote Ali and Nino.

He fled to Positano in Italy where he wanted to write Mussolini’s
biography but could only earn a living by giving his own rights to
an Austrian baroness, losing his identity as an author, until now.

‘The Moslem’ survived on the charity of a local contessa, an
Algerian-Italian drug/arms-dealer/paratrooper, and the local
pharmacist, who gave him morphine. He needed it: a rare gangrene,
Raynaud’s Syndrome, was agonisingly consuming Lev, aged 35. He died
in 1942.

No ordinary disease would do for Essad Bey, whose youth resembles
a Caspian Proust, whose adventures resemble Michael Moorcock’s Pyat
novels, whose death has something of The English Patient. Meanwhile,
everyone should read Ali and Nino, newly republished.

–Boundary_(ID_/yap/k7xEijHwmAwVe7RLA)–

BAKU: PACE to mull Garabagh conflict in September

PACE to mull Garabagh conflict in September

Assa-Irada, Azerbaijan
June 27 2005

Baku, June 23, AssA-Irada

The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) temporary
committee on Upper Garabagh conflict decided on Friday to discuss
ways of settling the conflict in Paris on September 12.

Parliamentary delegates from the conflicting sides represented at
PACE as well as representatives of the mediating OSCE Minsk Group
member states will participate in the meeting to last 24 hours,
said member of the Azeri delegation at PACE Asim Mollazada.

Mollazada said Azerbaijan has suggested that the Committee cooperate
with the Venice Commission in outlining the legal aspects of the
conflict resolution.

The Azeri delegation appealed earlier to the PACE Ministerial
Committee over the inactivity of the temporary committee. The appeal
said that although the Committee has been operating for six months,
its experts have not visited the conflict zone yet. The Azerbaijani
parliamentarians raised the issue on realization of the visits in
July at the Ministerial Committee.

The temporary committee was established on the basis of a resolution
passed by PACE in its winter session.*

Beaten ARFD Parliaetnary Canddiate Gives Details of His Beating

BEATEN ARFD PARLIAETNARY CANDDIATE GIVES DETAILS OF HIS BEATING

STEPANAKERT, JUNE 24. ARMINFO. The ARFD parliamentary candidate Pavel
Manukyan beaten June 21 in the office of NKR DM Seyran Ohanyan has
been brought from the Stepanakert military hospital to Yerevan.

Giving the details of his beating Manukyan says that June 21 afternoon
he went home and received a phone call from some unknown person. 15
minutes later a young man knocked at his door and told him that NKR
Deputy Defence Minister Samvel Karapetyan was waiting for him. He got
into a black VAZ-2108. Karapetyan and Vardan Balayan joined him at the
corner. Karapetyan asked Manukyan what he meant by saying that “the
Karabakh generals smell of clay.” Manukyan said that he meant what
really was. Then the generals asked him to specify who smelled of
clay. Manukyan called Balayan and Movses Hakopyan because they did not
care for the blood shed for Karabakh and were speaking of concessions.

Then Manukyan was taken to the headquarters of the Defence Army to the
office of NKR DM Seyran Ohanyan. Hakobyan was also there. When
Manukyan said that the power no longer belonged to the people
Karapetyan hit him in the jaw and then in the belly. He sent him to
the ground and began hitting him with legs yelling: “Tell Grisha to
give me the mill and the bakery and I will give my uniform and the
whole army!” Then Ohanyan rushed on Manukyan with swearings against
him and his party.

Ohanyan and Karapetyan beat Manukyan till he began bleeding. Then
Ohanyan ordered the others to take him out of the office saying “you
smell of shit and you are telling us something?” Seeing that Manukyan
was in a critical state Ohanyan instructed to take him to the
hospital, bring to senses and then to bring back for “further
beating.”

Manukyan asked for water. Balayan brought one but spit into the glass
before giving it to Manukyan.

“I am not going to forgive this. One can no longer forgive such
things,” says Manukyan.

Venice Commission work recorded serious progress

A1plus

| 19:14:19 | 24-06-2005 | Politics | PACE SUMMER SESSION 2005 |

VENICE COMMISSION WORK RECORDED SERIOUS PROGRESS

According to the agreements reached as a result of the meeting of the Venice
Commission working group and the Armenian delegation, up to June 7 the head
of the Armenian delegation to COE must represent to the Venice Commission
the draft Constitution which must reflect the content of the document
adopted as a result of today’s discussions.

`The document especially underlines that the final draft must preserve the
principle of checks and balances. Till July 25, 2005 the Venice Commission
must evaluate the renewed draft Constitution’, said expert of Constitutional
right Vardan Petrosyan who took part in the session. He also mentioned that
the Armenian authorities must take into account possible offers by the
Venice Commission.

The draft Constitution must be represented to the second reading of the NA
in August. The third reading must take place as soon as possible, and the
Referendum must be organized in November, 2005. `I think, today’s session of
the Venice Commission working group recorded serious progress, as the
document adopted as a result of today’s discussions outlines the principles
of solution of all the three main issues. Now the principles must be turned
into clear-cut articles’, said Mr. Pogosyan.

AGBU Armen Quebec-Alex Manoogian School Celebrates 35th Anniversary

AGBU Press Office
55 East 59th Street
New York, NY 10022-1112
Phone: 212.319.6383, x137
Fax: 212.319.6507
Email: [email protected]
Website:

PRESS RELEASE

Friday, June 24, 2005

AGBU ARMEN QUÉBEC-ALEX MANOOGIAN SCHOOL CELEBRATES 35TH ANNIVERSARY

New York, NY – Marking its 35th anniversary on June 19th, 2005, AGBU
Armen Québec-Alex Manoogian School held graduation ceremonies for over
120 kindergarten, sixth-grade elementary and eighth grade high school
students with special guests AGBU President Berge Setrakian, His
Eminence Bishop Bagrat Galstanian and AGBU Central Board Vice
President, Founder and Chairman of the School Board Dr. Arshavir
Gundjian present.

Addressing a capacity crowd of 800 community members, proud parents,
friends and supporters, Dr. Gundjian recounted the history of the
School and its many scholastic achievements, honoring dedicated staff
members and teachers who have served the School for 25 years or
more. Setrakian then paid tribute to Dr. Gundjian, whose vision and
initiative in the early ’70s along with the support of the late Alex
Manoogian built what is today one of the largest Armenian schools in
North America. Manoogian underwrote the entire cost of the
construction of the School and the surrounding complex of buildings,
which houses the AGBU Community Center and the Tekeyan Cultural
Center.

School Principal Robert Kechayan proudly presented the graduating
classes with their diplomas praising the students for their many
achievements. Setrakian commended all graduating classes and with
special parting words to the eighth grade class, urged them to carry
on the values instilled in them by the School to preserve and promote
the Armenian identity and heritage, stressing the importance of giving
back to the community.

Prior to the graduation, Setrakian attended a reception hosted by AGBU
Montréal at the Alex Manoogian Community Center visiting with the
Chapter’s Committee, members and youth.

Founded in 1970 in Montréal, Canada, AGBU Armen Québec-Alex Manoogian
School offers instruction to over 500 students from kindergarten
through eighth grade. For more information on the AGBU Armen
Québec-Alex Manoogian School, please visit

For more information on AGBU and its Schools, please visit

www.agbu.org
www.alexmanoogian.qc.ca.
www.agbu.org.

Turkish Writer Picks up German Peace Prize

Deutsche Welle, Germany
June 23 2005

Turkish Writer Picks up German Peace Prize

A literary ambassador for Turkey

Turkey’s best-selling novelist Orhan Pamuk has been awarded the
German Book Trade’s Peace Prize, reflecting a growing awareness that
many of the issues preoccupying Turkey these days have a profound
global resonance.

Just one week after demonstrations took place in Berlin against the
German parliament’s resolution in memory of the massacre of Armenians
by Turks in 1915, Germany has awarded one of its most prestigious
cultural prizes to Turkish writer Orhan Pamuk, an outspoken critic of
his country’s inability to own up to its often harrowing history.

Born in 1952, Pamuk grew up among Turkey’s secular upper classes.
After spending several years in New York, he was given a mixed
reception when he returned to Istanbul, the city where he was born.
The country’s Islamic intellectuals accused him of exploiting
religious and historical themes to pander to Western tastes. Still,
however progressive and pro-European he may be, his support of
Turkey’s westward development is far from unconditional.

Admirers see his work as a rejection of a recent intellectual
tradition that aspires to be western by ignoring the past. “If you
try to repress memories, something always comes back,” Pamuk once
said in an interview with Time magazine. “I’m what comes back.”

A love-hate relationship

According to the selection board that chose Pamuk, in novels such as
“Snow” (2002), “he follows the historical traces of the West in the
East and of the East in the West in a way no other writer does.”

He enjoys both commercial success and critical acclaim in his home
country. His 1990 novel “Kara Kitap” is widely seen as one of the
most controversial and popular readings in Turkish literature.

But despite his phenomenal popularity, Turkey itself has a love-hate
relationship with Pamuk. Nationalist groups angry at his criticism of
Turkey’s treatment of its Kurdish minority want to see his books
removed from public libraries.

And while many welcome the attention he brings Turkey as its literary
ambassador, others envy his international stature. “There is a lot of
jealousy that Orhan Pamuk has been translated into so many
languages,” said one anonymous source in an interview in the
Tagesspiegel newspaper.

Yavus Baydar from the newspaper Sabah has described the award as
“very significant for freedom of speech in Turkey.” He knows what
he’s talking about. Earlier this year, he asked Pamuk to write an
article for Sabah about South Korea. After it was published, he was
bombarded with outraged readers’ mail, accusing him of having given a
voce to a “traitor.”

A relevant writer

The prize jury’s decision continues a tradition of honoring writers
whose works have a topical significance. In 2003, US essayist Susan
Sontag (photo) received the award for her reflections on the fragile
state of post 9/11 trans-Atlantic relations. A year later, the
selection of Hungarian novelist Peter Esterhazy came shortly after
the EU’s eastwards enlargement. In 2005, the choice of Pamuk serves
as a reminder of just how much Turkey and Turkish issues factor into
Germany’s political and cultural debate.

“My novel (“Snow”) is about the inner conflicts of modern Turks,” he
told Die Zeit in April. “It’s about the contradictions between Islam
and modernism and the desire to be integrated into Europe — and the
simultaneous fear.”

In 1998, Ankara wanted to present him with Turkey’s highest cultural
accolade, the title of state artist. He rejected the honor. “For
years I have been criticizing the state for putting authors in jail,
for only trying to solve the Kurdish problem by force, and for its
narrow-minded nationalism,” said Pamuk. “I don’t know why they tried
to give me the prize.”

This time, though, Pamuk will be accepting his award — at the
Frankfurt Book Fair in October.

Minnows hoping to paint the town Red

7DAYS, United Arab Emirates
June 24 2005

Minnows hoping to paint the town Red
Written by 7DAYS | Friday, 24 June 2005

Champions League holders Liverpool will discover the first obstacle
between them and their trophy when the draw for the first qualifying
round is made today.

The Premiership side were handed a reprieve earlier this month, when
UEFA changed their own rules to allow the holders to defend their
trophy, despite the fact that Liverpool failed to qualify through the
league – finishing fifth.

The Reds, five-times European Cup winners, will need as detailed a
map of Europe as they can find with such continental luminaries as
Pyunik of Armenia, Kairat of Kazakhstan, Neftchi of Azerbaijan and
Rabotnicki of Macedonia lying in wait. They will be desperately
hoping to avoid an arduous trip to eastern Europe as they prepare for
their league campaign, and will be keeping their fingers crossed for
a tie much closer to home.

Glentoran, of Northern Ireland, are in the hat, but with the city of
Liverpool sitting on the cusp of Wales, the ludicrously named Total
Network Solutions will be an even more attractive proposition. The
town of Llansantffraid, just 100km from Liverpool, has a population
of little over 1,000 – more than 44,000 less than the capacity of
Liverpool’s Anfield stadium.

Llansantffraid only reached the League of Wales 12 years ago, but the
real catalyst in their history came when local computer firm, Total
Network Solutions, made the club an offer they couldn’t refuse and in
1997 TNS FC was born. Three years later, largely thanks to the
financial injection the sponsorship deal afforded them, TNS became
Welsh champions. Their subsequent venture into Europe was typical of
their form on the continent since.

They lost 6-2 on aggregate to Levadia Maardu, and have since suffered
6-0, 12-2, 7-0 and 4-1 aggregate defeats. Liverpool would probably
set a new Champions League scoring record if the pair were drawn
together, but the Welsh club are, all the same, dreaming of a
match-up with one of Europe’s most illustrious clubs.

`Clearly it would be a fantastic draw in terms of gate receipts and
the interest in the tie would be enormous,’ says TNS managing
director Mike Harris `If we took the game to the Millennium Stadium
(in Cardiff), we would get a bumper crowd. `It would be Liverpool’s
first game since winning the European trophy, so of course it would
be incredibly special.

`On the other hand, meeting the champions means it would be difficult
for us to proceed to the next stage, though I’m sure Liverpool would
prefer to meet us, than some of the other teams.’

Second Mobile Comm. Operator – Vivacell To Enter Market in July

SECOND MOBILE COMMUNICATION OPERATOR – VIVACELL TO ENTER ARMENIAN
MARKET ON JULY 1

YEREVAN, June 23. /ARKA/. Second mobile communication operator –
VivaCell (K-Telecom Company trademark) will enter Armenian market on
July 1, stated Hussein Rifai, member of “K-Telecom” Board at today’s
press conference in Yerevan.

He said that the company managed to create a network satisfying the
requirements of the market in record short period after receiving
mobile operator license in November 2004. He noted that the
cooperation with the Lebanese Comium company allowed achieve success,
despite numerous difficulties and obstacles the company faced.
According to him, the cooperation with various suppliers -Intracom,
AlcaTel, Axalto, Eskadenia was decisive factor for the start. “The
single measure of success will come later and will depend on all our
potential clients”, said Rifai. He noted that activities of VivaCell
will mean the start of a new period in the field of telecommunications
in Armenia. Competition in the market will not only mean mobile
communication tariff decrease, but also quality services. “Quality in
the network, quality in the customer care, quality in every single
aspect of our relation with the customer”, stated Rifai.

According to him, it is insufficient to only introduce the technology;
it needs to be adapted by using the local potential and foreign
experience.

VivaCell is the trademark of “K-Telecom” company, which was recognized
by the AR Government winner of mobile communication services tender on
Nov 4, 2004. K-Telecom is included in the Lebanese KT-Holding, which
belongs to the family of Pierre Fatush, the owner of the national
communication operator of Nagorno-Karabakh – “Karabakh-Telecom”.

Note, OTE, Greek Telecommunication Company obtained through an
international tender 90% of shares of ArmenTel Telecommunication
Company for USD 142.42 mln. Till the decision fop the Government of
Nov 4, 2004 “ArmenTel” was the monopolist in the mobile communication
market of Armenia. L.V. -0–

=?UNKNOWN?Q?Greece’s?= ostpolitik

Kathimerini, Greece
June 23 2005

Greece’s ostpolitik
By Petros Papaconstantinou

Turkey’s EU membership aspirations appear to be a main casualty of
the crisis triggered by the French and Dutch rejection by referendum
of the European Constitution. Former Commission president Romano
Prodi, who could become Italy’s prime minister after a general
election next year, has said that `the conditions now are no longer
there for Turkey’s entry in the short or medium term.’

In Germany, Angela Merkel, leader of the main opposition
conservatives, is favored to win an early general election. She has
made opposition to full Turkish membership the main platform of her
Christian Democratic Union party. Even French President Jacques
Chirac, once a warm advocate of Ankara’s bid, is now stressing the
need to define Europe’s geographical limits. Finally, it was US
Deputy Secretary of State Robert Zoellick who urged Ankara `to look
beyond the EU to a global context.’

Athens must adapt to these shifting parameters. By lifting its
objection to Turkish EU prospects, Greece materialized an
`ostpolitik’ toward Turkey – much like the West did with the former
communist countries of Eastern Europe – while not becoming the
scapegoat for other European nations who did not want Turkey in the
EU.

Greece should be wary of being too keen on backing Turkey’s bid. In
fact, too much zeal could cost Athens key continental allies and
leave it only with the gratification of British Prime Minister Tony
Blair, from whom the government can expect little, be it on the
Cyprus issue or the community budget.

Political pragmatism may advise us against imitating the French and
German parliaments, which raised the Armenian genocide issue. Yet
Merkel also said it would be disastrous if Ankara did not recognize
Cyprus before the start of membership talks, and it’s hard to see why
these comments did not resonate in Athens.